Hello,
I use Amavis as interface to Spamassassin and DSPAM, using the Spamassassin DSPAM plugin.

This setup is very useful to have a global spam protection and a fast per-user learn "on error" (DSPAM), configured through LDAP. With the LDAP ExtLookupDriver I can map all mailboxes aliases on each own account. With Spamassassin rules I can tune all different contributes to the final score. (I don't like Spamassassin learn, I prefer an "on error" approach, which is more reactive and doesn't require initial learns).

Move this design on rspamd is not easy. I think rspamd is not a magic wand to easily replace Amavis&c.

I hope Amavis could still be maintained. DSPAM is already gone. If also Amavis dies, Spamassassin will follow...

Regards
Marco


Il 08/10/2018 09:42, Tom Sommer ha scritto:

On 2018-10-08 09:37, Boris Gulay wrote:
Benny Pedersen писал 2018-10-08 00:18:
Boris Gulay skrev den 2018-10-07 21:24:
Benny Pedersen писал 2018-10-07 17:34:
Ralph Seichter skrev den 2018-10-07 14:48:
On 07.10.18 12:12, Alexander Dalloz wrote:
That's too a one man show?
See https://github.com/rspamd/rspamd/blob/master/AUTHORS.md
impresive that amavisd have less tickets
Because rspamd is actively maintained. Amavisd is not.

this does not hold water, since it could aswell be that amavisd is
more stable then rspamd

i have being using both at diffrent times, got more simple setup with
clamav-milter and spampd
Looks like it was long ago. rspamd can now also be installed as a
filter and it works "out of the box".
And one more impotent advantage of rspamd: it gives you access to
global SPAM databases like fuzzy and so on. Just take a look at
default config files. It improves spam detection of freshly installed
system.

The problem is that if you've built an entire system/cluster, UI etc. etc. based on Amavis - it's not really plug-n-play to just change to rspamd.

Also rspamd replaces spamassassin, so you are looking at a change in spamfiltering technology/ruleset/config as well.


Reply via email to