Hi Wouter, > shouldn't we re-use other efforts that have already spent time and > energy on this matter ? I mean, XDoclet is proven and is > being used by > thousands of people. > Furthermore, I think most AndroMDA users will not be so > confident in the > generated code if we would write this stuff ourselves.
Yes, you're right. It was just an idea, because the Home-, Remote-, Local- Interfaces are already generated without Xdoclet. I'm also thinking about problems regarding the development of Xdoclet. Xdoclet 2 is not final and the effort creating templates or modules for Xdoclet 2 is almost the same as creating templates for AndroMDA - they aren't reusable from the 1.2x version of Xdoclet. The next problems will occure with newer versions of Weblogic or Jboss 4.x, EJB2.1 and other features that aren't possible at the moment. Sure, AndroMDA should not create everything new, but in this case I'm just want to be sure that there will be a migration path if Xdoclet 1.2x is outdated and Xdoclet 2.x isn't ready. > What are your arguments for cutting out XDoclet ? Is there something > that cannot be done ? Even in those cases I think it would be more > interesting to apply fixes to the xdoclet codebase. For example, the newest Xdoclet 1.2 Version (from begin of may) won't work with EVERY project I've created using Xdoclet - sounds not really good. > Anyway, did you already send your templates or did you already commit > them ? Yes, Chad has got them. >Because I would like to add web-services to the > templates (I need > them in a project) Oh, cool. How Do you want to use them? I've also a big project based on webservices, in my case I've created almost for my own using Axis (no Jboss.NET) and SessionBeans exposing their remote interface - also using EJB Security for securing the webservices. Isn't all this stuff firstly useable without beeing application server dependend since EJB 2.1? Regards, Sascha ------------------------------------------------------- This SF.Net email is sponsored by the new InstallShield X. >From Windows to Linux, servers to mobile, InstallShield X is the one installation-authoring solution that does it all. Learn more and evaluate today! http://www.installshield.com/Dev2Dev/0504 _______________________________________________ Andromda-devel mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/andromda-devel
