@Michael - previously I wrote this:
> If 8366 already addresses the erratum, why do we need to mention the
erratum in 8366bis ?
So: I don't really understand why you've added to 8366bis that it closes
errata 7263.
Based on what Toerless wrote in his summary, i.e. that 8995 specifies
new inclusion requirements for the Registrar's Voucher Request which
were not yet specified in 8366 (because it was only about Vouchers), it
seems that we can use the 8366bis document as the fastest way to
clarify what we meant in 8995.
But that would require specific text in the I-D somewhere, to explain
what 8995 Section 5.5 did mean, not just mentioning that 8366bis "closes
this erratum".
Esko
On 14-1-2026 23:17, Esko Dijk wrote:
> If the existing text is not correct, then it does create a
problem
> marking it HFDU. I would rather just reject it, and have a new
errata
> filed or just wait for a new version of 8995 to address it.
The text is correct, but it has to be read along with 8366.
Agree here that the current text in RFC 8995 Section 5.5 is correct;
if read along with 8366. If the reader doesn't open 8366, it may be
unclear whether the idevid-issuer field is mandatory or optional to
include.
The new text proposed by the erratum 7263 is in any case incorrect.
E.g. there's an all-caps phrasing SHOULD BE which isn't RFC 2119
language.
And the inserted MUST is wrong - not required per 8366 and not
intended to be required - and also hard to act on ("you MUST configure
an appropriate value" - but what is 'appropriate' here exactly?).
So maybe best is to reject this erratum.
I commented on the commit also
(https://github.com/anima-wg/voucher/commit/64056649c836f7b9fd4094d827e2d04860e41a3e)
- 2 changes look incorrect.
If 8366 already addresses the erratum, why do we need to mention the
erratum in 8366bis ?
Esko
_______________________________________________
Anima mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
--
*IoTconsultancy.nl* | Email/Teams: [email protected] | +31 6
2385 8339
_______________________________________________
Anima mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
