Hi Lalsingh, Just think what we do if you don't have any software to RIP voice less BGM from DVD or anything. In my point of view... some BGM tracks are useless without the voice... for example... Many scenes from Iruvar (Maniratham's movie) and most of the scenes from Sivaji including the Mottai boss RAP.
I guess Vithur learnt to RIP BGMS very recently with the help of a member of this group (Vithur, I am not sure. Pleas correct me if I am wrong) So... I would suggest you to try the same and tell us about your experience. I have been using the Ripping and other sound editors like Cool Edit pro, Gold wave, Audacity, and Sound forge (all the versions) more then 6 years.. Only thing we required is Good software and the excellent knowledge in using the software. That's it. Nothing else... I guess Kassim has enough experience and good software to RIP the BGMs. Here every one knows Vithur doing a great job on behalf of out group. If you are frustrated with his stuff... don't use it. Pleaseeeeeeeeee don't spoil other's mood here. Since you have started the discussion about the individuals.... I would like to give you the same here. I would to give you a small suggestion here... before going to criticize some one... please ask your self who you are and what you have done. I am not trying to hurt or praise any individuals here. Friends please do not encourage this kind of threads anymore. - Mathan Raj A --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "lalisingh20" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Obviously, I can't help it if you can't understand a simple point I > was trying to make, and instead you decided take it in a negative > direction. Don't worry, no offense taken. The other problem is > people are way too sentimental and sensitive on this group. Any time > anyone criticizes... "Oh no, the world falls apart".. be realistic > and objective, grow up people. > > If someone makes a point, be objected and FIRST try to understand what > they are saying... then comment. I never claimed to be better than > anyone here. I never claimed to know how to rip BGMs. I'm not taking > anyone's side or putting anyone down here. Vithur's or Kaissiom they > have both done a great job providing us with countless BGMs, it's > people like them who make this group lively. > > My point was.. when you have two collections of Swades BGM.. 1) > completely voiceless (kaissiom) and 2) partially voiceless (vithur). > Which one would you keep? > > The point I was trying to make..AGAIN.. was just that I, and maybe > other people as well, prefer completely voiceless over partially > voiceless. And then I stated that we are so spoiled because of that. > we are so spoiled with completely voiceless BGM that we do not > fully appreciate partially voiceless BGMs. Do I not like Vithur's > work or can I do better than him? NO. I grab everything Vithur or > Kaissiom post on here.. but when I listen to partially voiceless > BGMs.. I wish they were completely voiceless. Don't tell me you know > wish that either. We are here's for Rahman's music, not to listen to > an incomplete dialogue from a movie. > > Anyway, you tried to take this comment in a negative way, so I had to > clarify my point again. Let's keep it at that. > > Let's see what the other two gentlemen (vithur and Kaissiom) have to > say about this. > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Kumaresh-n <kumaresh.n86@> wrote: > > > > Dats a good 1 Gomzy.... > > > > > > 2008/5/10 Gomzy <gomtesh.upadhye@>: > > > > > I would appreciate if you could try your hand in ripping any one > BGM of > > > any movie. And oh, no offense! > > > > > > > > > On Sun, May 11, 2008 at 12:45 AM, lalisingh20 <lalisingh20@> > > > wrote: > > > > > >> Thanks to kaissiom and Aj, I think we are spoiled in this group > with > > >> wonderful voiceless BGMs. Honestly, no offense to Vithur or anyone > > >> who is putting in effort to rip BGMs, I only like the BGMs posted by > > >> kaissiom now, since AJ is not posting for a long time. Only because > > >> of quality and the fact that they are truly voiceless. > > >> > > >> Although it is great to collect all the BGMs Vithur and others are > > >> posting, they are not as enjoyable as the one kaissiom posts, because > > >> they still have some voice in the background... which at least kills > > >> my mood. I want to be able to put the BGM CD in the stereo, just like > > >> how I put in a music CD, and enjoy the music. Sometime the ones with > > >> the voice tells us exactly what is going on in the movie... so the > > >> focus changes to the movie where I start visualizing it..not paying > > >> much attention to the music, rather paying attention to the voice and > > >> dialogues. This is why I prefer only truly voiceless BGMs. > > >> Unfortunatley, kaissiom doesn't post all of his work. > > >> > > >> Only if Vithur could start posting truly voiceless BGMs..it would be > > >> dream come true. Or if kaissiom had never posted anything... we would > > >> have appreciated vithur's efforts more greatly. Now I'm unsatisfied > > >> with vithur's efforts only because I know it could be better. So, > > >> forgive me if I'm hurting anyone's sentiments but the truth is we are > > >> spoiled in this group to even have any BGM available to us in any > > >> format. But Rahman's music is such that we want more and more and the > > >> best. > > >> > > >> Do you guys agree? > > >> > > >> --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans% 40yahoogroups.com>, > > >> Vithur <vithurm@> wrote: > > >> > > > >> > Balakrishnan, > > >> > > > >> > Initially, we have to rip the DVD to Mp3s first, and then > remove the > > >> voices > > >> > using software like Goldwave or any other good software. > > >> > > > >> > The best Guide as far as BGms are concerned is Kaissiom. The way he > > >> extracts > > >> > BGMs is an experience altogether. > > >> > > > >> > On Sat, May 10, 2008 at 9:50 AM, Balakrishnan R <vij0988@> wrote: > > >> > > > >> > > I'm sorry if i'm asking the same question many of u have asked > > >> and got > > >> > > answered before ... but what is the software u guys use to rip > > >> > > voiceless BGM ... I have the Sivaji Ayngaran DVD and would > like to rip > > >> > > the BGM to share with all of u .. > > >> > > > > >> > > Balakrishnan > > >> > > > > >> > > > > >> > > > >> > > > >> > > > >> > -- > > >> > regards, > > >> > Vithur > > >> > > > >> > Whatever God wants to give, no one can deny; Whatever God wants to > > >> deny, no > > >> > one can give. Be happy always > > >> > > > >> > > >> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > All the good praise goes to the Almighty > > http://www.arrahman-online.com > > >
