*Ha ha ha. The fact remains that he will hear neither to you nor to me.* This was a joke . Hope you got it the way I intended :)
*btw, screen version of palanhare was different from the audio release version, guess why? probably the entire song was planned on gracy singh (when hero and heroine are on screen who gives songs to moms -- just kidding) but then it might have got changed to be coming from Ammir's mom and Gracy, guess why? We would never know the reason for that switch.* This happens so many times with ARR. Check out Khalbali audio and movie versions for example. He is the one who always innovates remember? -- *Another of my statement that would be hated by us fans:* *I feel that In Luka Chhupi, it was ARR's voice that sounded bad - according to his previous renderings. ARR sounded much more aged in Luka Chhupi with a voice that was not at all suitable for a 25 or so years old on-screen Madhvan. May be ARR should also sing more of religious prayers now, appropriate for his 40+ voice.* My statement might not be liked by you now. I felt this is one of the best songs rendered by ARR. I agree his hindi diction is not perfect, but it never will be. And Madhavan did not lip sync for ARRs voice. Hell he wasnt even there! The song was perfect. But maybe you right , and the oscar jury and myself wrong ! :0 On 7/2/08, V S Rawat <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On 7/2/2008 12:12 AM India Time, _Gomzy_ wrote: > > > Ugly ? i can understand for RDB if you say so, but for Zubeida! > > yeah, Zubeida. BTW, I personally feel Luka Chhupi was much better and > appropriate considering the characters and situation. > > I mentioned Zubeida especially from many songs of ARR-Lata because in > "so gaye hain", I was shocked to hear the aging in Lata's voice is such > a bad manner. BTW, same Zubaida's Pyara Sa Gaanv was much better. But in > So Gaye Hain solo, was it the same lady who had given "solah baras ki > bali umar ko salam" just some 20 years ago when she herself was some > 50+? That was the first time when I had thought that the lady should > take a retirement. > > > And I > > hope ARR will give her more songs. > > Lets see who he listens to. :) > > Ha ha ha. The fact remains that he will hear neither to you nor to me. > > But still, I feel that the music ears that he has, he must have realized > that the lady's voice is no more suitable for Another "Diya Jale" (which > was supppppperb), so our man is giving her religious prayers that you > wouldn't mind sounding aged (palanhare - that she thankfully did much > better) or an aged mom's grieving song at her youthful son's funeral > (Luka Chhupi). > > btw, screen version of palanhare was different from the audio release > version, guess why? probably the entire song was planned on gracy singh > (when hero and heroine are on screen who gives songs to moms -- just > kidding) but then it might have got changed to be coming from Ammir's > mom and Gracy, guess why? We would never know the reason for that switch. > > -- > Another of my statement that would be hated by us fans: > > I feel that In Luka Chhupi, it was ARR's voice that sounded bad - > according to his previous renderings. ARR sounded much more aged in Luka > Chhupi with a voice that was not at all suitable for a 25 or so years > old on-screen Madhvan. May be ARR should also sing more of religious > prayers now, appropriate for his 40+ voice. > > -- > Summing up: > > ARR's best female singer - Lata in Jiya Jale > ARR's worst female singer - Lata in So Gaye Hain > > -- > V > > >
