Dear Sunil, Agreed, recognising the effort of musicians are important. But illayaraja has an orchestra and arr does not. In this case its becomes difficult to detail all the names in one cd cover.
Yuvan,Harris and our boss works quite similar. Anyway, I am not comparing Illayaraja with arr coz both are from diffrent schools but to me though i am a arr fan, in terms of composition raja is way above. You can see that in shivamani interview where he calls raja as a genius in compostions and rahman for his technicality expertise. Cheers Shashi --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "Sunil VG" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I remember Guitar Prasanna once mentioned on his web site that the July > Madham intro was totally created by ARR. Prasanna just played it and brought > his style into the brilliant piece. A similar statement was made by Naveen > when asked about his heavenly flute bits in ARR songs. > > Although ARR gives his instrumentalists the freedom to improvise, it doesn't > take any credit away from. Crediting musicians on album covers was his way > of recognizing & acknowledging the importance of team work. > > Regards, > Sunil > > On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 10:23 AM, anishshreya <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > wrote: > > > Dear All, > > > > Rahman and other music directors work differently. For example if you > > look at Ilayaraja , he composes and give notes to his musicians where > > they just play according to notes and no changes. So the effort comes > > from Illayaraja as a soul person and the operators are many.I guess > > in this case raja did not feel the need to highlight / credit the > > musicians names. > > > > In ARR case, I feel he starts it all fresh. Gives a basic rag and > > asks the musician to play in different styles. So these musicians > > have to be credited coz rahman chooses what fits to the composition. > > > > I guess thats the difference. I am a Rahman fan myself but in terms > > of composition and notes..we have to give it to ilayaraja.He is a > > mastero and till date no one can match it. > > > > Rahman is great in his own stride coz the layers he puts into a song > > and the sound is pure. I had asked my friend who is a professional > > sound engineer to hear Rangde Basanti and was surprised to hear that > > its the ultimate sound at this contemporary time. Its very pure and > > asked me more abt arr. Thats the strength of arr. > > > > Anyway, please do not think i am comparing both of them. I am > > highlighting the need to credit the musicians and why? > > > > Shashi > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans% 40yahoogroups.com>, > > "Vinayakam Murugan" > > <mvinayakam@> wrote: > > > > > > Hello Group, > > > > > > I have marked the post as Semi-ARR not because the attached article > > > talks about ARR but because I am impressed by the way ARR's albums > > > have always bore the name of the percussionists , music programmers > > > and chorus. > > > > > > Please note that the idea of reproducing this article is not to put > > > down any other MD but to celebrate ARR. I have the greatest regards > > > for the MDs listed in this article. > > > > > > http://www.mumbaimirror.com/net/mmpaper.aspx? > > page=article§id=82&contentid=2008072020080720021240406d646d942 > > > > > > Sachin Karta (S D Burman) couldn't think of how to start Roop Tera > > on > > > an appropriately high tempo," says Dinesh Ghate. So Kersi Lord > > > strummed his accordion. > > > > > > And Manohari Singh blew his saxophone. From the improvisations that > > > ensued, the instrumental introduction that generations to come would > > > dance to was drawn. "Similarly, the tune which begins Mera Naam Chin > > > Chin Chu was courtesy S Hazara Singh," Ghate continues, "A guitar > > > player so talented, he actually invented a new kind of guitar." > > > > > > Also, the ghungru interlude in Mohe Panghat Pe... was perfect > > because > > > it wasn't danced but rung, in rhythm with the tabla, by legendary > > > percussionist Cawas Lord. Ghate tops these tidbits with a question: > > > "Are you even aware of these names?" > > > > > > He wasn't either at the time. A percussionist earning his daily > > bread > > > by performing old and new Hindi film songs with a band, the applause > > > Ghate received for an octopad interlude one day made him wonder who > > > the piece had originally been performed by. > > > > > > "This started a series of questions," remembers Ghate. Questions > > like > > > what role do instrumentalists play in a song's composition? How much > > > do they earn? And finally, why don't Hindi film music credits > > include > > > their names when private albums and western music tracks make it a > > > point to do so? "While it's true that some composers had up to > > hundred > > > instruments playing for one track, there were always some > > instrumental > > > pieces, performed solo or in duets, which formed the essence of the > > > track," Ghate argues. > > > > > > > > > So he decided to seek out the performers of such pieces to feature > > > them in a crudely printed black and white newsletter titled Dastak. > > In > > > May 2002, his family (comprising his parents and wife who live with > > > him) helped him prepare a mailing list of those in the music > > industry > > > who would be interested in reading about such performers and mail > > them > > > what looked like a Xerox copy of a feature on sax and flute maestro > > > Manohari Singh. > > > > > > Today Dastak has been renamed and registered as Swar Alaap, a finely > > > printed colour magazine that circluates over 1000 monthly copies to > > > the industry's who's who and universities which teach music. One > > such > > > copy is found in the Voice Of America Library in Washington DC. > > > Likeminded enthusiasts Kushal Gopalka (a businessman), Shankar Aiyar > > > (a banker) and Arun Puranik (a corporate executive) have joined > > Ghate > > > in his endeavour. > > > > > > They've extended their activities beyond the magazine to the Swar > > > Alaap Foundation, that holds concerts to felicitate behind the > > scenes > > > Hindi film musicians (their last show in Mumbai being a tribute to > > > Kawas Lord after his death in December last year). > > > > > > They held an exhibition last year called 100 Years Of Music, which > > > presented chronologically songs, photographs and write-ups outlining > > > the contribution of such musicians, along with instruments used in > > > those times. His next big show, organised with Hansmukh Ravjiani (a > > > music industry veteran) launches the Harmony Club, by mixing the > > most > > > experienced instrumentalists in the business with fresh new voices > > > waiting to be launched. > > > > > > Few know that Leslie Gudinho > > > had drummed out O Haseena Zulfonwaali... > > > "Some of these musicians were given up to eight bars (a sizeable > > > range) by the music director to improvise within," Ghate mentions. > > > "And some, like the Lords (Cawas and his sons Kersi and Burgess), > > were > > > a family of musicians dedicated to imbuing filmy hits with the > > > instrumental magic. > > > > > > " And some like Leslie Godinho who researched percussion to add an > > > additional drum and make Congo a three drum set, or Hazara Singh, > > who > > > invented the double guitar, were musical scientists in their own > > > right. "Yet when I travelled to corners of cities, small towns and > > > villages to locate such musicians post their retirement, many were > > > living in conditions of extreme ill health and poverty," Ghate > > > informs. > > > > > > Some of their neighbours, he claims, referred to them as 'bajaane > > > waala', not knowing of their contribution to the very songs they > > were > > > listening to on their tape recorders or radios as they said this. > > The > > > proceeds of the felicitation concerts Swar Alaap holds go towards > > the > > > medical expenses of some such musicians. > > > > > > Ghate wants to take this forward and institute a charitable trust > > for > > > the purpose. "I also want to set up a small museum displaying what > > we > > > did during our exhibition permanently," he adds. "Our next project, > > > however, is a detailed website." > > > > > > Ghate might have first related so strongly to the plight of a > > musician > > > living in anonymity because of his own situation. "I carried on my > > > live shows and research alongside," he recounts. "I kept wondering: > > I > > > am so unhappy when I don't receive applause for a piece I've > > > performed. > > > > > > What must a musician who improvises such a piece, and yet receives > > no > > > recognition feel like?" Then he takes out some old photographs he's > > > collected of these legendary musicians in their younger days, > > clicked > > > during performance. Seeing these photographs transforms the nature > > of > > > Swar Alaap Foundation's work from complaint to celebration. > > > > > > These musicians, from Leslie Gudinho who drummed out O Haseena > > > Zulfonwaali... to Pandit Ashok Sharma whose Sarod formed the > > backdrop > > > for Bole Re Papihara... don't seem "unhappy" at not recieving > > > "recognition". Their happiness instead, seems to transcend what a > > > famous music director or singer will ever know. > > > > > > It is the happiness of a person who works as a part of an > > arrangement, > > > yet refuses to become just a notation. It is also the happiness of > > > making music that will be heard, rather than having names that will > > be > > > read. > > > > > > > > > Warm Regards > > > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > > > Vinayak > > > http://theregoesanotherday.blogspot.com/ > > > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------- > > ------------ > > > > > > Main chupana jaanta toh jag mujhe sadhu samajhta, Shatru ban gaya > > hai > > > chal rahit vyahvar mera > > > > > > Harivanshrai Bacchan > > > ---------------------------------------------------------- > > ------------- > > > > > > > > > >
