Why would i not want SDM to win? :) I was just trying to appreciate the other song too. We have this habit of pushing something down to pull something up. :P Just giving my opinion thats all.
On Tue, Feb 10, 2009 at 2:15 PM, serge belier <s03g...@hotmail.com> wrote: > Gomzy, I did not understand your position. Are you saying that Wall-E is > better than SDM ? > Would you prefer that Wall-E win the oscar ? > > At this stage of the competition, for me, both music are elligible for > winning, but being a true ARR fan, I want that ARR SIR wins. > In other terms, being in love with India, I wish an Indian wins. It's like > when there is a cricket match in which India is playing, will you wish that > India loses the game ??? > > Honestly, I hope I misunderstood your view. Otherwise, I don't know what's > going on in people mind, I don't understand. > Regards, > > Serge BELIER > (Paris - FRANCE) > > > ------------------------------ > > To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com > From: gomtesh.upad...@gmail.com > Date: Tue, 10 Feb 2009 13:09:28 +0000 > Subject: Re: Down to Earth by Peter Gabriel (Re: [arr] 'Slumdog' vs. > 'Wall-E' for best song) > > > > I heard Wall-E's Down to Earth by Peter Gabriel. I think that is the > song nominated for Oscar in the category of SDM songs. > > *Yes Rawat. Thats the song.* > > The song seems good, but English music has had enumerable equally good > or even better songs compared to that, whereas our man's SDM songs have > a novelty value as international level music from India. > > *Are you telling that Jai Ho is the best ever from India and hindi music?* > > And something in this song reminds me of some of Bryan Adams' songs and > even his voice, not able to pinpoint which one. Anyone. > > *Jai Ho reminds us of Bazi laga and the ATM song too. Thats not the point. > * > ** > *Watch the movie. You will appreciate the song better. Also check out the > lyrics. Great message.* > > > > On Tue, Feb 10, 2009 at 8:22 AM, V S Rawat <vsra...@gmail.com> wrote: > > I heard Wall-E's Down to Earth by Peter Gabriel. I think that is the > song nominated for Oscar in the category of SDM songs. > > The song seems good, but English music has had enumerable equally good > or even better songs compared to that, whereas our man's SDM songs have > a novelty value as international level music from India. > > And something in this song reminds me of some of Bryan Adams' songs and > even his voice, not able to pinpoint which one. Anyone. > > -- > Rawat > > On 2/10/2009 10:02 AM India Time, _Gopal Srinivasan_ wrote: > > > 'Slumdog' vs. 'Wall-E' for best song > > No clear frontrunner among Oscar nominees > > By JON BURLINGAME > > > > For the third time in the past 20 years, music-branch voters chose only > three tunes as best > > song nominees. Two are from the same movie, and two of the singers are > world-class world-music > > recording artists. > > > > There is no clear-cut favorite this year, unlike, say, eight years ago > when Bob Dylan's win for > > "Things Have Changed" was a foregone conclusion, or the year of "Titanic" > and its ubiquitous > > Celine Dion song. What happens Feb. 22 depends several factors. > > > > First, the "Slumdog" phenomenon: Both of the key songs in "Slumdog > Millionaire" are nominated, > > both co-written by leading Indian composer A.R. Rahman (who is also > nominated for his original > > score). The soundtrack album is rising fast on the charts, so a "Slumdog" > win would not > > surprise. > > > > But which song? Will voters remember that it was "Jai Ho" that was > performed as an elaborately > > choreographed, Bollywood-style dance number in the Mumbai train station > at the end of the > > movie? > > > > "Jai Ho," with Indian lyrics by poet Gulzar, may be the most talked-about > musical moment from > > year-end films. And Oscar voters, excited about the prospect of seeing > the number re-created on > > the telecast, may be thinking about that when filling out their ballots. > If it wins, it will be > > only the second foreign-language song to do so (after 2004's "Al otro > lado del rio" from "The > > Motorcycle Diaries"). > > > > But Rahman's collaboration with London-born, Sri Lankan-raised Maya > Arulpragasam -- better > > known to the pop world as M.I.A. -- on "O... Saya" may resonate with > younger voters for its > > pounding rhythms, electronica sound and rap-style vocals. That song's > used earlier in the film, > > as police chase poor youngsters from an airport tarmac through the > streets. > > > > "Slumdog's" competition is the song from the end of the Disney-Pixar > movie "Wall-E," co-written > > by Thomas Newman (also nominated for his score) and Peter Gabriel. The > nom is Gabriel's first > > despite having composed scores for such films as "The Last Temptation of > Christ" and > > "Rabbit-Proof Fence." > > > > Eight of the past 20 song statuettes have gone to tunes from animated > movies (all Disney pics > > but one). And nine of the past 20 have gone to popular artists (including > Gabriel's ex-Genesis > > bandmate Phil Collins, for "Tarzan," another Disney toon). Also, > Gabriel's human-rights and > > environmental activism would seem to coincide with the politics of many > Acad voters. > > > > And, in recent years, voters have spread the Oscar wealth among multiple > pics. A "Slumdog" > > score win could translate into a "Wall-E" song win. > > > > http://www.variety.com/article/VR1117999867.html?categoryId=3275&cs=1 > > > > > > > ------------------------------ > See all the ways you can stay connected to friends and > family<http://www.microsoft.com/windows/windowslive/default.aspx> > > >
