To me it doesnt sound like Darbari and Shudda Danyasi
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "Vajra" <dianic_dre...@...> wrote:
>
> Oh, and while we are at it... so far I have come across two sources that say
> that "Porkalam" from film Thenali, is Raga Kedar. However, Pankaj insists
> it's Shuddha Dhanyasi... and Karthikeya says it's Dharbari Kannada...
>
> What's going on?
>
>
> --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Pankaj 4 Music <pankajformusic@> wrote:
> >
> > hi karthikeya
> >
> > Yes it is Porkalam in Thenali is Shuddha Dhanyaasi. And Raa Raa in C'Muki
> > is a combination of two raagaas thats Sooryaa & HindhoLham (This Sooryaa
> > raag also called as Raag Sallaabam in certain usage of Swaraas). And for
> > dharbari kaanadaa i will say Malarae Mounamaa a class melody by Vidyasagar
> > for Karnaa Movie sung by SPB & S.Janaki. I like to share one of famous
> > Ilayaraja's composition of Pure Sooryaa Raag from the tamil film Thaai
> > Moogaambigai (movie on goddess shakthi) where there ll be a competition in
> > classical concert singing between Manorama & Sarithaa on stage. Manorama
> > character influenced by jealous & greediness & sarithaa a devotee of the
> > goddess when she could not sing in half way of the concert due to the mix
> > of poison in coffee done by manorama, Goddess shakthi comes to her rescue
> > in the form of K.R.Vijaya. The wonderful thing is....., the song sung by
> > three great singers of yesteryears. S.Janaki for Saritha, P.Susheela for
> > K.R.Vijaya & S.Rajeswari for
> > Manorama. Class song that I want Rahman to do a song in that Raag Sooryaa.
> > Hope someone close to him....., place such request on our behalf. pnkJ :-)
> >
> >
> >
> > karthikeya murthy <smartjkm@> wrote:
> >
> > hi pankaj r u sure it is suddha dhanyasi... if i m correct both
> > the songs are based on DHARBARI KANNADA... a typical example for suddha
> > dhanyasi is RA RA from Chandramukhi...
> >
> > with regards
> >
> > KArthikeyamurthy.J
>
