Ghazals... are great but does music limit itself to it??? i think JS thinks music is all about ghazals, only ghazal is music and only ghazal shud be appreciated and awarded , the rest is bakwass....
so beatles were bad and all the others also..... , thats wat he wana say.... On Thu, Apr 9, 2009 at 3:35 AM, vedavid manick <vedavid_man...@yahoo.com>wrote: > > > Although personally, Jai ho is not my favorite song in Slumdog Millionire. > I say it DESERVES the oscar. Why? Because the reality is that it is the > only song that captured the imagination and the the attention of a totally > different culture which may not have paid much attention to a song in Hindi > ever before. This "foreign" song captured the hearts of so many people. > Thats where its strength lies. There are so may good songs that Rahmanhas > made, and how many went unnoticed? Quite a few. The strength of music also > lies in how it reaches out to people, and Jai ho did that more than any > other song on the Slumdog millionaire CD. THats why it deserves it. > > --- On *Tue, 4/7/09, Anish Gupte <musimax2...@gmail.com>* wrote: > > From: Anish Gupte <musimax2...@gmail.com> > Subject: Re: [arr] 'Jai Ho' did not deserve an Oscar: Jagjit Singh > To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com > Date: Tuesday, April 7, 2009, 3:20 PM > > well im not a great fan of jagjit singh or anything...but thats nt the > point... > > in fact the 2 songs u mentioned (yeh jo des ..and maa tujhe salaam) are in > fact way better than jai ho ..lol > > rahman deserved an oscar fr sure..but not for jai ho...why... i prefer > 'dreams on fire' and 'mausam and escape' to jai ho too... > > anyway..lets just say that 'for me' jai ho did not deserve the oscar..but > rahman won it so what more can rahman fan ask for?? > > One must not forget that music is an art..and what one person appreciates > may not be appreciated by someone else... > > sometimes opinions match, and sometimes they dont....its as simple as > that!! > > Anish. > On Tue, Apr 7, 2009 at 12:29 PM, $ Pavan Kumar $ <pawancumarr@ > yahoo.com<pawancum...@yahoo.com> > > wrote: > >> >> Dude, you need to correct your senses like Jagjit singh.. >> >> If you go in that thinking..everyone will accept that jai ho didnt deserve >> an oscar..for someone it would be yeh jo des hai tera, for some other it wud >> be maa tuje salam, it wuould go on on and on.. >> >> The question to ask here is..How many Rahman songs till date has been >> nominated for oscars? Some of you are talking as if every year a Rahman song >> or other gets nominated and fail to win award..This was the first time >> Rahman got the nomination.. and out of the nominated songs for this >> year..Jai Ho was a deserved winner...no doubts in that... >> >> Jagjit singh just wants to promote his albums..he is restoring to cheap >> tactics..if you see..he has made these comments at the time of release of >> his album...Its only when you say these kind of things, the event will get a >> good publicity..Even last time when he attacked rahman, it was some sort of >> event..which i am not able to recollect it...These are nothing but cheap >> publicity stunts. >> >> --- On Tue, 4/7/09, Anish Gupte <musimax2000@ >> gmail.com<musimax2000%40gmail.com>> >> wrote: >> >> > From: Anish Gupte <musimax2000@ gmail.com <musimax2000%40gmail.com>> >> > Subject: Re: [arr] 'Jai Ho' did not deserve an Oscar: Jagjit Singh >> > To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com> >> > Date: Tuesday, April 7, 2009, 8:56 AM >> > I'm afraid i agree with jagjit singh. >> > >> > jai ho is hardly rahmans best. >> > .... i guess 'mitwa' from lagaan aroused more >> > emotions for me than jai ho. >> > >> > On Tue, Apr 7, 2009 at 5:17 AM, Bivin Chandra >> > <bivinchandra@ yahoo.com <bivinchandra%40yahoo.com>>wrote: >> > >> > > New Delhi, Apr 7 (PTI) The world might be ga ga over >> > A R Rahman's Oscar >> > > winning composition 'Jai Ho' but legendary >> > Ghazal singer, Jagjit Singh finds >> > > the song overrated. >> > > >> > > The 68-year-old legend who is famous for his candid >> > nature believes that >> > > getting the Academy award was a golden moment in >> > Indian history but the song >> > > per se did not deserve the honour. >> > > >> > > "Getting an Oscar is no doubt a great achievement >> > but the song, for which >> > > we got the award, is not so special. Frankly I did not >> > understand on what >> > > basis it was awarded," Singh told PTI at a >> > function where he released his >> > > new album 'Inteha.' The Ghazal maestro, said >> > that he did not understand the >> > > lyrics of the composition and why it has become so >> > popular that everybody >> > > from Indian political parties to International pop >> > bands is eager to use it. >> > > >> > > When referred that lyrics for the song has been penned >> > by Gulzar with whom >> > > he has given many hits, Singh said, "When I work >> > with Gulzar Sahab I >> > > categorically tell him to write such poetry which my >> > fans and I can >> > > understand." Singh, who has composed some hit >> > music for films like 'Arth' >> > > and 'Saath Saath' in the 80's does not >> > seem to have a good opinion about >> > > today's Bollywood music as he stated, "it >> > lacks profound poetry and soulful >> > > tunes". PTI >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > http://www.ptinews. com/pti/ptisite. nsf/0/2B0F45FB83 5F7D706525759100 >> 2EB0FB?OpenDocum >> ent<http://www.ptinews.com/pti/ptisite.nsf/0/2B0F45FB835F7D7065257591002EB0FB?OpenDocument> >> > > >> > > >> > > >> >> > > > -- Ashish . . .
