Good one..Agree with you on most of the points..My views on some of the minus
points you had put down...
1. Guys, please dont complain on delay..it happens and that too if it is
happening in southern india, delay is sure to happen. There could be many
reasons for delay..
Rahman was at rehearsals for whole of night..It ended off only at 6 am.
Also there were felicitations and many ministers coming to meet Rahman..you can
expect the craze especially after the 2 oscars that he had just won.
2. Hariharan forgot to come with his mike onto the stage...so he had to share
it with the female singer
3.Yes..the Intro was not that great..but do remember the opening track Mausam
and Escape or O Saya is not so popular as jai ho..so it was something new fot
the audience.
4.Regarding the singers...I too would love to see Shreya or SPB..I feel the
reason for this may be the cost involved..We need to understand that its a
Charity concert...Regarding sukhi and Kailash kher not being part of the
concert..it doesnt makes sense in having them in southern india where the major
attractions are songs from regional languages.
--- On Mon, 5/4/09, live for arr Live <livefor...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> From: live for arr Live <livefor...@yahoo.com>
> Subject: [arr] Plus'es & Minus'es of the Calicut concert - My thoughts
> To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
> Date: Monday, May 4, 2009, 11:48 PM
> friends,
>
> Had a great time watching the ARR show at Calicut. It was
> one of the breathtaking crowd ever seen. Calicut had its day
> when ARR blessed them on May 3rd. Sure, it was a day to
> remember for us Calicut people.
>
> Now coming to the details of the concert, I would like to
> mention the Plus'es & Minus'es which I had felt.
> I am not critising ARR or his fans. This is
> just my opinion, so please dont create a controversy here.
> I also LOVE ARR as much you all do. Thanks..
>
> Pluses -
>
> a) Great crowd, Great visual presentation accompanying each
> song.
> b) Hariharan and Chitra's singing were almost perfect,
> and they were the real stars of the day.
> c) Padakaali was a great surprise for all Mallus. It was
> great singing by george/benny.
> d) Post interval, the concert's momentum picked up and
> it was rocking till the end. Most fast numbers
> were performed post interval.
> e) Humma Humma, with the Carnatic beginning was astounding.
> f) Same with Ey Hairathe Aashique.
> g) ARR's fathers song which he dedicated.
> h) Sanjeev on the Crane and Mustafa after that. It was the
> highest point of the concert. The entire crowd with their
> mobile lights on was just
> a visual treat to watch.
> i) Khwaja was again a mere bliss to watch and hear.
> Azeem/Rukumani/Veerapandi was a rocker.
>
> Minuses -
>
> a) Why was ARR not handling the Keyboard? It was so
> frustrating to see Stephen handling it and ARR was just as a
> mere singer.
> People who have put their hard earned money had to
> come to watch ARR and not Stephen. This was very
> disappointing.
> b) The concert was delayed by 40 mins which led to the
> downfall of momentum which had got built very high at 7 PM.
> c) Pre interval - the Songs/performances were very average
> and some people left between 8 and 9 PM.
> d) Where was the String section? What was the drummer
> doing? Was he just hitting the drums without knowing which
> song was playing?
> I felt he was a MERE SPECTATOR like us.
> e) Sivamani was heavily missed. Because his presence would
> have mad the concert more interesting and his 20 minute
> individual performance
> would have been great.
> f) Most of the songs had Karoake (i.e. the background
> track). Only the voices were Original. All background music
> in the songs were ditto from the CD.
> i.e it was not played LIVE.
> g) Naveen didn't have much to show his skills. We all
> know how much he is talented.
> h) Sadhana Sargam was given 2-3 songs and she was wasted.
> i) Only 2 Singers who are widely popular performed in
> this concert?? Hariharan and Chitra. Rest all are from
> ARR's immediate gang. i.e. who have become popular in
> the last 2-3 years. Where are the other singers? like SPB,
> Srinivas, Naresh, Sujatha, Shreya, Karthik, Sukhwinder etc.
>
> j) In some songs, only 1 Charanam was performed.
> k) Opening song and ARR's intro was not great and it
> didn't capture the audience as expected.
> l) ARR's singing was out-of-pitch at times.
> m) Hari and Sadhana having a single mike to sing Roja
> Janeman. I thought it was amateurish.
> n) At lots of places, lyrics were forgotten, some one was
> talking on the Mike when the song was going on. It
> wasn't professional.
>
> friends, I am repeating that these are my thoughts and
> please dont take it as a offence. I just expected more from
> this concert. When compared
> to his previous Chennai, Delhi concerts, this was a
> letdown.
