for me Aisi Sazaa (Gulaal) tops the list and tops kili re too, comfortably.
Iktaara is not a solo right ?. Amazing song though. On Mon, May 3, 2010 at 11:42 PM, rtyags2k <rahul.ty...@gmail.com> wrote: > > > > Hmmm... not that I don't like Khili Re, but since you ask, some of the > non-ARR female solos (and almost solos) that I like as much as Khili Re (and > some much more than Khili Re right now.. thought that can obviously change > later).. > > 1) Jaadu Hai Nasha Hai (Jism) > 2) Paayaliya (Dev.D) > 3) Sawar Gayi (Saawariya) > 4) U Me aur Hum - I (U Me aur Hum) > 5) Iktaara (Wake Up Sid) > 6) Ek Lau (Aamir) > 7) Aisi Sazaa (Gulaal) > 8-9) Ye Tumhaari Meri Baatein & Phir Dekhiye (Rock On) > 10) Badi Dheere Jali (Ishqiya) > 11) Laakad (Omkara) > 12) Kaisi Paheli Zindagaani (Parineeta) > 13) Udi Udi & Mudi Mudi (Paa) > > And perhaps some more that I can't think of right now. Not that it changes > much. I'm sure if I start making such a list for ARR, it will probably have > many more songs composed by just him while these 13 represent 8 different > composers. So, yes, you do have a point there. Just that "not a single > non-ARR song" is perhaps not true for some of us. > > Rahul > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, V S > Rawat <vsra...@...> wrote: > > > > Actually, it is not really "NOT" liking, it is more like not rating it > > as the best song of the album. > > > > Not many of us has Khili Rey as our most fav of Raavan songs. And some > > of the reasons cited are: > > > > - it is too short > > - ARR has given equally good or better (and longer songs earlier) > > > > Does anyone have any third reason for not rating is the best song of > > the album? please do mention. > > > > -- > > Now, to all those who don't rate Khili Re as the best song of Raavan, > > my request is to name all female solo songs by OTHER MDs (mention only > > non-ARR songs) of last 18 years that were better than or as sweet and > > hummable and soothing as Khili Rey. > > > > I thought about it and I couldn't find any single non-ARR female solo > > song of last 18 years worth mentioning here in comparison of Khili Rey. > > > > So, even when there is no song by other MDs better than it or as good > > as it, even then if we don't rate it as the best song of the album, > > that means ARR has competed with himself and ... > > > > That means ARR has raised our standards and expectations drastically, > > over what other MDs can give to us. > > > > My own favs are Kata Kata, Behne De and then Khili Rey, so I am also > > guilty of undermining a great ARR song on account of non-songs > > drawback that it is too short and that ARR has given equally good or > > better songs earlier. > > > > -- > > Rawat > > > > >
