Jahanzeb..Check the group archives. U will ask me whether Iam a 'Hater' of Amit... Then u would be surprised to find this thread of mine. Iam no Amit trivedi fan, as u qouted.
By the way, Ravi is being a little rational, by saying that no one can come up to ARR's level. It was like how people in the late 80's believed that no one would be ever born to replace Ilayaraja. But, Amit will never replace ARR. Time will tell us who will match ARR's talent (Not possible to replace ARR; coz ARR is emperor of Indian film music). But until then, I would request u guys to enjoy the extraordinary ARR; as well as other good musicians. Jai ho... Spread Rahmanism..Spread CWG.. On Sun, Sep 5, 2010 at 8:41 PM, ravi <ravis...@gmail.com> wrote: > > > ohhh.. is this how it was supposed to be. From the prev posts of KP I had > thought he isn't a big fan of Amit. > But I feel Abbas lyrics are good, though with simple words he plays around > the words and places so well that it fits in to the bars of composition. I > dont remember any of his lyrics where it was misspelt with tune. Though it > is a bit difficult to recite I still love the way he uses the words. His > lyrics aren't poetic like those of Gulzaar saab & Javed Akhtar but is > perfect match for pop & AR's composition goes very well with it. No wonder > Kabhi Kabhi aditi was very fast in picking up the pop lovers. Dont forget AR > is the master of pops just like any other genres. > > There are 2 good composers Amit & Mithoon who are very young and seem > dependable. Given a right opportunity to score serious movies they would > shine as well. Amit's work in "Aamir" was exceptional. > > Personally I don't like comparing creativity and its creators be it Amit / > Mithoon / Rahul Raj / Deepak Dev / Yuvan / Harris / GVP... they are good in > their own accord and it would be foolish to think they will replace AR or > not. > As long as a good music is heard I dont mind appreciating it without being > prejudiced of who the composer is. > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > "Jahanzeb" <jahanzebti...@...> wrote: > > > > Kishore dear don't mind but you sounded very much an Amit Trivedi fan on > an ARR fan group. going to extents of imagining a situation when ARR won't > be available for an Abbas project and declaring that Amit and Abbas would > make a superb combo, and starting a new thread on it, I doubt this is about > discussing and encouraging good music, this is something beyond that. > > I don't know about others but now I am really getting sick of this all > Amit stuff. yeah he did some very good work in his early albums but recently > his work has only been okay to average. to me all songs of Aisha except two > and all songs of Udaan are average. nothing special about them at all. and > even if he has actually given some extra-ordinary stuff etc etc we shall at > least remember that it is an ARR fan group in the first place. > > > > /Jahanzeb > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > kishore parayath <kishore.parayath@> wrote: > > > > > > well, > > > Guys, I have always revolted when many people here crowned Amit Trivedi > as > > > the next ARR, or ARR in the making. He is never an ARR in the making. > But he > > > is definitely a good music director with a different style, although he > > > sticks to the contemporary style. > > > > > > I enjoyed the songs of Aisha, and I feel, Amit Trivedi would be a > brilliant > > > second choice for Abbas Tyrewala, when ARR is unavailable. Because, > Abbas's > > > taste of music is mostly very contemporary, usually with a blend of > > > acoustics, subtle rhythms, simple, but peppy and hummable tunes.. (The > Kabhi > > > Kabhi Aditi kinda stuff). Abbas wouldnt need an avant garde experiment > like > > > Thiruda Thiruda, Rangeela or Iruvar. Abbas's film-making are also > colorful, > > > depicting chocolate romance at campus. I feel, Amit Trivedi and Abbas > > > Tyrewala would prove to be a brilliant. > > > At the same time, Amit cannot work for a Rajiv Menon, Shankar or Mani > > > Ratnam. The difference in ARR is that, he can cater to the tastes and > styles > > > of ANY filmmaker. > > > > > > > >
