Sean,

You have right. I agree with you.
I will try to explain you how Plugin SSO works from TopPositions.

If you connect to ARS through the Mid-Tier. Md-Tier is authenticating in the 
ARS through the special password.
Of course the mid-tier-ip is on the whitelist (see the Installation guide page 
15, MidTier-IP parameter).

But if client connect to ARS through the Windows client you have the followed 
process:
1. Remedy User authenticate user in the special Authentication Service through 
the NTLM negotiation(NTLMv2) in the Domain Controler. 
2. If user is confirmed the Service return generated token to the Remedy User. 
(Token is unique for every User)
3. Remedy User passed into the "Authentication" field in area this token to 
ARESSO.
4. AREA SSO confirm in the Authentication Service this token, If token is 
correct user is authenticate, if no user is no authenticate. Of course the 
Authentication Service confirm client IP address. And the token expired if is 
not use to long time.


Cheers

Konrad 

TopPositions
Really only one secure Plugin SSO for BM Remedy AR System.
Http://www.remedy-sso.com




        







-----Original Message-----
From: Action Request System discussion list(ARSList) 
[mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Garrison, Sean (Norcross)
Sent: Tuesday, March 30, 2010 4:01 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: Top Positions SSO Solution

Without being too technical I don't really trust an ARS SSO integration that 
much.  In order to build an sso you have to follow a process:

1.  Modify the authentication to the mid-tier to check the users credentials.
2.  If the user is valid allow them to log into remedy
3.  If the user is from mid-tier and they have valid credentials bypass the 
AREA authentication and let them in.

It is at step 3 where I believe the security hole lies in an SSO 
implementation.  Granted there is some security but it is relatively weak.  
Typically they ask you to enter in a list of ip addresses and a password of 
some type.  This password is usually passed into the "Authentication" field in 
area.  The IP address is a "whitelist" to tell area whether or not this is a 
mid-tier ip.  So let's say you added your ip address to the whitelist that you 
configure for the sso implementation.  Using the User tool you enter in the 
mid-tier password into the authentication field and put in your username 
leaving the password field blank.  My guess is that you would log right into 
ars with no problems.  Go further and you could probably spoof one of the 
mid-tier ip addresses so that ars thinks your ip address is one of the 
mid-tiers you could do the same thing with entering in no password just the 
mid-tier password.  I don't know what java system solutions does for this issue 
nor what the remedy-sso does.  But in both flowcharts you see a little arrow 
going from mid-tier to ARS.  Before implementing either SSO I would recommend 
validating with the vendor how secure that data is that is passed between 
mid-tier and ars and your comfort level with this type of security.  The only 
reason I know this is because I have tried to build an SSO solution before. 

Thanks, 

Sean




-----Original Message-----
From: Action Request System discussion list(ARSList) 
[mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Shellman, David
Sent: Tuesday, March 30, 2010 8:25 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: Top Positions SSO Solution

Top Positions is spamming every email address that they can associate with an 
Remedy Admin.  They hit a new email address of mine that was added to the 
www.wwrug.com website a couple of weeks ago.
Dave
-------------------------
[email protected]
(Wireless)

----- Original Message -----
From: Action Request System discussion list(ARSList) 
_______________________________________________________________________________
UNSUBSCRIBE or access ARSlist Archives at www.arslist.org
attend wwrug10 www.wwrug.com ARSlist: "Where the Answers Are"

Reply via email to