>This is substantially correct if the law and the constitution were to be
>viewed from the Entry 56 >perspective. And once we have gone into the
>clutches of  Entry 56, we are doomed.


*** It might so appear. But I don't believe we have seen this issue
contested. There are enough open ended threads here where the loops have
NOT been closed.


For one thing, has the Lok Sabha passed a law regarding river-linking?
Sure, article 56 gives all power to the Lok Sabha to make those laws. But I
don't recall ever hearing a parliamentary debate and a law having been
passed authorizing river-linking.

If no such law has been passed SPECIFICALLY, authorizing river-linking and
appropriating funds for its execution, then HOW could the SC direct the
executive branch to execute it? It APPEARS ( obviously I could be
thouroughly misinformed on this) that the SC merely acknowledged the fact
that it has no jurisdiction on the matter, and acknowledged the Lok Sabha's
authority to do what it pleases, requiring no consent from the components
of the supposedly FEDERAL union.

Once again it is clearly shown that the federalism of the Indian union is
more wishful thinking than real.

However IF the Lok Sabha is required to debate the issue and pass the
required laws and appropriate the funds, then it could get quite
interesting. Could it be considered a foregone conclusion that the Lok
Sabha will rubber stamp the administration's politically designed scheme of
river-linking?




*** Forgive my fixation on Assam related issues ( I am fairly ignorant of
the pertinent issues relating to the other regions), but the Brahmaputra is
NOT an interstate river system. B'Desh is NOT an Indian state any more.
Therefore the CENTER could not possibly exercise unlimited authority in
messing with it, even with the blank-check of Article 56.


*** Furthermore, the Manas river, with its three branches merging on to the
Brahmaputra could not possibly be INTERSTATE by ANY stretch of the
imagination. I wonder how, under such circumstances, the big brothers at
Dilli decided, in its unlimited wisdom, to siphon its waters off, WITHOUT
ever discussing the issue with all those whose lives are intertwined with
this river system?

Personally, I am NOT the least bit worried about the Manas river being
diverted or dammed and canalized to direct waters to the west. It is one of
those thoroughly harebrained ideas, most likely proposed by people who are
severely geographically challenged. Why I say that, is that a canal from an
impoundment of the Manas river in Assam ( as opposed to in Bhutan) will
have to cross at least three other rivers before it could be connected to
the Kosi, as 'river-linking' envisions. Nobody has yet found it fit to ask
HOW these other rivers will be crossed with a canal, without impounding
them too. Even a high-school student would know better than to talk in
these ignborant terms. Obviously the political hacks like the BJP minister
Bijoya Chakravarty is mouthing off stuff she has absolutely no clue about.



cm




At 8:22 AM +0530 7/26/03, aditi20 wrote:
>
>
>The Attorney-General has submitted that if a legislation under Entry 56 of
>List I of the Constitution was made, the need for consent of the affected
>states  would not arise and the Centre would be in a position to undertake
>and complete  the project.
>
>
>
>This is substantially correct if the law and the constitution were to be
>viewed from the Entry 56 perspective. And once we have gone into the
>clutches of  Entry 56, we are doomed.
>
>
>
>The case against the riverlinking plan has to be examined in terms of
>lists  II and III where it can be shown that this is a specific case of
>water sharing,  water management and water rights, which is a basic
>constitutional right. While  the Parliamentary jurisdiction is enormous,
>its legislative command cannot allow  it to violate the right to
>life/water. Quite clearly, the case, when argued  before the Supreme Court
>has to establish why river linking will hasten  destruction of water
>resources and not add to them. We need to tabulate facts  around at least
>10 recent large dams and gets experts to endorse them. We need  to
>tabulate facts around the bottomline of the green revolution is establish
>the  need to switch gears towards appropriate agricultural revolution and
>water  management.
>
>
>
>I know we are all very sincerely talking amongst ourselves but we have no
>clue what we are saying to the government? All we know is what the
>government  propaganda machinery is saying.
>
>
>
>Is there any sensitive/sensible lawyer who will work with us. We can find
>competent help in Calcutta but we will need help in New Delhi.
>
>
>
>Aditi Roy Ghatak
>
>
>
> 
>
>
>  Yahoo! Groups Sponsor   ADVERTISEMENT
>
><http://rd.yahoo.com/M=256694.3636030.4902496.1261774/D=egroupweb/S=1705291771:H
>M/A=1688501/R=0/SIG=11if1rb57/*http://webevents.yahoo.com/universal/seabiscuit/>
>
>
>To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
>
>[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
>
>
>
>
> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the
><http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/>Yahoo! Terms of Service.



_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Reply via email to