Hi Ram:

 >I hope you give us due credit in understanding some of
the problems in the NE.



** I do, I do. To you. You did display a desire to acknowledge at least some of it, however grudgingly. I also appreciate your not attempting to insult anyone's intelligence by playing no-comprendo.


 but more so
because you completely avoided answering Barua's


** But I said I will. Just stay tuned. I refused to earlier, because, shall we say it was not worth responding to ? I have not changed my mind yet on the worthiness. But I realize I do need to pay SOME penance for my sins of omission and commission.

But I cannot respond to so many fronts of attack instantly. Can you
downplay my feeling of being surrounded by hostile Indians?


c-da :-)







At 11:08 AM -0800 1/1/05, ram Sarangapani wrote:
Dear C'da,

 But still I would admit, I was too strident with my
 language, and I remain contrite for it. With you,
with Ram, with Alpana and even with Rajib :-).
 I realize that more than anything else, my
 intemperate choice of words and phrases raised the
hackles it did.

I hope you give us due credit in understanding some of the problems in the NE. Atleast in my case (and I suspect others too), your response raised the hackles NOT becuse it was strident or harsh, but more so because you completely avoided answering Barua's question and simple set it aside as being too broad or immaterial/immature. Please tell us why you think it is immaterial or immature? Are such comparisons bad or is it that you really do not have an answer?

What I was looking for in your response was solid
arguments against (or for) Barua's question 'Why the
NE states are lagging behind?). A simple answer that
brushes it under the carpet as being inconsequential
is NOT attacking the problem at all.

You have been arguing that even if Assam got
sovereignty they are unfit to govern themselves ( as opposed to say India who is fit) and
other such opinions.

The bottomline here is that there are a group of people in Assam who think they could do a better job of governance than Delhi. But just wishful thinking like this does not cut it. People who support such a stance should be able to answer a few questions first.

If the GOI will NOT give independence to Assam (a very
likely scenario) on a silver platter, what then?

Are the Assamese willing to go on for another 25 years
of insurgents fighting superior Indian forces and the
resulting unstable conditions? Is that what is in
store for Assam?

Its one thing to be passionate and to preach from
afar, but its, I am sure totally different for the
people (insurgents, common folks, soldiers etc) to
keep dragging this to no end and against all odds.

The best option I think is for states to get together
and urge the GOI for more autonomy for states. The
modalities could then be worked out. In fact the GOI
has said they are willing to discuss autonomy in
Kashmir. This all-or-nothing stance will only lead to
a near total destruction of basic structures for
development/growth that exist in Assam.

-- Ram




--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

 OK Rajen, finally we are at the gates of the big
 Kahuna of a question
 that generated so much angst.

 First let me address:

 >So you think my question is so simplistic that it
 is not worth answering even.

 *** On the face of it, stripped of CONTEXT under
 which you raised the question,
 your protestation of my unfairness implied in the
 comment above would
 be understandable. I would be guilty of making an
 insensitive and
 disrespectful comment about a fellow netter and a
 friend's question
 in a public forum.

 And if it were just that, I should and would offer
 an unconditional
 apology, at the very least.

 But there was more to it:

        Your question's possible answer was designed as
 another of
          your arguments against any justification
> for the ULFA insurgency
          and the complicity of the people of Assam
 in it. You have been
          arguing that even if Assam got sovereignty
 they are unfit to govern
          themselves ( as opposed to say India who is
 fit) and other such
          opinions.

(>If Assamese do not have the courage to stand up
> for justice, how one
         can even think of an >independendent Assam?
 That is why I said, Assamese
         are probably not fit for democracy. Do you
 >think Assamese nature will
          change overnite?)


Which is fine, we all have opinions about all kinds of things. And none of us here are for stifling such views, unless they are patently offensive in some manner or other.

 But as I explained to Ram, that one should not be
 surprised to be challenged
 when someone is floating as vague or broad-brushed
 proposition as
 yours in pursuit of a hotly debated political
 position.


That is the difference Rajen. And that is my defense.

 But still I would admit, I was too strident with my
 language, and I
 remain contrite for it. With you, with Ram, with
 Alpana and even with
 Rajib :-).
 I realize that more than anything else, my
 intemperate choice of
 words and phrases raised the hackles it did.


Stay tuned now for some answers to your question.


c








At 12:55 PM -0600 12/30/04, Barua25 wrote: >Chandan: >I asked the question: >Why the South seems to be better disciplined in educational >institutions in India specially in Medicine? What is the secret? >Sometime it looks like South India is more Mainlanland India. Why >they donot revolt against the domination of the Hindi-wallas? Why >they donot hate India like the North East? The South seem to be >progressing completely ignoring or in spite of the Hindi belt North >India. Or is the South gradually taking over the North? > >Ram's response was: > >The question itself is a great question. Such questions do >>provide us the opportunity to do some soul searching >>as to why the NE has lagged behind, and allows us to >>be introspective. At least it shows that we do not run >>away from asking/answering such questions. > >And your response was: >*** Yes I agree that Rajen's question here was a very simplistic one >at best. But we don't need to attempt to answer a question that >itself is that simplistic or questionable in substance, do we? > >So you think my question is so simplistic that it is not worth answering even. >Probably you like complicated questions only like : >Why the center does not take responsibility for the ills of Assam? >I say Hob Diok Kokaidew >RB/- > >----- Original Message ----- >From: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>Barua25 >To:

<mailto:[email protected]>[email protected]
 >Sent: Wednesday, December 29, 2004 2:40 PM
 >Subject: [Assam] Educational Institutions in India
 >
 >Blue Thoughts:
 >
 >It seems some Indian educational institutions are
 doing great. Take
 >for instance the welknown : Manipal Medical
 College. I came to know
 >that they have now opened brnaches even in Nepal
 and Thailand and
 >are attarcting lot of international students.
 >
 >Question: Why the South seems to be better
 disciplined in
 >educational institutions in India specially in
 Medicine? What is the
 >secret? Sometime it looks like South India is more
 Mainlanland
 >India. Why they donot revolt against the domination
 of the
 >Hindi-wallas? Why they donot hate India like the
 North East? The
 >South seem to be progressing completely ignoring or
 in spite of the
 >Hindi belt North India. Or is the South gradually
 taking over the
 >North?
 >
 >RB
 >
 >
 >
 >_______________________________________________
 >Assam mailing list
 >[email protected]
 >http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
 >
 >Mailing list FAQ:
 >http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
 >To unsubscribe or change options:
 >http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
> >
 >
 >_______________________________________________
 >Assam mailing list
 >[email protected]
 >http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
 >
 >Mailing list FAQ:
 >http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
 >To unsubscribe or change options:
> >http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
 > _______________________________________________
 Assam mailing list
 [email protected]
 http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

 Mailing list FAQ:
 http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
 To unsubscribe or change options:
 http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam





__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail - 250MB free storage. Do more. Manage less.
http://info.mail.yahoo.com/mail_250

_______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to