Rajen:


I am glad you did not expect me to reply to this post. Because, I will be hard-pressed to do justice to it. But I felt that I needed to, in segments perhaps:





 >Sensing
this, at one point I frankly suggested that let us discuss offline so that
we can sort out these differences outside the net so that we donot have to
take the entire through this gruelling excercise in debate.


I did not wish to get into a private debate or discussion, because it is neither about you, nor about me. Besides neither you nor I represent ANY constituency of Assam. We discuss these things in public, hoping to raise awareness of the issues among those who might care to read. Great if we have some response, but that happens so rarely.


Anyway, why did YOU think I rejected the idea flatly? What was your conclusion?



1) I have great
convictions for the things I believe and at the same time I am open for
discussion. 2) I never take things personally.


I had no doubt of that. And I have always admired that. Exactly the reason I did not hesitate to be candid with my comments and views. But I do realize that even for the most secure and open-minded, there is a threshold, a boundary, beyond which one must not venture, without creating some backlash. I am afraid I crossed that line with my choice of words, which invited your anger. I don't blame you for it. It was MY fault for not exercising restraint.


From the very beginning, I have been
very upfront about what I believe and what I do not believe. (You can check
the records in the net and the netters be the judge).

However I found that I
could never found actually what you believe and what you do not believe.


Absolutely unnecessary Rajen. It is not about you. Same way, who cares what MY beliefs are? People are too pre-occupied with running a life as it is. Neither I nor you are such luminaries, God's-gift-to-humanity, that they would be waiting with bated breath to hear what I or you believe. We are lucky if anybody even reads what we post.

I am acutely aware of the fact that the sound of my voice might charm myself, but not many others. That is a sobering realization. Has been very helpful to me.

But what I believe usually exude from every sentence I write. People who read them have a pretty darn good idea of were I stand on the issue under discussion.
That is NOT to suggest I go about TELLING or LECTURING other people on what to do. Like GoI, or GoA or ULFA or the people of Assam. I bring out the issues when I do, analyze them, and hope I made some persuasive arguments that others might accept, or at least be cognizant of.


I am however always open to considering a specific question on a specific issue.
I try to answer as candidly and forthrightly as I can, when I have an answer. But unfortunately I DO NOT have an answer to every issue under the sun, or even Assam. Furthermore I respect others' intelligence not to LECTURE them. For example the people of Assam, or ULFA.


For that reason, I do not attempt TELL those people of Assam who agitate
to uphold their language/cultural/ethnic identity are WRONG. That they should not do that, because they have no right to that, or because others do not do so, or that it is meaningless or any such thing. It is an intangible, and cannot be measured with an arbitrary scale that I might hold dear. It is a GREY area. It is very subjective. No one needs any JUSTIFICATION to feel that way. All it requires is that IMAGINATION.


That however is different from the rule of law, something, if not adhered to by society, it turns into various degrees of anarchy, like India is. That is a black and white issue.




netters would know that I already said
what believe about ULFA. I already told that ULFAs are misguided brothers
and that I donot beliecve in Soveregnity.


That is your right. I can't tell you not to believe what you do. It is just that I believe differently. I believe that a group of people which has imaginations of themselves as a distinct nation, it is their right to feel that way. It is their right to regain their sovereign, if it was denied them by others by force, or coercion, or trading or accident of history.

I believe it is immature to tell them that they do not deserve it, or have no right to it, because someone traded it away, or took it away by military force. And even if it was consensually given up with conditions or understandings, if those conditions were not fulfilled or understandings breached, they have a right to seek it back.


But the BOTTOM LINE is that, it is for those people to decide what they want, or what they can live with. In the context of Assam, *I* will never attempt to TELL, or LECTURE the people of Assam what they should or must do. It is for THEM to decide. If I lived in Assam, *I* would stand up for Assam's right. But I left, voluntarily. I have no right to TELL them anything.


That is the single major difference in your and my outlooks on these matters, Rajen.


More later.

c






At 1:13 AM -0600 2/5/05, Barua25 wrote:
Chandan:
As we can see there are major difference of opinion (or rather convictions)
between us about the political and economic secenario in Assam. Sensing
this, at one point I frankly suggested that let us discuss offline so that
we can sort out these differences outside the net so that we donot have to
take the entire through this gruelling excercise in debate. I remember you
flatly rejected my offer and wanted to debate public things in public. I
don't know about you, but you can take two things about me: 1) I have great
convictions for the things I believe and at the same time I am open for
discussion. 2) I never take things personally. With the above bases, I
decided to go along with you and debate in a rational manner to sort out
things in public for the good of Assam. From the very beginning, I have been
very upfront about what I believe and what I do not believe. (You can check
the records in the net and the netters be the judge). However I found that I
could never found actually what you believe and what you do not believe.
Take for instance, the case of discussing the problems of Assam. I always
believed, and voiced that way. that we should discuss these problems and
should try to come up with solutions so that we can help Assam. You never
participated in the discussions of the actual problems or their solutions,
At best probably you would raise some critical questions as if you are
trying to throw a monkey wrench to discussion. Now it is rather a shock that
after all these years, you suddenly dropped a bombshell that you donot want
to take part in these discussions, because Rajen has hidden motive behind
raising the list of problems, and that he is doing it so that he would say
ULFA cannot solve these.  I have never seen such twisted logic. If you had
been reading my notes in the net, netters would know that I already said
what believe about ULFA. I already told that ULFAs are misguided brothers
and that I donot beliecve in Soveregnity. Other than that I donot have
anything against ULFA . I even donot care what they discuss and what they
dot with GOI. My only grievance is that ULFA is keeping Assam hostage for
the last 25 years and they are actually undermining the democratic process
started by the Assam Movement which was supported by the entire Assamese
population. and frankly speaking I wish that they will come overground and
help rebuild Assam.  Now after declaring all these above in the net,  you
don't have to bend backwards and try to come up with a twisted theory that
Rajen is doing it to oppose ULFA.  I can ignore many things for sake of our
friendship, but how can I ignore such false accusations in the public?
There are many cases wehere you have thorwn persoanl accusation against by
imagining hidden motives behind my statements. I don't want to go into
details of these now as it will not serve any piurpose but simple want to
say that you don't have to do that.
To make it short, let me come to the idea of poll. Basically you are
proposing that let there be a poll asking the people if they will go back to
rebuild Assam if 1) BJP 2) AGP 3) CONGRESS or if 4) a FOURTH party asking
for the formation of a AUTONOMOUS or SOVEREIGN  ASSAM.
I don't know what prompted you to the idea of such a poll, but when I read
this, my first reaction was to laugh aloud. As I told you, I have such
strong convictions of things, that I found the whole thing very ridiculous
and childish at best for several reasons.
1) There is no mention of any issues or problems for Assam to which the guys
will go to help or rebuild. Rebuild what? This itself is a major difference.
2) You have thorwn both the words AUTONOMY and SOVEREIGNTY together as if it
is an Assamese way of saying: Hobo Diok, we will do something, either
Autonomy or Sovergnity. Don't worry. While on the other hand the both the
ideas are worlds apart. You will find probably the entire Assamese
population voting for an Autonomous Assam. But Soveregnty iss abnother
matter.
3) This is coming from you who refused to discuss  in the net the merits of
Autonomous or a Soveregn Assam.
4) For people to vote for a Soveregn Assam, people will have to be told, at
least, how this Soveregnty will be achieved  by the FOURTH party (which we
failed to discuss in the net).
4) You should not worry about getting votes for this Soveregn Assam on one
condition. If the FOURTH party (be it ULFA or any other) promise
Ambassadorships to foreign country, you will get at least so many votes as
there are countries. In such case, I will also vote 'yes' if ULFA promise me
the Ambassodrship for China. AKN is already thete in Taiwan. Ram and Alpana
will be good cadidate for India. You may even ask people to choose.  But the
thing is, even if you get these votes, say a majority of NRAs, will it be
something like a check that you will be able to cash. What that vote will
mean unless you discuss and let the people know the details. An NRA can say
'yes' today, and with the same face he/she can say 'no' tomorrow. In the net
Jugal and others had taken so many polls in the past. Any result of any
single poll? I am convinced that these polls are meaningless. I therfore
found the idea childish at best.
5) There are many other faults of your proposition. Like why you are putting
AUTONMY only for the FOURTH party. In fact AUTONOMY can be an option with
every party.
6) My main questin is however, why you are bringing all these politiocal
parties? BJP, AGP, CONGRESS, ULFA  etc. So far in the net we donot have any
affiliation to any political party. At least when I response to Ram or
anybody, I donot think whether he is BJP guy or a CONGRESS guy. Now by
conducting the poll, all the NRAs will be stamped. We will know who is who
AGP or CONGRESS or ULFA or what. This is where I questioned that the poll
will make the net a into political platform. I used the word 'secular;
meaning now it is not a political party platform. The NRAs will be divided
into political groups. At present, with two groups, ASA and AANA, I think we
have enough. Why you want to create more groups?
without achieveiing any purpose.
7) Your whole idea of SOVEREIGN Assam is based on the imaginary theory that
the present system will not work. Basically you are trying to put old wine
in new bottle, but refused to show us the bottle.

Now as I told that I am open for discussion. Now if you or anybody can
convince me with one example which the poll will be able to achieve, I am
ready to listen.

In spite of my undermining the poll, it is up to you if you want to conduct
such polls. But the way I see it it will boil down to a discussion between
AUTONOMY AND SOVEREUGNTY which I already suggested and which you refused
vehemently. Till now I donot have a clue why. Now with your idea of a poll,
if it biols doen to such a discussion, I will be delighted.

Chandan, I am not asking for a response to this mail. In another mail I will
post my beliefs and convictions more clearly in the net. After that I don't
see any purpose in taking part in any of these fruitless discussions since
we donot agree on the main theme.

It is way past bed time. TGIF .Good night.
Rajen



----- Original Message -----
From: "Chan Mahanta" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Barua25" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "ram Sarangapani"
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Alpana B. Sarangapani" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: <[email protected]>
Sent: Friday, February 04, 2005 10:41 PM
Subject: Re: [Assam] Wave of Prodigals?


 Rajen:

 It is way past my bedtime. But I thought I would reply anyway, in
 spite of the fact that my thinking abilities are at its lowest this
 time of the night.
>

Your explanation is good enough for me. As I always say, English is only a second language for us. This damned language has caused us more problems than any one of us would care to enumerate. So I blame it on them English folks :-).


I can give it a try to help explain your views. But I still have not a clue what you were taking issue with.

 Was it because you were troubled by the fact that NRA's might agree
 with my suggestion that they might support a reform minded autonomous
 or sovereign, democratic, Assam govt.? That the poll, if held, might
 create a wedge between NRAs and India? That it might validate my long
 held belief that Indian governance is unable or unwilling or both--to
 institute much needed reforms, and thus validate the NE insurgencies?

 If you tell us what your thoughts were behind the charges you made, I
 might be able to offer a word or phrase that so many tonight are at a
 loss for. Anjan and Ram, two products of St. Edmunds, are even
 attempting to impart new meaning to the word secular, because so many
 misuse it. Their disingenuous attempts at equating democracy with
 secularism must be making their old English teachers at St. Edmunds
 taking a turn or two in their graves. Bipin sent us the entire
 Internet archives on secularism. Fortunately I saw no confusion there
 with either democracy or egalitarianism. I am glad though that you
 did not encourage them.

 It takes a big man to own up to mistakes that none of us are immune from.

 You single me out to be the utterly confused. Maybe I am, because I
 am so uniquely misguided :-). But really, you confused the heck out
 of everyone. People are attempting to give you a little cover with
 convoluted reasoning.
 Good thing you showed that you don't need any such cover. I feel good
 about that.

 Take care.

 c







 At 6:51 PM -0600 2/4/05, Barua25 wrote:
 >  > All I am saying is that Barua more than likely used
 >>  the word 'secular' instead of maybe a word like
 >>  'democratic'. Now, of course, Barua would have to
 >>  clarify what he was really thinking.
 >
 >Netters must excuse me. I misused the word 'secular'. May be I should
have
>used the word 'non-political-party' or something like that. (I would
request
>any netters to come up with the right word and help me.) You see, I
cannot
 >use the word 'non-political' either because what we are discussing is in
 >fact politics.  So I should say it is a Janji-mukhia slip meaning I
learnt
 >my English, which as you know is not my mother tongue, in Janji Mukh and
 >make such silly mistakes from time to time. But if Chandan insists that I
 >intentionally used the word 'secular' meaning non religious to create a
 >confusion, then also I would say that due to my Janji-mukhia English,
 >probably I mistook the scared organizations like BJP, Congress, ULFA,
which
>Chandan was trying tinvoke, to be 'religions' because one need to have
some
 >type of 'belief system; to become members of these too.
 >Either way, it is entirely my fault, and I pray netters, specially
Chandan
 >who seem to be utterly confused with my use of the word,  to excuse me in
 >this case. I promise to try not to do any more this type of Janji-mukhia
 >slips in future.
 >
 >Rajen Barua
 >
 >----- Original Message -----
 >From: "ram Sarangapani" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
 >To: "Chan Mahanta" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Alpana B. Sarangapani"
 ><[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
 >Cc: <[email protected]>
 >Sent: Friday, February 04, 2005 3:45 PM
 >Subject: Re: [Assam] Wave of Prodigals?
 >
 >
 >>  C'da,
 >>
 >>  > Are you suggesting that I am SPINNING  what Rajen
 >>  > might have intended to say?
 >>
 >>  Not at all.
 >>
 >>  > The word 'secular' has been a lightning-rod of
 >>  > controversy in Assam Net for years on end. So one
> >> > might presume the meaning of the word is not a
 >  > > mystery to these netters.
 >>
 >>  I agree. But you are giving me far too much credit.
 >>  All I am saying is that Barua more than likely used
 >>  the word 'secular' instead of maybe a word like
> >> 'democratic'. Now, of course, Barua would have to
 >>  clarify what he was really thinking.
 >>
 >>  All I did was to substiute democratic for secular and
 >>  I could understand what he was talking about. Frankly,
 >>  I think Barua just used the wrong word here - thats
 >>  all.
 >>
 >>  > Also should I have railed about Alpana asking me
 >>  > the question about returning to Assam this
 >>  > morning, because it was a 'personal' question?
 >>
 >>  First, let me clarify, I seriously doubt if Alpana or
 >>  I would think this as personal, if someone were to ask
 >>  such a question. In fact, I think its quite valid,
 >>  given the subject matter.
 >>
 >>  But if you were to go back and look at her question,
 >>  you would know that she was really suggesting you to
 >>  include the question in your survey. I did not get the
 >>  feeling she was asking 'you' personally. Of course you
 >>  went ahead and answered it - of what "you" would do
 >>  instead of the survey itself. Of course, she would
 >>  have to clarify - I will leave this to her.
 >>
 >>  > Did you, Rajib, Rajen not charge me of 'evading'
 >>  > Rajen's question about the educational
 >>  > achievements of the South issue? And when I
 >>  > answered, under harassment, was that getting
 >>  > personal?
 >>
 >>  Again, I did not see them as being personal. If I did,
 >>  I wouldn't ask in the first place.
 >>
 >>  > >is a democratic forum, where members could voice
 >>  > >opinions for/against any topic and that we should
 >>  > >avoid personal references.
 >  >
 >>  When I said the above, I was trying ONLY to
 >>  discern/interpret what Barua was trying to say. He did
 >>  write several times that he felt the exchanges were
 >>  personal. It was in that reference that I used it. I
 >>  guess it was a poor attempt. But those are not my
 >>  ideas of exchanges. My views are slightly different.
 >>
 >>  > Did you, Rajib, Rajen not charge me of 'evading'
 >>  > Rajen's question about the educational
 >>  > achievements of the South issue?
 >>
 >>  I hope you really did not take that as personal-:)
 >>  I enjoyed those banters, and still do (even if I am on
 >>  the losing side).
 >>
 >>  But, C'da, if I am allowed in the net, I would always
 >>  tend to ask those questions to you or others. And I
 >>  would also expect others to ask me too. I thought that
 >>  was the essence of the net. Correct me if I am wrong
 >>
 >>  C'mon, C'da, I write on the net because I enjoy it,
 >>  learn somthing on the way, exchange ideas. Sometimes
 >>  passionately, other times I am caustic, but NEVER in
 >>  anger.
 >>
 >>  --Ram
 >>
 >>
 >>  --- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
 >>
 >>  > Ram:
 >>  >
 >>  > Are you suggesting that I am SPINNING  what Rajen
 >>  > might have intended to say?
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > The word 'secular' has been a lightning-rod of
 >>  > controversy in Assam Net for years on end. So one
 >>  > might presume the meaning of the word is not a
 >>  > mystery to these netters.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > Assuming it is a mystery still to Rajen or Alpana
 >>  > then all the arguments BOTH made for or against
 >>  > secularism in Indian governance were based on
 >>  > very distorted  perceptions on the meaning of
 >>  > that word on their parts, wouldn't you think?
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > >is a democratic forum, where members could voice
 >>  > >opinions for/against any topic and that we should
 >>  > >avoid personal references.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > Did I force anything on Assam Netters to stifle
 >>  > that?
 >>  >
 >>  > Also should I have railed about Alpana asking me
 >>  > the question about returning to Assam this
 >>  > morning, because it was a 'personal' question?
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > Did you, Rajib, Rajen not charge me of 'evading'
> >> > Rajen's question about the educational
 >>  > achievements of the South issue? And when I
 >>  > answered, under harassment, was that getting
 >>  > personal?
 >>  >
 >>  > I do acknowledge here however that I used strong
> >> > language. I knew enough words and phrases to use
 >>  > in lieu of the ones I did. In that I stand
 >>  > contrite.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > >It shouldn't matter if
 >>  > >someone is for/against GOI or Ulfa or something
 >>  > else,
 >  > > >we should all have that voice to express, and
 >>  > really
 >>  > >don't expect to be shouted down.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > Is that what I was guilty of -- shouting down
 >>  > someone--to invite the charge of attempting to
 >>  > undermine the 'secularity' of Assam Net and
 >>  > injecting something alien to the net, namely
 >>  > politics ?
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > Come on Ram. You are trying too hard, but not very
 >>  > effectively.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > >Its difficult to see
 >>  > >some of the most senior members bring out their
 >>  > >rancour in an open forum.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > I would agree  with you on that. It is not good.
 >>  > I certainly am not enjoying it.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > >
 >>  > >My MO is very simple, when I read views from
 >>  > readers -
 >>  > >I try very hard to read them at face value, without
 >>  > >regard to what may or may not be their political
 >>  > >beliefs off the net
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > Easier said than done. But even if I gave you a
 >>  > pass on that, Rajen himself wrote several times
 >>  > indicating why he is undertaking the effort on
 >>  > establishing a list of Assam's Problems. I was
 >>  > not using anything at all culled from OFF-the NET
 >>  > sources, confidential or otherwise.
 >>  >
 >>  > But our conversations, debates, shouting matches
 >>  > and even the fights are like a part of a never
 >>  > ending story. To pretend they are stand alone,
 >>  > un-related islands of discourse would be highly
 >>  > unpersuasive.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > >  >(I guess), but when
 >>  > >talking about 'problems' in Assam, I really do not
 >>  > >look for some ulterior motives.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > I won't argue with you on that. By and large few
 >>  > do. But on this point of contention if I remember
 >>  > correctly, ulterior motive assignments have been
 >  > > flying right and left. Not that it bothers me. I
 >>  > know how to defend myself.And I make no apologies
 >>  > for my leanings. But there are others who might
 >>  > get offended when the boomerangs return home or
 >>  > their protestations of neutrality get challenged.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > >I also try very hard not to take anything said
 >>  > against
 >>  > >my views on a personal basis.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > I agree. It has always worked for me. But then
 >>  > again I have 40 mil.th.  naugahide skin ( now
 >>  > don't twist it and call it Noga-hide. We have
 >>  > enough problems with them ). And gets thicker by
 >>  > the day from accumulating scar  tissue.
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > Finally:  Can I give my assessment of what Rajen
 >>  > and Alpana might have been attempting to say: "
 >>  > You are trying to create a split between Assam
 >>  > and India by encouraging them to share their
 >>  > views on this poll. We don't like that."
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > If that is so, why are they squeamish about
 >>  > saying it like it is? What are they afraid of?
 >>  > Are they afraid I might turn the ULFA on them to
 >>  > teach them a lesson ?
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > And if they did, I might say something like:'
 >>  > Yes, yes, it was me who started it all. My bad!
 >>  > So sue me.'
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > c-da :-)
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  >
 >>  > At 11:29 AM -0800 2/4/05, ram Sarangapani wrote:
 >>  > >C'da
 >>  > >>  Neither you nor Rajen have done it yet, leaving
 >>  > >  > myself and I am sure a host of other netters
 >>  > >>wondering what you are saying :-).
 >>  > >
 >>  > >Let me try to give it a shot! You grabbed on to one
> >> > >word 'secular' in Barua's sentence, but seemed to
 >>  > have
 >>  > >ignored the gist of what he was trying to say.
 >>  > >
 >>  > >From what I discerned, I felt Barua (Barua, correct
 >>  > me
> >> > >if I am mistaken) was trying to tell us that the
 >>  > net
 >>  > >
 >>  > >is a democratic forum, where members could voice
 >>  > >opinions for/against any topic and that we should
 >>  > >avoid personal references. It shouldn't matter if
 >>  > >someone is for/against GOI or Ulfa or something
 >>  > else,
 >>  > >we should all have that voice to express, and
 >>  > really
 >>  > >don't expect to be shouted down. That you will
 >>  > agree
 >>  > >does us no good. That is what will bring down the
 >>  > >STANDARDS of the net.
 >>  > >
 >>  > >My observations are, by and large, we have been
 >>  > very
 >>  > >accommdative of divergent views. Its difficult to
 >>  > see
 >>  > >some of the most senior members bring out their
 >>  > >rancour in an open forum.
 >  > > >
 >>  > >My MO is very simple, when I read views from
 >>  > readers -
 >>  > >I try very hard to read them at face value, without
 >>  > >regard to what may or may not be their political
 >>  > >beliefs off the net. Now, if were talking about
 >>  > >AANA/ASA, those might come in play (I guess), but
 >>  > when
 >>  > >talking about 'problems' in Assam, I really do not
 >>  > >look for some ulterior motives. Some of those
 >>  > problems
 >>  > >are real human problems, and I would like to give
 >>  > the
 >>  > >utmost respect that they deserve.
 >>  > >
 >>  > >I also try very hard not to take anything said
 >>  > against
 >>  >
 >>  === message truncated ===
 >>
 >>
 >>
 >>
 >>  __________________________________
 >>  Do you Yahoo!?
 >>  Read only the mail you want - Yahoo! Mail SpamGuard.
 >>  http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail
 >>  _______________________________________________
 >>  Assam mailing list
 >>  [email protected]
 >>  http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
 >>
 >>  Mailing list FAQ:
 >>  http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
 >>  To unsubscribe or change options:
 >>  http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
 >>



_______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to