Ram:

I was confused a little, because from some of your
posts, I got the impression that the issues we are
trying to understand (vis-a-vis Assam) MIGHT be
construed as being condescending.


*** It was not my intent to somehow portray Rajen as some kind of a self-impressed megalomaniac. Nothing could be further from the truth.
I know his intentions are and have always been most honorable. I can
say that with sincerity because I know him personally, just like I know
you and so many others here in the net where we disagree and engage in
heated debates.


We all tend to lose our cools occasionally, indulge in hyperbole, and so forth.
I know I indulge far too often on sarcasm for one thing, knowing full well it is not an admirable trait.


Having said that, I will not be candid if I did not say that our debates
often cannot rise to a desired level of objectivity, because we get bogged
down with our biases, leading us to play 'no-comprendo', or resorting to specious arguments, or avoiding responding to issues and at times obvious evasiveness and so forth. As a result, all the intelligence here go to waste, because we fail to close the loops on the threads of a discussion.


I have one suggestion to netters for consideration in that context:

*** If we intend to let the chips fall where they may with our discussions and analyses, and thus contribute something meaningful towards HELPING the people of Assam to make intelligent decisions about what is right for them, then we might be able to overcome our self-imposed obstacles.

One thing that I have found very helpful is a realization that I do not have to be right about anything. It helps if I am, but I am free to be wrong, free to make errors. That makes it easy for me to accept it when someone presents a better argument, or corrects my erroneous perceptions. Surely WE ALL are much more than what we portray ourselves as in Assam Net. It is such a small part of our beings.

Simply put, our sense humility should be an asset, not a burden, to our discourses.

My own lack of interest or enthusiasm about TELLING people of Assam anything is based on that. Surely I have my preferences. But I have no interest in telling Assam or ULFA or AASU or the Chief Minister on a given day,or India -- that I have the answers to their problems. I can help analyze SOME of them. But it is not my role to tell them what is right for them.

That is not the same as unwillingness to take a stand on issues where we ought to be able to see in blacks and whites. We owe it ourselves to see them and acknowledge them.

That is why I have no qualms about our condemning Dhemaji, or custodial deaths,
or blatant violations of the rule of law.



Now let me ask you something again:


What do you think? Is it likely that


NRAs might be energized
 > enough to consider returning to Assam, at least
 temporarily, or intermittently,
 to help reconstruction, should there be genuine,
 visible and believable
> governmental reforms and /or when so asked.


Or to rephrase it more directly:

That NRAS really have no faith in Assam Govts, be it the current one, be it the past ones, or be it some future one, based on the current model. But they might
have such faith in a future REFORMED one?


I know I am asking you to comment on something that MIGHT reflect negatively on your own beliefs. And as an incentive for you to comment forthrightly, you can ask me any leading question that might reflect negatively on my own leanings, and I promise to answer forthrightly.

You cannot get a better blank check than that can you?


Is it a deal :-).

c-da












At 7:48 PM -0800 2/7/05, ram Sarangapani wrote:
Hi C'da,

Wow! that was a marathon session you and Barua had!
-:)

Though, it may have frayed tempers a bit, it did bring
out the fact that we netters are passionate about
whats going on back home.

No, you are not confused Ram. You are just trying to
> pin me down and demonstrate to the world that I am
full of it .

No, far from it (you may find this hard to believe), there was no such intention - and least of the demo to the world etc, etc. Thats not my style.

I was confused a little, because from some of your
posts, I got the impression that the issues we are
trying to understand (vis-a-vis Assam) MIGHT be
construed as being condescending.

I do understand YOUR point that at times some NRAs do
tend to do that - tell the "natives" how its done. But
C'da, there are times, when many of us 'sincerely'
want to do something.

Yes, many a time, our approaches are just outright
wrong or over the top, but then, we also have
outspoken people in this net (or outside) who will
tell you frankly where and why we are going astray. I
think thats a good thing.

I don't go about waylaying unsuspecting
assam->netters, and play gotcha when they make a slip.

Ditto here. I never thought you did (maybe sometimes
in playful banter), but never as put-downs.

I never said a word until you guys badgered me to
open my mouth. I was happy to play I saw or heard
nothing.  Now you cry foul.

No such intention - but sorry if that was the impression 'we' gave out. For me at least, it was more to pick your brains (and ideas).

 What has happened was that I was dragged into an
 inquisition. You guys did not realize that an
 inquisition can dig up dirt to smear the diggers.

Ah! the Spanish. But, seriously, that was never a goal. I really did want a healthy discussion.

You catch my drift ?

I sure did.

Did I ever even imply that? But we ought to be aware
of or abilities and limitations, lest we get carried
away with our own righteousness, or sanctimony >and
/or bombast.

I did think that was the implication. But that part
about limitations, sanctimony - I agree. If anything
we can never afford to be pompous or scantimonious.

I have myself come across situations where some
Kharkhowas do project themselves to be that way. And I
do get teed off. But you will agree that there are
also Kharkhowas who are sincere in their efforts.

 Glad to hear that from you, even though I never
 suspected you of not knowing that.

I glad too. We are from that same stock, and yes, it would be presumptous to think otherwise.

But, back to the basics. In all sincerity, I would
like to know some thoughts about the proper role for
NRAs - from both you and Barua? What should be the
"practical"  approach? Those thought then could be
basis for some fruitful/positive discussions on the
net.

Now, this is NOT to snare either of you into some web
of deceit, I am weaving. I am sure, it will be to the
benefit of netters at large.

-Ram



--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

 At 3:59 PM -0800 2/6/05, ram Sarangapani wrote:
 >C'da,
 >
 >I am little confused. And it leads me to wonder if
 it
 >might be time for the NRA community to define what
 our
 >role is vis-a-vis Assam and her problems (if at all
 >there is a role).



 No, you are not confused Ram. You are just trying to
 pin me down
 and demonstrate to the world that I am full of it .




> >When we discuss, identify problems, or even 'think'
> >about possible solutions to these, it becomes
 pretty
 >easy to label us as being condescending, 'looking
 down
 >on the Assamese people' or 'assuming we are more
 >intelligent', or 'speaking for all of Assam', etc.


Yes, it would be easy. But it is so only when we say or do things making it that way.


I don't go about waylaying unsuspecting assam-netters, and play gotcha when they make a slip. Do I? I never said a word until you guys badgered me to open my mouth. I was happy to play I saw or heard nothing. Now you cry foul.


What has happened was that I was dragged into an inquisition. You guys did not realize that an inquisition can dig up dirt to smear the diggers.

 Lawyers would tell you never to ask leading
 questions unless
 you know there is NOT more than one good answer to
 the question,
 the answer you are seeking that is.

It is not a good idea to spit upwards, unless you
> are wearing a wide brimmed
 jaapi ( Tilokor Boson).

 If you p--- against the wind, you could soil
 yourself ( ancient
 Oxomiya wisdom- applicable to the male of the
 species only).

 If you try to jump over too wide a ditch you could
 fall,into it.
 MSBSP--Rule 12 of Guide to Happiness)

 Don't bite into more than you can swallow, you could
 choke to death
   ( mothers' advice to little children).


You catch my drift ?



 >So, what is the role we need to play? Most of us
 have
 >left Assam many moons ago - possibily never to
 return
 >on a permanent basis. So, are we out of this
 picture?
 >Is that your assessment?


I never proposed anything of that sort, have I? Did I ever even imply that? But we ought to be aware of or abilities and limitations, lest we get carried away with our own righteousness, or sanctimony and /or bombast.



 >We all know that there are very intelligent people
 in
 >Assam, and they know the problems better than we
 do.
 >And no one is trying to dictate what they should or
 >should not do.



 Glad to hear that from you, even though I never
 suspected you of
 not knowing that. Not even Rajen, until he
 pronounced that Assam is
 unfit to govern itself, a Churchillesque verdict,
 coming down from a
 kharkhowa, albeit being blessed as an NRA.



 >I feel that Barua was attempting to identify a set
 of
 >problems, we should at least give him a hearing and
 >discuss those issues. A sincere discussion on
 issues
 >should not be such a big deal.


You make it sound as though I was trying to shout Rajen or you, the other participants down. In fact I gave you a wide berth. I kept silent, and tried not to steal your thunder.

 And then you dragged me into it, kicking and
 screaming,
 and beat me up for keeping quiet, which is not in my
 nature
 and which I had to do with only great
 self-restraint.

 But I still did not say a THING about your list. I
 could have.
 I chose not to, because it would have generated
 another round
 of acrimony if I had expressed my views candidly.


>A sincere discussion on issues >should not be such a big deal.


No, not unless it has some other agenda, and when it is not so simplistic as some in that list of Rajen's were.



 >Just because some of us have moved into this
 country
 >permanently should not mean we have also divorced
 from
 >Assam/India? does it?


Did I say that?

 But to pretend we can enumerate or prioritize what
 the people of
 Assam may consider as serious problems, will be
 laughable. Maybe
 you all do have that ability. I know I don't.



 Finally, the POLL questions I raised: Kamal made his
 observations
 to taunt Assam Netters. But he did not realize that
 there could be
 something that he would much rather not see or hear
 about: That NRAs
> might be energized
 enough to consider returning to Assam, at least
 temporarily, or intermittently,
 to help reconstruction, should there be genuine,
 visible and believable
 governmental reforms and /or when so asked.
>

Do you think my observation above is without basis?
>

c-da.












>

=== message truncated ===


__________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com

_______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to