Ram:

 >See, I have no qualms blaming Delhi when they are
wrong. -:)



You are a fair man :-).


But if I am not mistaken there have been a lot of opposition expressed by both Assam and of course Manipur, for a very long time. In fact I recall some AASU led demonstrations and other such expressions of dissatisfaction, not to mention intellectuals' opposition to the GoI tactics, including articles published in forums such as Himal South Asia, Frontline etc. There have been editorials in the AT and the Sentinel, if I am not mistaken, even though these are of questionable usefulness if past experience is any guide.



We raised this issue of an underhanded and opaque deal-making strategy employed by Delhi on the Naga, Assam, Manipur imbroglio during the BJP regime, several years back, right here in Assam Net.



I suspect Wasbir is referring to either an absence or muted Assam Govt. reactions.


That of course is predictable. Imagine a Congress led state govt. giving its maa-baap at Indraprstha a hard time. They are compromised severely. Remember Hiteshwar Saikia's regime during the Rajib Gandhi's rule and where it led Assam to?


New Delhi has not done its homework


*** That is a very benevolent way to present it Ram. You are a very understanding person obviously :-).

Fact is Delhi has been doing its homework very diligently. It is yet another demonstration of a very old and time-tested tactic of the Center's: to make slimy deals to divide and rule. It backfired severely in Manipur. But it was predicted by observers who saw the handwriting on the wall.


Are the Nagas really asking for what truly belongs to
them or are they just going on territorial expansion?


*** I cannot answer that. But the point we must nor forget is how the Center has been dealing with it, by secret deal-making, dividing further an already polarized and seething group of peoples.

Any solution for the NE must include all,dealing with issues openly. But it is not convenient for the Center, it is NOT in Delhi's interests to have to deal with an unified NE.


c-da













At 7:09 AM -0800 2/9/05, ram Sarangapani wrote:
C'da,

Clearly, New Delhi has not done its homework in this
case. My feeling is they just wanted this decades long
problem to go away, and since the Nagas have dropped
the sovereignty demand, the Center thinks this is a
way out.

 I hope you are not suggesting it is Assam's own damn
 fault for not raising hell.

C'da, if Assamese do not think they have been wronged in this case, then the Center would assume its OK with them. That is the reason that Assamese should appraise the Center of the problems.

Another question, though, as I am not very familiar
with the Naga demands for territories. They claim
those areas inhabited by Nagas (even if they are in
Assam) should belong to Nagaland.

Are the Nagas really asking for what truly belongs to
them or are they just going on territorial expansion?

See, I have no qualms blaming Delhi when they are
wrong. -:)

--Ram



--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

 Ram:


>It is not the NSCN-IM, but New Delhi that is to blame >for the lack of direction in its handling of the peace >negotiations.



 Does this ring a bell:-)?

 Of course Delhi will wait till violence breaks out.
 And then the
 military would be deployed to restore order. Just
 like it always does.

 I hope you are not suggesting it is Assam's own damn
 fault for not
 raising hell.

 c-da


















At 6:42 AM -0800 2/9/05, ram Sarangapani wrote: >I wonder why there has not been much reaction in >Assam? >______________________________ > >Web| Feb 08, 2005 > >Naga Talks > >Jeopardizing Peace > >By failing to gather the courage to tell the NSCN-IM >leadership that the redrawing of the maps of the >volatile region in the Northeast, the government
> will
 >not only lose the Naga rebel group, sooner rather
 than
 >later when this reality has to be faced, but will
 also
 >create more enemies within.
 >
 >WASBIR HUSSAIN
 >After nearly eight years of peace talks, it now
 >appears to be clear that the faction of the rebel
 >National Socialist Council of Nagaland headed by
 >chairman Isak Chishi Swu and general secretary
 >Thuingaleng Muivah (NSCN-IM) is ready to give up
 its
 >demand for a 'sovereign' Naga homeland. New Delhi
 is
 >obviously happy, and, consequently, not rejecting
 >outright the next best option that the NSCN-IM is
 >pushing for - the integration of all Naga-inhabited
 >areas in the Northeast with the existing state of
 >Nagaland to constitute a single
 >politico-administrative unit.
 >
 >By failing to gather the courage to tell the
 NSCN-IM
 >leadership that the redrawing of the maps of this
 >volatile region was no easy task, however, the
 >government of India will not only lose the Naga
 rebel
 >group, sooner rather than later when this reality
 has
 >to be faced, but will also create more enemies
 within.
 >
 >This was more than demonstrated in the June 2001
 >uprising in Manipur when New Delhi announced the
 >extension of the ceasefire with the NSCN-IM
 "without
 >territorial limits", which was interpreted by the
 >people as a prelude to slicing off Naga-dominated
 >areas of the state for integration in a 'Greater
 >Nagaland'. The bloody protests that forced a
 reversal
 >of that announcement - eighteen protestors were
 killed
 >in police firing in the capital, Imphal, the
 Manipur
 >state Assembly Complex and dozens of government
 >buildings were set ablaze by angry mobs - are still
 >fresh in the minds of the people of the region.
 >
 >It is not the NSCN-IM, but New Delhi that is to
 blame
 >for the lack of direction in its handling of the
 peace
 >negotiations. The Manmohan Singh-led United
 >Progressive Alliance (UPA) government had stated in
 >its Common Minimum Programme (CMP) that "the
 >territorial integrity of existing states will be
 >maintained" in the Northeast, and that existing
 >geographical boundaries would not be altered. If
 that
 >is indeed the position of the Congress-led
 coalition
 >in New Delhi, the question of redrawing the map of
 the
 >northeastern states should not arise.
 >
 >Regrettably, New Delhi has tended to muddy the
 waters,
 >and Union Home Minister Shivraj Patil's
 contradictory
 >statements over the past week have exposed an
 >insensitivity to both the sentiments of the NSCN-IM
 >and of the people in the states of Assam, Manipur
 and
 >Arunachal Pradesh, whose territory the Naga rebel
 >group has set its sights on.
 >
 >On a visit to Assam's capital Guwahati, Patil
 reminded
 >journalists about the UPA's stand on not altering
 >existing geographical boundaries of the states.
 Once
 >back in Delhi, however, Patil refused to confirm
 >reports that had quoted him on this, and his
 ministry
 >officials said they were not aware of Patil having
 >given any assurances to anyone in Assam, Manipur or
 >Arunachal Pradesh that their territories would not
 be
 >dismembered.
 >
 >On February 3, 2005, moreover, after a meeting with
 >Patil, NSCN-IM leader Muivah declared that the Home
 >Minister had made it clear to them that the issue
 of
 >integration of Naga areas would definitely
 constitute
 >part of the negotiations that would follow between
 the
 >insurgent outfit and the group of Union Ministers
 >specially appointed to raise the peace talks to a
 >political level.
 >
 >On its part, the NSCN-IM has been consistent on its
 >integration demand, while it has now chosen silence
 on
 >its key slogan of an independent Naga homeland. At
 the
 >end of the two-day Naga People's Consultative
 Meeting
 >that ended on January 21, 2005, at Camp Hebron, the
 >NSCN-IM headquarters near Nagaland's commercial
 hub,
 >Dimapur, the rebel group issued a four-point
 >declaration:
 >
 >. .
 >unification of all Naga inhabited areas is a
> >legitimate demand of the Nagas and therefore
 >non-negotiable;
 >support for an honourable solution to the
 'Indo-Naga
 >problem' should be on the basis of the uniqueness
 of
 >Naga history and situation;
 >political solution should be found through peaceful
 >means;
 >government of India and the NSCN-IM should both
 uphold
 >utmost honesty and sincerity towards reaching a
 >political solution.
 >The NSCN-IM has come to regard the decision arrived
 at
 >the Consultative Meeting, attended by up to 10,000
 >people, as a 'mandate' from the Nagas for the
 >integration of all areas inhabited by them. Armed
 with
 >this 'mandate', Muivah stated in an interview at
 New
 >Delhi on February 1, 2005, that any attempt by the
 >government of India to resolve the Naga issue by
 >'appeasing' the Assamese, Meiteis (of Manipur) or
 the

=== message truncated ===




__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Read only the mail you want - Yahoo! Mail SpamGuard. http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail

_______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to