Danny Ayers wrote:
On Tue, 08 Feb 2005 10:40:43 +0000, Bill de h�ra <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

Henry Story wrote:

If you just want to stick to syntax, then please leave the pace
as it is. Don't try to impose a model through syntax and then
argue that people can't argue about the model that you are
surreptitiously trying to introduce.

Henry, I have no idea what you are talking about.


I think all Henry's referring to is the implicit model - only so much
is made explicit in the spec.

Oh no, is this one of those "do buildings have an intentional or extensional architecture or both" conversations? [I see your link now: yes it is. Damn.]


Anyway Henry seems to think I'm trying to impose a model (whatever it is). Otherwise why would he tell not me to impose it? That's why I said I have no idea what he's talking about. Henry, mindreading objection from me.


There's the "obvious" containership
semantics of XML,

XML has containership semantics? You jest methinks.


But don't let's kid ourselves what we have right
now is much more than a syntax and a model with
ArchitectureByImplication [1].

Fine, that's all fine - I'm not looking to kid anyone - I just don't care too much about what implicit model people happen to see from day to day, as I don't think it matters much to the format. If people willfully want to polarize themselves over some pet model, then they can have at, but not at the cost of shipping this spec. Has it occured that dragging this WG through an explicit model think-fest might not be helpful at this point?



10/10 for the Pace title, btw ;-)

Thank you.

cheers
Bill



Reply via email to