I agree with James. If feels more natural to have the arrow go from the
representation to the URI. The unjustifiable intuition would be that the
representation "knows" that it is an alternate representation of the resource,
but probably not vice versa. Another one would be that the link element is
attached to the representation, not to the uri.


In short proposal A reads "alternate" as "alternate representation of".


Proposal A ----------

replace

[[
The value "alternate" signifies that the IRI in the value of the href attribute identifies an alternate version of the resource described by the containing element.
]]


with:

[[
The value "alternate" signifies that the containing element is an alternative
representation of the resource identified by the IRI in the value of the href attribute.
]]



I have changed the name of the proposal below to Proposal B to make it easier
to discuss.


On 1 Apr 2005, at 12:45, James Aylett wrote:
On Fri, Apr 01, 2005 at 12:15:03PM +0200, Henry Story wrote:

Proposal B
----------

replace

[[
The value "alternate" signifies that the IRI in the value of the href
attribute identifies an alternate version of the resource described by
the containing element.
]]

with:

[[
The value "alternate" signifies that the IRI in the value of the href
attribute identifies a resource for which the containing element is an
alternative representation.
]]

The problem is that 'alternative', as used here, is not bidi: the statement you're proposing has (for me, at least) the implication that the most important representation is the one at the other end of the rel='alternate' arc.

What then makes this more confusing, for me, is that the text still
says "a resource", which gives the further implication that there
might be multiple /different/ resources for which the containing
element is an alternative representation. I'd have thought it would be
clearer to have the relation going the other way, so that the
containing element is the most important representation. From its
point of view, it is - and this is its metadata.

PS. grammarians might want to tell me of it is "of which" or "for
which".

I think it's "of which". It's clear either way, though, which is the important thing :)

James

-- /---------------------------------------------------------------------- ----\
James Aylett xapian.org
[EMAIL PROTECTED] uncertaintydivision.org





Reply via email to