On Apr 3, 2005 7:04 PM, Bill de h�ra <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Tim Bray wrote:
> >
> > On Apr 3, 2005, at 12:45 PM, Graham wrote:
> >
> >> So do you have an argument here as to why it should be required? All
> >> I'm seeing is that it's easy to workaround when the publisher omits it.
> >
> >
> > Agreed. Joe, that wasn't very convincing. I repeat, we've seen several
> > very believable use-cases for why someone might want this, and no good
> > arguments (that I can remember) that it would break anything. Sam has
> > pointed out that no previous version of RSS has done this, which is a
> > reasonable argument; except for we have use-cases, and nobody's shown
> > that the cost is non-zero. -Tim
>
> The top level feed stuff doesn't make a lot of sense to me. That
> @alternate is mandatory while @self and atom:id are not isn't very
> convincing either:
>
> atom:[EMAIL PROTECTED]'alternate'] : MUST
> atom:[EMAIL PROTECTED]'self'] : SHOULD
> atom:id : MAY
>
> You can't have a useful discussion about @alternate without talking
> about @self or atom:id.
>
> Thus: I'm -1 to downgrading @alternate unless @self is lifted to MUST or
> atom:id is lifted to MUST. If either are lifted to must I'm 0 on
> downgrading @alternate. At that stage @alternate doesn't matter a whole lot.
For me David Nesting's example of an Atom document as
an email attachment was the most convincing that @alternate
doesn't need to be a MUST.
I agree here with Bill and personally prefer to see atom:id lifted
to a MUST.
-joe
--
Joe Gregorio http://bitworking.org