Simon Brown has upgraded the Atom feed generated by his Pebble weblog software (http://pebble.sf.net/) to draft-10. I've reported a few problems with it, based on my understanding of the spec, but there are a couple of points that don't seem to be directly addressed. See:
http://www.simongbrown.com/jira/secure/ViewIssue.jspa?key=PEB-266 First, where does the spec actually say that the atom:id shouldn't change if the blog moves to a different domain? I think that if the URL of the blog changes, it means that the Atom Feed Document has been relocated so the ID should stay the same, but Simon doesn't see this in the spec. Second, what sort of values should be used for the scheme attribute on the category? Looking at http://www.tbray.org/ongoing/ongoing.atom as an authoritative example, it seems that the scheme should be the same for all categories, but Pebble uses the URL of the individual category page. The spec doesn't say, so does it matter? Can the list offer some advice? Thanks. (Reposted because the original didn't get through; my apologies for any duplicates. Look out for the Gmail Reply-To.) -- http://carey.geek.nz/
