James Holderness wrote:


James M Snell wrote:

This could all get rather complicated very quickly. My primary objective is to address known use cases for ordered feeds (my netflix queue feed[1] for example), most of which are structured as complete datasets that are non-incremental in nature.


I realise that this sort of thing sounds like a good idea from a content provider's point of view, but as an aggregator developer, this is probably the last thing I would want to support. A feed that is not incremental is not a feed IMHO. There are just too many special case complications that an aggregator developer has to deal with that have nothing to do with regular, honest-to-goodness feeds.

I do believe this falls under the Not-All-Feeds-Should-Be-Aggregated Category. That said, however, I think the concept of Feed-As-List is one that generally has a lot of support.

1. It helps us to scope the relevance of an i:rank element within an entry. For instance, if an entry with an i:rank in the urn:foo domain is aggregated into a synthetic feed that either a) does not specify a ranking domain or b) specifies a different ranking domain, consumers can safely ignore the urn:foo i:rank.

This kind of makes sense, but I'm not convinced it's necessary. If the feed has various ranks on which it can be sorted, I'd rather leave the decision on which one to use to the user. If, for whatever reason, those alternate domains are no longer applicable and the feed absolutely has to force the use of a particular domain, wouldn't it make more sense to filter out all those unused ranks rather than making the user download them?

i:domain is not used as a key of determining which rankings to use; it's a key that is used to correlate rankings. Regarding filtering, we should not rely on aggregators filtering out unused ranks. Consider the case of digitally signed entries; filtering out a rank covered by the digital signature would invalidate the signature.

2. It helps us to correlate ranks that span multiple feed documents. For instance, two separate feed documents may specify the same ranking domain.


This I like.

By the description given, it sounds as if the BBC ranking is more a ranking of relative importance than a ranking of natural order. That is, Top Story A has a higher importance that Top Story B, etc. If that is the case, a "priority" or "importance" ranking scheme can be used in conjunction with the atom:updated element.


This almost works. As an aggregator, what I would want to do is automatically sort with the date as the primary key and the priority as the secondary key. That way, today's high-priority items would appear at the top of the list, and yesterday's would follow on afterwards. Any of yesterday's items that were still of some importance today would need to have their atom:updated element set to today and their priority adjusted as appropriate.

There are couple of problems though. The atom:updated element has to be identical for all items on a particular day. Also the atom:updated element can't be changed when an actual update occurs (say a spelling correction, or an update on a story) without breaking the ordering. The problem is we're abusing the atom:updated element so as to use it for something that's it's not.

The updated elements would not need to be identical. Aggregators can easily determine whether or not entries with different updated values occured on the same day / same hour / etc. In other words, I could sort by Day+Priority, Hour+Priority, Minute+Priority, whatever, without any difficulty. There is no abuse of atom:updated here.

It would be better if we could add an extra attribute to your rank tag that specified what date the rank applied to. For someone like the BBC that reprioritizes feeds on a daily basis they'd set this attribute to something like say midnight for the date on which the ranking applies. If you have an item from a previous day that is still important today, it would keep its original atom:updated value, but the rank-date would be set to today.

I'll give this some thought, but my initial gut reaction is that it is not necessary. Let me see if I can convince myself otherwise ;-)


Regards
James

Thanks for the input!

- James


Reply via email to