On 14/09/2005, at 1:06 PM, David Powell wrote:
How will this interact with the sliding-window/feed-history interpretation of feeds? The natural order assigned by this extension seems incompatible with the implied date order that would be implied by two feed documents, polled over some period of time. What should be the order of a merged feed history such as this: Poll 1: feed(e1, e2, e3) Poll 2: feed(e3, e1, e5) - where, perhaps, 3 and 1 have been updated. How do you combine entries sorted by their natural order, with the time-ordered feed history?
There'd need to be an algorithm described for combing the feed documents; e.g., see the _combine() method in http://www.mnot.net/rss/ history/feed_history.py. In practice, most/all(?) popular aggregators do this now (feed history + natural order); the only change is that the algorithm would be documented and well-understood (which IMO would be a vast improvement, *if* we can agree on one... or more).
With the rank approach, you'd probably need to say that the ranks were valid within the scope of a single feed document, and then describe the relations between ranks in different feed documents. Not sure that's as interesting.
-- Mark Nottingham http://www.mnot.net/
