I concur and logged bug 4712829.

Regards,
Lance

Davanum Srinivas wrote:
Lance,

Please see a challenge for the
saaj\api\javax_xml_soap\Node\URLClient_getValueTest1_from_standalone test case from SAAJ TCK. Also
enclosed is the URLClient_getValueTest1_from_standalone.jtr output file.

Thanks,
dims



=====
Davanum Srinivas - http://xml.apache.org/~dims/

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Sign up for SBC Yahoo! Dial - First Month Free
http://sbc.yahoo.com

1. Licensee Name: Apache 2. TCK and version: SAAJ (saaj_tck-1_1-fcs-bin-06_jun_2002.zip) 3. SDK version: NA 4. Priority (low, medium, high, ): HIGH 5. Specification Reference: - Spec Name: SOAP with Attachments API for Java - Spec version : (SAAJ) v1.1 Maintenance Release - Spec date: June 2002 - Page/Section to reference: Section 2.8.3, Page 50. 6. Test Name(s): saaj\api\javax_xml_soap\Node\URLClient_getValueTest1_from_standalone 7. Problem Description: In getValueTest1 method in NodeTestServlet.java (Line 438) there is a check for a getValue and a comparison to an empty string (""). This is not the correct test according to the spec. The spec states clearly as follows: "a String with the text of the immediate child of this Node object if (1) there is a child and (2) the child is a Text object; null otherwise" So the TCK code must be changed to compare the return value as follows: if (value != null) { instead of the existing code if (!value.equals("")) {

-- 
Lance Andersen                       email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sun Microsystems Inc.                phone: (781) 442-2037
1 Network Drive, UBUR02-301          fax  : (781) 442-1610
Burlington, MA 01803

Reply via email to