Apakah Kuta Great Wall termasuk program Bali Clean and Green ? On Sat, Sep 18, 2010 at 7:20 PM, Nengah Sudja <nsu...@gmail.com> wrote:
> *Mbak** Vieb, Pak Nyoman Suwela,* > > > > Pembangunan Tembok Kuta sepanjang 1500 m dengan biaya 4 milyar Rp., > menunjukkan parahnya birokrasi kita. > > Pikiran pertama birokrasi, seperti mencari jelah, kesempatan kreasi > proyek, yang disebut * proyect oriented. * > > Bukannya *demand** oriented* yang didasarkan untuk memenuhi kebutuhan > utama, meninngkatkan sarana wisata KUTA. > > Apakah abrasi merupakan kebutuhan pertama, tentu masih bisa diperdebatkan > ?. > > > > Birokrasi kita masih tidak cerdik, untuk mencari solusi optimal yang > memberi solusi dengan biaya terendah (least cost). > > Birokrasi tak mau melepaskan kekuasaan (power ) mereka , keputusan agar > tetap dari atas ke bawah (* top down*) dan proses > > dari bawah ke atas (*bottom up*) tak mau dilakukan. > > Dengan demikian demokrasi belum jalan atau mati ! > > > > Tiada smart policy karena tidak adanya kesediaan untuk berdialog dengan > mengikutsertakan partisipasi public, > > shareholder utama ialah masyarakat setempat, termasuk juga pendapat > masyarakat wisatawan. > > > > Solusi yang baik dapat dilakukan dengan memakai jasa konsultan, apakah > dalam hal ini telah dilakukan?. > Tetapi mengikutsertakan masyarakat tetap diperlukan. Solusi tanam pohon > bukankah solusi yang lebih cerdas, murah, > > rindang, asri sekaligus bisa cegak abrasi? > > > > Seandainya birokrasi dapat berpikir ke demand oriented , penggunaan dana > 4 (empat) milyar Rp., akan dapat > > dimanfaatkan untuk kebutuhan lain yang lebih penting (seperti perbaikan > sanitasi, parkir , lalu lintas KAWASAN KUTA). > > > > *Karena** itu perbaikan birokrasi ( Eksekutif, Legislatif, Judikatif) > perlu dilakukan.* > > *Proses** Dengar Pendapat Birokrari dengan Masyarakat perlu dikembangkan.* > * * > > > > > > SALAM. > > Nengah Sudja. > > > > > > > > > > > ------------------------------ > > *From:* bali-bou...@lp3b.or.id [mailto:bali-bou...@lp3b.or.id] *On Behalf > Of *Suwela > *Sent:* Saturday, September 18, 2010 4:55 AM > > *To:* bali@lp3b.or.id > *Subject:* [bali] Re: KUTA GREAT WALL - sharing > > > > Stakeholders? Saya kira Sateholders. Saya pernah beli sate disana. Jadi > waktu itu saya juga "sateholder". Ha..ha..Kuta WAS a beach resort. It WAS > famous for its white sandy beach. Now it IS famous its beach wall. Ha..ha... > > Nyoman Suwela > ----------------------------------------- > Powered by Telkomsel BlackBerry® > ------------------------------ > > *From: *"Nengah Sudja" <nsu...@gmail.com> > > *Sender: *bali-bou...@lp3b.or.id > > *Date: *Fri, 17 Sep 2010 21:09:14 +0700 > > *To: *<bali@lp3b.or.id>; <bali-b...@yahoogroups.com> > > *ReplyTo: *b...@lp3b.or.id > > *Subject: *[bali] Re: KUTA GREAT WALL - sharing > > > > *Mbak Vieb,* > > > > Seperti tembok Berlin ya. > > > > Contoh proyek top down, semau gue. > > > > Partisipasi masyarakat tak ikut diajak. > > > > Kasihan. > > > > > > SALAM. > > Nengah Sudja. > > > ------------------------------ > > *From:* bali-bou...@lp3b.or.id [mailto:bali-bou...@lp3b.or.id] *On Behalf > Of *Asana Viebeke Lengkong > *Sent:* Friday, September 17, 2010 6:33 PM > *To:* bali@lp3b.or.id; bali-b...@yahoogroups.com > *Subject:* [bali] KUTA GREAT WALL - sharing > > > *Tourists, experts reject ‘Great Wall’ of Kuta* > > Luh De Suriyani, The Jakarta Post, Kuta, Badung | Fri, 09/17/2010 10:19 AM > | Bali > > Danny Yatim, a frequent visitor to Bali, was startled when he saw a “great > wall” being built along the once-pristine Kuta Beach. > > Over the last few months, Badung regional administration has been > constructing a two-meter concrete fence made from white sandstones, which > some said has also hidden the beauty of the white sands and great waves of > Kuta Beach. > > The project is estimated to cost over Rp 4 billion (US$444,000) to complete > is intended to protect Kuta and Legian area from tidal and sea abrasion. > Fences that will span more than 1,500 meters will be built along Kuta and > Legian Beach, Bali’s most famous tourist destinations. > > “For those travelling to Kuta, here’s another weird development that I call > ‘Kuta Wall’. If you are driving, riding, walking, strolling on the main road > or sipping coffee at a ground floor cafe, you can no longer see the blue > ocean. So, sorry guy, just enjoy the wall,” shared Danny. > > Dozens of people shared unfavorable comments on the “Kuta Wall” on social > networking sites such as Twitter and Facebook. > > “I just wonder why the local government is building such an environmentally > unfriendly construction,” Danny said. > > Visitors could only view the wall instead of the beautiful beach when > strolling along Kuta area, he added. > > Kuta resident and activist Asanna Vibeke Lengkong said that the local > administration should not build such a wall. > > “They could plant trees or other vegetation to protect the areas from > abrasion. > > “[Kuta Beach] can still look friendly, open and beautiful,” Lengkong said. > > Kuta and Legian are located in Badung regency, the richest of the island’s > eight regencies and mayoralties. > > “[Badung administration] has a lot of money and they do not know how to > spend it. Nothing is spent on the poor or for education. They should spend > it on education, health and people’s welfare instead of building such a > wall,” Lengkong said. > > The walls were built using traditional elaborate Balinese architectural > motifs. > > The gates in front of Hard Rock Hotel were built in homage to Bentar Temple > in a style reserved for royal palaces, big temples and important buildings. > The construction of the gates near the hotel cost > Rp 500 million, she said. > > Badung administration spokesman I Gede Wijaya said that the walls were > built with three principals in mind. > > First, Wijaya said that previous fences, which had been comprised of stone > walls and plants, did not reflect Balinese architectural motifs. > > Second, many tourists lodged complaints that Kuta Beach produces abundant > sand storms during the rainy season. > > Third, Wijaya said that Bentar Temple and the walls could be beautiful > backdrops for photographers. “We do not take the protests seriously. It’s > common for people to do that. We did outreach programs prior to starting > construction,” Wijaya said. > > Project head Retno Hapsari said that she has already consulted with all > stakeholders in Kuta, including hotel owners, community leaders and other > related parties. > > “All of them agreed to the project,” she argued. > > Noted architect Yoka Sara said that the construction of concrete walls at > public facilities was not necessary. > > “True Balinese architecture has no need for fences in public places such as > markets, cemeteries and other public areas,” Sara said. > > The development of fences and gates using the grand styles of Balinese > architecture is a waste of money and not functional, she added. > > “It is easy for the local administration to spend money unwisely. The > buildings should not be designed with such an elaborate style. Physically, > the walls create uncomfortable and unfriendly atmosphere for visitors,” Sara > said. > > > -- Gde Wisnaya Wisna Jl.Dewi Sartika Utara 32A Singaraja-Bali website : www.lp3b.com
