Jadi MMR aja nih ya? Cuek? Aduh kenapa ya, kok masih rada ngeri... hehehe.. belum ada yang berhasil convince saya nih... :- Gimana dong...
On 9/12/05, intan dima <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > infonya salah mbak.... jepang buanyakkk kasus autis hehehehe > coba silahkan dibaca dibawah ini... > saya juga ada beberapa artikel ttg tidak ada hubungannya antara mmr dan > autisme, tapi dalam bhs jepang.... > > http://curezone.com/forums/m.asp?f=74&i=928 > Autism in the absence of MMR vaccine > http://www.jr2.ox.ac.uk/bandolier/booth/Vaccines/noMMR.html > Clinical bottom line > Autism rates in Japan continued to rise after the withdrawal of MMR > vaccine. > > > > -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- > > Reference > H Honda et al. No effect of MMR withdrawal on the incidence of autism: a > total population study. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 2005 > doi: > 10.1111/j.1469-7610.2005.01425.x > Background > A link has been postulated between the specific use of the triple MMR > vaccine and the rise of childhood autism. Though very considerable > research > has shown there to be no connection, some people continue to believe in > such > a link and they propose use of single vaccines instead. In Japan, MMR > vaccine was introduced in 1989, but the programme was terminated in 1993 > and > only single vaccines used thereafter. > > The experience of Japan therefore constitutes a real-world experiment of > replacing triple MMR vaccine with single vaccines because of problems with > production. If the proponents of a link between MMR and autism are > correct, > the result should be that cases of autism fall after withdrawal of MMR. > > Study > The study was conducted in a part of Yokohama with a population of about > 300,000, and which was stable, or reflected changes typical for Japanese > society as a whole, over the period of the study. The population was > served > by a special centre (Yokohama Rehabilitation Centre) that included a > developmental psychiatry unit with early intervention services for > developmental disorders. There was in place an early detection and > intervention system that included specific routine checkups at four, 18 > and > 36 months, working to defined diagnostic criteria. At 18 months, about 90% > of children participated in the programme, but those who did not, or those > who were missed by the programme, could be referred by nurseries, > paediatric > clinics, or other services. These services began in 1987, two years before > introduction of MMR. > > Not only did the study have specific diagnostic criteria, therefore, but > also ensured a complete coverage of a defined population, consistently > over > a period covering the introduction and withdrawal of the triple MMR > vaccine. > > Each birth cohort from 1988 to 1996 was followed up to age seven years, > and > results presented for all autistic spectrum disorders, for autism, and for > autism associated with regression. The cumulative incidence per 10,000 > children for each diagnosis was calculated for each year. > > Results > Over the whole period, and with full follow up to age seven years in birth > cohorts from 1988 to 1996, 278 children developed autistic spectrum > disorder, 158 autism, and 120 other autistic spectrum conditions. Of those > with autism, 60 had definite regression and another 12 probable regression > according to defined tests. > > In the 1988 birth cohort, 70% of children had the MMR triple vaccine, > falling to 1.8% in the 1992 birth cohort. Thereafter no children had the > MMR > triple vaccine (Figure 1). > > Figure 1: Autistic conditions in birth cohorts to age seven years, and MMR > vaccination rate in Japan: autism, all autistic spectrum disorders (ASD), > and autism with regression > > The incidence of all autistic spectrum disorders, and of autism, continued > to rise after MMR vaccine was discontinued. The incidence of autism was > higher in children born after 1992 who were not vaccinated with MMR than > in > children born before 1992 who were vaccinated. The incidence of autism > associated with regression was the same during the use of MMR and after it > was discontinued. > > The increase of autistic spectrum disorders was evident in children with > higher IQ. > > Comment > The increase in autism and autistic spectrum disorders in this part of > Yokohama displays the same increase over time seen in other parts of the > world. Here, though, the increase occurred even when the MMR vaccine was > withdrawn. This destroys any possible causative link between use of the > vaccine and autism. > > Perhaps the most important features of the study were that it > comprehensively covered a population, and that the population was served > by > a special service testing children for developmental; disorders and using > standard methods over the whole period. The quality and validity of the > study is superlative, and the size good. > > Whatever causes autism, it is not the MMR vaccine. > > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Shannon Hartono" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: <balita-anda@balita-anda.com> > Sent: Saturday, September 10, 2005 12:00 PM > Subject: Re: [balita-anda] Fw: [sehat] Re: Menyikapi Kontroversi Autisme > dan > Imunisasi MMR > > > Mbak Intan, > Ada teman yang mengatakan bahwa di Jepang itu MMR tidak di berikan melalu > 1 > suntikan, melainkan 3 suntikan yang berbeda sehingga tidak terjadi > chemical > imbalance dan memperkecil kemungkinan MMR. Dia juga mengatakan bahwa > karena > ini lah, di Jepang belum di temukan kasus autis. Do you think this is > true? > Karena kalau memang demikian, berarti kita seharusnya bisa minta pada > dokter > untuk memberikan 3 suntikan yang berbeda dong, masing2 untuk measles, > mumps > dan rubella secara terpisah? Apa dokter di Indonesia bisa melakukan ini? > Thanks ya. > Cheers, > Shannon > > >
