On the subject of using PennHip to shorten the time frame for evaluating
progeny:

Personally, I will not use Penn Hip as I have had dogs injured by it as have
others.  When I sell a puppy, it is against my sales contract to use PennHip
before the age of 12 months.  This is my opinion and I'm not trying to
debate Penn Hip here as I will not change my mind.

However, this is a mute point as Penn Hip doesn't give you elbows anyway
which puts you right back to the same time frame used by OFA.  I feel that
currently elbows are a worse problem in this breed than hips.

I'd be more inclined to use OVC (Canadian Registry that certifiies at 18
months) than Penn Hip.  I can tell you for a fact that many reputable and
honorable BMDCA breeders are now using OFA prelims since we have lost GDC.

Personally, I see no problem with this as all the registries are one tool in
a very large picture.  I like to see the x-rays myself in the presense of a
skilled radiologist/vet and make my decision based on that along with the
results of a registry.  I don't use any registry as a Bible on which dog to
breed.

Flames happily deleted,

Dawn Gabig, Classique Berners, Kansas City USA
Our Website: http://ClassiqueBMD.homestead.com
FREE Graphics:  http://ClassiqueBMDs.homestead.com/graphics.html
Heartland Club Website: http://www.hbmdc.org/

Reply via email to