Hi Group, I think the National Anthem is made not to address all, but to hold all in a single bond and to create a feeling of patriotism in all. If we all can sing it coherently with that feeling, then doesn't matter if it has "Bharat Bhagya Bidhata" in it.
Correctly said that now "Sindh" is not a part of our country. But to modify a national anthem with the changing geography of the country is not at all a good idea. Because, it will take years to get the same spirit with a new anthem. Even if "Sindh" is not there, I can feel the same intensity of the anthem. Regarding RGV's Rann. He or NOBODY should not be allowed to play with NATIONAL ANTHEM. Because, then the real motto of the anthem will be lost. No body would feel pride or respect the anthem and we all will be in loose again. Regards, Sudhir --- In [email protected], "Govind... Hoping for better" <hopegov...@...> wrote: > > I am agree with Mr. Rakesh. > What is the use if someone hoist national flag dawn to dusk and corrupt and > this is the truth. > Even there is controversy in national anthem. > "bharat Bhagya Vidhata".. who is this > What our national anthem is saying, is it praising Bharat as a nation? I > don't feel so > > Jana Gana Mana Adhinayaka Jaya hai Bharat Bhagya Vidhata.. can we understood > it is from people, evenry people, from heart we praise the master of India > (British or President of India? Who is this Bharat Bhagya Vidhata?? > > Panjab Sindh Gujrat Maratha, Dravid Utkala Banga > Vindhya Himachala Yamuna Ganga uchchhala Jaladhi Tarang.. (I agree but where > is Sindh in India? After this many states have been formed, it does not > include all these names) > > Tava Shubh name jage, tav shubh aashish mange, gaye tab jaye gatha > Jana Gana mangal dayak jaya hai Bharat Bhagya Vidhata... (Again praising for > Bhagya Vidhata..) > > About the RGV film, RGV is not aperson who has respect for nation or like > that. His main intention is to make movie and earn money but in any case, as > we have freedom to express, I don't see there is anything to wrong in > expressing dissatisfaction over whatever have been told to us. > > If we analyse situation of the nation, some years back, in politician there > was fear of public outcry, media etc but now, everything corruption as well > as others have very common and noone fears. Our country is definitely not > developing. We have 128 criminal MPs (officially, unofficial figures must be > thrice) Juduciary is powerless and puppet of rulers. Under such > circumstances it is not crime. It would have been crime if someone had made > its remix and wouldn't have taken it seriously > > Jaya he > > Regards > Govind > > > On 08/05/2009, Rakesh Agarwal <rak...@...> wrote: > > > > > > > > Amitabh, I believe that we cannot have true freedom unless our citizens > > and even the foreigners in India have the right to burn our flag and the > > constitution. It is best to have such feelings come out than the anger > > boiling within. In the last 5 months, I have had 2 occasions when I wanted > > to toss the constitution myself. If the Delhi High Court itself cannot > > respect the constitution, what good is it? > > > > > > > > In any case, respect comes from within. A person may hoist the tricolour on > > top of his house from dawn to dusk everyday and may be corrupt beyond > > imagination. Another may want to make an underwear (is illegal) of the > > tricolour and be an upright man of impeccable integrity and honesty. > > > > > > > > Virtues such as patriotism cannot be legislated. > > > > > > > > We waste our time on non-issues when we discuss and get worked up about > > insult to the flag (even accidental), and obscene song in the movie Bhool > > Bhoolaiya. Such issues hardly matter to the half-naked and hungry man with a > > family to feed but not a grain in the mud-house. Shouldnât we be working > > instead to reduce/eliminate their misery? > > > > > > > > Rakesh Agarwal > > > > > > > > > > > > *From:* [email protected] [mailto: > > [email protected]] *On Behalf Of *Amitabh Thakur > > *Sent:* 08 May 2009 13:12 > > *To:* [email protected] > > *Subject:* [rti4empowerment] Jana Gana Mana and RGV- Amended > > > > Friends, > > > > Extremely sorry. The Hindi font from Gmail which I used was a huge > > disappointment. > > This made me feel like an ass with the Hindi saying (Chaube gaye the chabbe > > banane, Dube ban ke aa gaye) fitting me like anything. > > I present the song again- > > Jana Gana Mana Rann hai > > Iss rann mein zakhmi hua hai Bharat ka bhagya vidhata > > Vindhy, Himachal, Yamuna, Ganga mein tezaab ubal rahaa hai > > Mar gayaa hai sabka zameer > > jaane kab zinda ho aage > > Phir bhi tav shubh naame jaage > > Tav shubh aashish maange > > > > As already stated these words from a RGV Film Rann are courting > > controversy. That apart, do these lines really come under the realm of some > > legal proceedings for having distorted the National anthem and for having > > showed disrespect to it? Hence can it be called a crime in any way? or is it > > just an outlet of emotions in one's own creative ways? > > > > Amitabh Thakur > > SP (Intll), > > Faizabad > > # 94155-34526 > > > > > > > > > > -- > ______________________________ > Don't sit and cry that nothing will change here. If you are a responsible > person, be an agent of change, accept responsibility to bring changes.. > > Revolution is waiting for you... > Govind- 9960704146 >
