First and foremost, I disagree with the gentleman that said it mattered what 
type of hard drive manufacturer you decide to opt for.

Western Digital drives use Seagate drives, and the only thing you're 
actually paying for is the name, so, you'll end up paying an extra 50 to 80 
dollars just because you opted to go with a name brand rather than the 
lesser known names like LACI or Razor, both of which use Seagate drives in 
their enclosures.

In fact, the biggest consideration when purchasing an external drive is what 
type of enclosure you'd like to get, either a self powered one, which means 
forget about plugging it into a USB 1.0 port, or an enclosure that utilizes 
an outside power source like an AC Adapter.

The second consideration is the type of interface you want to choose.  For 
the price the gentleman  stated of 160 dollars, you'll end up paying for a 1 
TB drive from Western Digital and you'll have to end up with a USB 
connection, when, for the same price, you can shop around, not go with a 
name brand drive, and get one with a higher seek time and RPM, multiple 
interfaces like network connectivity, which means you'll be able to access 
it across the board on all of your computers connected to the same network 
independently of a second computer, or firewire and SCSI interfaces.  Either 
way, don't flush money down the toilet going for a name brand when the 
enclosure is more apt to fail than the drive, assuming no accidents happen.

I just purchased a rugged 2.5 terabyte drive which can be dropped from a 
height of three to four feet and it won't get damaged.  It cost me all of 
110 dollars at Best Buy, and it's a LACI drive, which, as I mentioned, uses 
Seagate drives inside their enclosures.

Speaking of the drive I purchased, .  I just remembered another 
consideration you may want to consider, especially if you're going to be 
sitting this drive on an unstable surface that rocks just from the typing 
action of your keyboard.

Get a drive/enclosure that doesn't require it stand up on it's end, and must 
lay down on it's side.

I don't want to tell you the number of horror stories I've heard of people 
who've bumped their desks with their hips, *I mean, we are blind after all*, 
and then hear a clunk when their hard drives tip over, then they're 
surprised that they can't access their drives and it's ticking like a time 
bomb.  Smiles.

Either way, I would seriously not recommend you get a name brand drive like 
Western Digital, and pick yourself up a more economical drive that is loaded 
with features and not branding, I can almost guarantee you won't be 
disappointed.

Scorpio 


For answers to frequently asked questions about this list visit:
http://www.jaws-users.com/help/

Reply via email to