I don't know if there is an exact standard for when to use tape and when it's too large an opening for tape alone.
I don't like to go much more than two inches with tape alone. Once a hole is larger than that, I will use another piece of drywall to fill the hole first. In order to use drywall, you first have to span the hole with a board from the back side. Otherwise, the piece will just fall behind the wall. If the hole is real large, you may need to use more than one backer board to make a strong repair. Cut a length of board a few inches longer than the opening. Drive a screw into the center of the board to use as a handle. Now tilt the board until both ends are behind the sheetrock. This is where you prove your skill. While holding the screw in the center, you will need to drive a screw through the sheetrock and into the board. Once the board is pulled tight to the back side of the sheetrock, you can remove the screw in the center. Now you can cut a piece of spare sheetrock to fit in the opening and also screw it to the backer board. Cover the area with tape and now apply the joint compound. While it is so tempting to use your fingers, you have found out why it isn't such a good idea. In time you will learn to listen to the sound the trowel makes as you spread the compound. It will almost be a hissing sound when the angle is right. I haven't been following the threads as close so in case no one has said it yet; apply with a smaller putty knife or trowel, then spread it out with a wider one. I use a 12 inch wide trowel to feather the edges of the compound. And as hard as it is, once you have done the feathering in, just get away from it and let it dry. Each time you touch it, you make another repair for yourself. ----- Original Message ----- From: blake To: blindhandyman@yahoogroups.com Sent: Friday, August 27, 2010 4:44 AM Subject: [BlindHandyMan] my experiences with sheetrock compound so far Hey all, ok so i decided if i messed things up bad with this stuff i would call for help ahha. Anyway so this stuff that i have comes with a puddy knife that i haven't found much use for as of yet. I have been just taking this stuff and basicly smearing it in to the whole with my fingers until it gets over the whole and then i just wait for it to dry. The reason i want it to come up over the whole a bit is so that i can make sure that it got in there really good. Im going to be sanding it down anyway so i don't guess it matters. So is your fingers the best thing for this that you have found? Or have some of you used the puddy knife or a different way of doing this? The problem that i have is that after a while you tend to get allot of your fingers and its hard to tell whats in the whole and what is just sticking to your fingers. Anyway any help guys? The stuff that i got just dries and when it does its like a pouder. Should i use tape at all? Thanks. [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]