For many years (dating back to when I maintained Texinfo), the way
Texinfo gets to CTAN is that I download the distribution tarball(s),
unpack it in ftp://tug.org/tex/texinfo*, and CTAN mirrors from there.
The CTAN metadata does not get updated in that process. It would not be
simple to do that. At best we could remove all the version-specific
stuff in the metadata, as we've done with other mirrored packages.

The slightly-stale texinfo.zip file was probably autocreated on the CTAN
end at one point.

In any case ... overall, I don't see a good reason to keep the Texinfo
sources/distribution on CTAN nowadays, and I'd be happy to stop doing
the manual mirroring. Thus my suggestion is

1) delete CTAN:macros/texinfo/texinfo and texinfo.zip;
2) I will delete the texinfo directories on tug.org;
3) CTAN and I can work out some description so that
   https://ctan.org/pkg/texinfo explains the situation. 
   
Also, not related to the original report, but while we're here, I
suggest moving CTAN:macros/texinfo/contrib, or rather its single subdir
texinfo-hu, to obsolete (and deleting contrib/). It contains a version
of texinfo.tex from 2007, adapted to (if I remember right) Hungarian. I
can't imagine that it is still of any use today.

That will just leave macros/texinfo/latest, which contains only those
files which are updated on their own on ftp.gnu.org. That can remain
unchanged.

What does everyone think? --thanks, karl.

Reply via email to