Sorry for the delay in replying.

Sarah Jelinek wrote:
> Hi Sanjay,
>
> A few questions...
>
> Under Assumptions:
>>  Since OpenSolaris supports only ZFS root file system, this is the 
>> only root file system that is
>>  supported. In addition for zones only ZFS zone roots are supported.
>
> For clarification, does this mean we only copy data from the root 
> pool, or root pools if there are multiple(and allowed for multiple 
> root pools)? The reason I ask is that the ZFS root filesystem, /, 
> today does not have separate /var or /usr. I know that there is talk 
> of allowing for a separate /var dataset, which means that this dataset 
> could live in another zpool(not the root pool). So, is the plan to 
> 'follow' any datasets that are part of the BE's? Even if it means 
> spanning pools?
 I am not envisioning dataset  spanning pools.   S10 with ZFS root 
support is also strongly recommending that zone roots be in the root 
pool.   I this plan to stick with that.
>
>
>> No user data payload. Flash provided the ability to include user file 
>> systems. This was
>> reasonable when disks were much smaller and data was closely tied to 
>> the system. Today, most
>> user data is either on a NAS or SAN device and they can be huge. User 
>> data is often separately
>> backed up. Hence it does not it does not make sense to include user 
>> payload.
>
> I have been thinking about this, and I am assuming you mean that we 
> won't copy anything outside of what is defined in the BE's, which 
> right now is anything under rpool/ROOT/. So, /export/home is in the 
> shared dataset space and would not be copied?
That is correct.
> I am asking because what does this mean for zones that have datasets 
> as resources that are not in the root pool? Or a device as a resource. 
> It sounds as if there is a possibility that some zones configurations 
> will not be fully functional or bootable on the new system if we are 
> only copying the content of the BE's.
>
Yup..but I don't quite see a way around this.  Perhaps the zones team 
has some thoughts here.



-Sanjay

> Requirements:
>
>> Master images must support global and non-zones.
>
> We should probably outline in more detail what the specific 
> requirements for non-global zones is.
>
> that's it for now.
>
> thanks,
> sarah
> ****
> sanjay nadkarni (Laptop) wrote:
>> Caimanics,
>>    Please review the requirements documents for replication in 
>> OpenSolaris.  This  provides the the  Flash type functionality but 
>> includes support for zones.
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>> -Sanjay
>>
>>
>> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> caiman-discuss mailing list
>> caiman-discuss at opensolaris.org
>> http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/caiman-discuss


Reply via email to