Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com>, Danny =?utf-8?q?Mösch?= <danny.moe...@icloud.com> Message-ID: In-Reply-To: <llvm.org/llvm/llvm-project/pull/80...@github.com>
sam-mccall wrote: Hey folks, I'm glad the clangd code for designators was useful, but this dep from clangd into the middle of tidy::utils isn't really OK - clangd depends on tidy only for the purposes of running tidy checks. It would have been appropriate to have a clangd reviewer on this. AFAIK the best place we have for code shared between tools is as a new library under `Tooling` - it's not a perfect fit, but there's precedent for this in `Tooling/Inclusions`. As a shared library, this would also need unit tests distinct from the integration tests in tidy+clangd. I'm not sure how best to proceed here - if it's possible to agree soon on a fix forward, let's do that, otherwise I'd plan to revert next week and you can fix as you see fit (extract a shared library, copy the code, etc). https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/80541 _______________________________________________ cfe-commits mailing list cfe-commits@lists.llvm.org https://lists.llvm.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/cfe-commits
