Reflection: Poor repair, poor maintance,  poor knowledge but  big mouth and 
rich in corruption 

http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/home/article/20519.html

May 21, 2009 


Putri Prameshwari, Amir Tejo, Fery Irwanto & Markus Junianto Sihaloho

Plane's Age, Poor Repair Blamed for Military Crash That Killed 98

Lawmakers and aviation experts said aging equipment and woefully inadequate 
maintenance by the Armed Forces were at the root of a military transport 
plane's crash in East Java, as the first burials began on Thursday of the 
scores of passengers killed. 

Aviation observer Dudi Sudibyo said the Air Force needed a bigger budget for 
maintenance, calling the current Rp 35 trillion ($3.2 billion) from the state 
budget insufficient. "Facility maintenance is as important as the soldiers' 
welfare," he said. 

The Hercules C-130 plane, carrying 99 passengers and 11 crew members, crashed 
in Geplak village, in East Java's Magetan district, on Wednesday as it was 
preparing to land, killing 96 people on board and two residents on the ground. 
Fifteen others were injured. 

The plane was carrying military personnel and their families from Jakarta to 
Papua, with its first stop at East Java's Iswahyudi Air Base. The precise cause 
of the crash is under investigation.

Theo Sambuaga, who chairs House of Representatives Commission I overseeing 
security and defense, said the military's weapon systems were in poor condition 
and had to be replaced. "There should be an audit of all military facilities," 
he said. 

In the last month, there have been 120 deaths in three military aircraft 
accidents across the country. In April, a Fokker-27 crashed into an airport 
hangar before bursting into flames at Bandung's Hussein Sastranegara 
International Airport, killing 24 people. It had been carrying soldiers and an 
instructor from Jakarta.

Last week, another Hercules C-130 lost its rear landing gear on landing in 
Papua's Jayawijaya district and slammed into a house, injuring a resident. The 
crash prompted authorities in Jakarta to order a thorough inspection of all 
Hercules C-130 planes, including those that had just had maintenance checks in 
Singapore.

Indonesia's civil aviation industry has many of the same problems, with 
multiple fatal crashes and mishaps in recent years blamed on inadequate 
maintenance or safety procedures.

In the wake of the latest crash, Vice President Jusuf Kalla said the state's 
annual allocation to the Armed Forces ­- estimated at less than a third of its 
total budget - was insufficient. Defense Minister Juwono Sudarsono has said the 
minimum to ensure a fully professional military is at least Rp 100 trillion a 
year. Only Rp 36.4 trillion was allotted in 2008, and of that only Rp 3.98 
trillion went to the Air Force.

Sudarsono on Wednesday said that less than 10 percent of the defense budget 
went to the maintenance of main armament systems, while ideally it should be 
20 percent to 25 percent. According to a recent report on Air Force equipment, 
only 27 of 75 jet fighters are said to be airworthy and 21 of 53 transport 
aircraft can fly.

In January, the Ministry of Defense announced three preferred candidates for a 
$7.2 million tender to upgrade the aging C-130 Hercules aircraft. The ministry 
said Malaysia-based Aerod, Canada's Standard Aero and England's Rolls-Royce 
were invited to Jakarta to discuss bids. 

President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono on Wednesday met senior Armed Forces and 
government figures to discuss the crash. "I, on behalf of the government and 
personally, would like to express my deepest condolences to the victims' 
families," he said.

Burials occurred on Thursday in Banten and Yogyakarta, and multiple others were 
expected today and this weekend.

 

Kirim email ke