commits  

Messages by Thread

• • Re: [PR] [#10410] improve(authn) : OAuth2 authentication supports obtaining user group information [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10410] improve(authn) : OAuth2 authentication supports obtaining user group information [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10410] improve(authn) : OAuth2 authentication supports obtaining user group information [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10410] improve(authn) : OAuth2 authentication supports obtaining user group information [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10410] improve(authn) : OAuth2 authentication supports obtaining user group information [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10410] improve(authn) : OAuth2 authentication supports obtaining user group information [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10410] improve(authn) : OAuth2 authentication supports obtaining user group information [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10410] improve(authn) : OAuth2 authentication supports obtaining user group information [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10410] improve(authn) : OAuth2 authentication supports obtaining user group information [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10410] improve(authn) : OAuth2 authentication supports obtaining user group information [gravitino] via GitHub
• [PR] [#10502] fix(ci): update docker actions from @v3 to @v3.6.0 [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10502] fix(ci): update docker actions from @v3 to @v3.6.0 [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10502] fix(ci): pin docker actions to SHA for v4.0.0 [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10502] fix(ci): pin docker actions to SHA for v4.0.0 [gravitino] via GitHub
• [I] [Bug report] CI failed due to docker/setup-qemu-action@v3 is not allowed(3/23/2026) [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [I] [Bug report] CI failed due to docker/setup-qemu-action@v3 is not allowed(3/23/2026) [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [PR] [SIP] support multiple Flink version code [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch branch-1.2 updated: [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#10175]improvement(PartitionOperations): include partition path parameter in getPartition error handling (#10388) (#10483) jshao
• (gravitino) branch cherry-pick-5a3c5953-to-branch-1.2 deleted (was e2444acea7) jshao
• (gravitino) branch cherry-pick-5a3c5953-to-branch-1.1 deleted (was 7b22fab746) jshao
• (gravitino) branch branch-1.1 updated: [Cherry-pick to branch-1.1] [#10175]improvement(PartitionOperations): include partition path parameter in getPartition error handling (#10388) (#10484) jshao
• [PR] [#9710] refactor(flink-connector): add versioned Flink catalog entries [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9710] refactor(flink-connector): add versioned Flink catalog entries [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [I] [Subtask] Spark,Flink and Trino connectors support credential vending [gravitino] via GitHub
• [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9536] feat(core): Add event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
• [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitin… [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10280] Support Iceberg snapshot maintenance procedures via Gravitino Trino [gravitino] via GitHub
• [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9736] feat(iceberg-rest): Support freshness-aware table loading with ETag [gravitino] via GitHub
• [PR] [#10496] improvement(lance): Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10496] improvement(lance): Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10496] improvement(lance): Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10496] improvement(lance): Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10496] improvement(lance): Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10496] improvement(lance): Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10496] improvement(lance): Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10496] improvement(lance): Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10496] improvement(lance): Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10496] improvement(lance): Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
• [I] [Improvement] Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [I] [Improvement] Clean up redundant code in GravitinoLanceTableOperations#createTable [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [I] [Improvement] Fix missing MyBatis @Param for role soft-delete mapper binding [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [I] [Improvement] Fix missing MyBatis @Param for role soft-delete mapper binding [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch cherry-pick-20e2ae1e-to-branch-1.2 deleted (was 8822f88767) roryqi
• (gravitino) branch branch-1.2 updated: [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#9518] improvement(authz): support batch get owner (#9914) (#10489) roryqi
• Re: [I] [Subtask] Event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [I] [Subtask] Event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [I] [Subtask] Event listener for function operations [gravitino] via GitHub
• [PR] [#9538] feat: Add Ray and Dask AI engine integration for UDF management [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9538] feat: Add Ray and Dask AI engine integration for UDF management [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9538] feat: Add Ray and Dask AI engine integration for UDF management [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9538] feat: Add Ray and Dask AI engine integration for UDF management [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9538] feat: Add Ray and Dask AI engine integration for UDF management [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9538] feat: Add Ray and Dask AI engine integration for UDF management [gravitino] via GitHub
• [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#9533] feat(trino-connector): Add UDF adaptation for Trino connector [gravitino] via GitHub
• [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch 1.1][#10262] refactor(build): remove release task and centralize JDK8 compatibility [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch 1.1][#10262] refactor(build): remove release task and centralize JDK8 compatibility [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch 1.1][#10262] refactor(build): remove release task and centralize JDK8 compatibility [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch 1.1][#10262] refactor(build): remove release task and centralize JDK8 compatibility [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch cherry-pick-pr-10485-branch-1.1 created (now 9ddfe889f0) fanng
  • (gravitino) 01/01: [#10262] refactor(build): remove release task and centralize JDK8 compatibility (#10385) fanng
• Re: [I] [FEATURE] feat(trino-connector): Add multi-version integration test automation [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch main updated: [#10454] feat(trino-connector): Add multi-version integration test automation (#10455) yuqi4733
• [I] [Improvement] add events for enable disable of metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [I] [Improvement] add events for enable disable of metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch cherry-pick-9377ca23-to-branch-1.2 deleted (was 5b3718b237) yuqi4733
• (gravitino) branch branch-1.2 updated: [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#10308] docs(clickhouse): clarify verified JDBC compatibility matrix (#10463) (#10491) yuqi4733
• (gravitino) branch main updated: [#10308] docs(clickhouse): clarify verified JDBC compatibility matrix (#10463) diqiu50
• [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#10308] docs(clickhouse): clarify verified JDBC compatibility matrix (#10463) [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#10308] docs(clickhouse): clarify verified JDBC compatibility matrix (#10463) [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#10308] docs(clickhouse): clarify verified JDBC compatibility matrix (#10463) [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch cherry-pick-9377ca23-to-branch-1.2 created (now 5b3718b237) github-bot
• Re: [I] [Bug report] ClickHouse: only clickhouse-jdbc-0.7.1-all.jar works, other version like clickhouse-jdbc-0.8.6-all.jar have NoClassDefFoundError issue [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [PR] [#10308] docs(clickhouse): clarify verified JDBC compatibility matrix [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [PR] [#10316] fix(catalog-jdbc-clickhouse): normalize quoted string defaults [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10316] fix(catalog-jdbc-clickhouse): normalize quoted string defaults [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [PR] [#10414] improvement(core): Unify cache invalidation in CatalogManager/Jcasbin/EntityStore [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch branch-1.2 updated: [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#10381][#10378] fix(clickhouse-catalog): Fix ClickHouse alter-table bugs (#10383) (#10487) yuqi4733
• (gravitino) branch cherry-pick-8afb3078-to-branch-1.2 deleted (was 059ceba282) yuqi4733
• [PR] [#10462] improvement(authz): Refactor the authorization expression [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch branch-1.2 updated: [Cherry-pick to branch 1.2][#10262] refactor(build): remove release task and centralize JDK8 compatibility (#10485) fanng
• Re: [PR] [#4860] improvement(core): Add a skeleton for EntityStore [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [PR] [Test] Test Jacoco [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [PR] [#1488]: fix(CI): make jacoco report work properly [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [PR] [#253] (Draft) feat(RocksDBKvBackend): make rocksdb.Options, WriteOptions, ReadOptions configurable [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [PR] Update Capability.java [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [PR] fix: trim trailing spaces in removeIdFromComment [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [I] [Bug report] Web UI v1 doesn't support specifying table property "format" [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch main updated: [#10453] web-v2(UI): support "delta" value for generic table format property (#10473) jshao
• Re: [PR] [#10453] web-v2(UI): support "delta" value for generic table format property [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch cherry-pick-20e2ae1e-to-branch-1.2 created (now 8822f88767) github-bot
  • (gravitino) 01/01: [#9518] improvement(authz): support batch get owner (#9914) github-bot
• [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#9518] improvement(authz): support batch get owner (#9914) [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#9518] improvement(authz): support batch get owner (#9914) [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#9518] improvement(authz): support batch get owner (#9914) [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch main updated: [#9518] improvement(authz): support batch get owner (#9914) roryqi
• Re: [I] [Improvement] Batch to get owners for the bundle of metadata objects [gravitino] via GitHub
• [PR] Fix: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] Fix: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [#10492] Improvment: Add events for enable / disable metalake and catalog [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch cherry-pick-8afb3078-to-branch-1.2 created (now 059ceba282) github-bot
• [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#10381][#10378] fix(clickhouse-catalog): Fix ClickHouse alter-table bugs (#10383) [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#10381][#10378] fix(clickhouse-catalog): Fix ClickHouse alter-table bugs (#10383) [gravitino] via GitHub
  • Re: [PR] [Cherry-pick to branch-1.2] [#10381][#10378] fix(clickhouse-catalog): Fix ClickHouse alter-table bugs (#10383) [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [I] [Bug report] Create a ClickHouse table with "autoIncrement": true didn't throw 400 or 405 exception [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [I] [Improvement] In the response of the Create ClickHouse Table API, the sortOrders field is empty, even though it was set in the request. [gravitino] via GitHub
• (gravitino) branch main updated: [#10381][#10378] fix(clickhouse-catalog): Fix ClickHouse alter-table bugs (#10383) yuqi4733
• Re: [I] [Bug report] Failed to add table index/delete table index [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [I] [Bug report] Recreate a ClickHouse table having `"on-cluster": "true"` encounter TableAlreadyExistsException after dropping it [gravitino] via GitHub
• Re: [I] [Improvement] Doc: clarify the support engine section for the ClickHouse catalog [gravitino] via GitHub

• Earlier messages
• Later messages