Re: [logging] Enterprise Common Logging... dare we say 2.0?

[Matt Sgarlata]

Richard Sitze wrote:
         - For message level logging, support globalized
           variants on the new EnterpriseLog interface:
           info(Class callingClass,
                String methodName,
                String messageID);
           info(Class callingClass,
                String methodName,
                String messageID,
                Object messageParam);
           info(Class callingClass,
                String methodName,
                String messageID,
                Object[] messageParams);
           same for warn, error, fatal.
 

I don't understand why the calling class and method name are included.  
Can't this information simply be retrieved from the current stack trace 
by the underlying logging implementation?  I would think a cleaner 
approach would be one of the alternatives below (note we have to avoid 
conflicting with the existing info, warn, error, etc. methods)

info(String defaultMessage, String messageKey);
info(String defaultMessage, String messageKey, Object param);
info(String defaultMessage, String messageKey, Object[] params);
or
i18nInfo(String messageKey);
i18nInfo(String messageKey, Object param);
i18nInfo(String defaultMessage, String messageKey, Object[] params);
Also, I don't want to type
private static final EnterpriseLog log = 
EnterpriseLogFactory.getClass(MyVeryLongClassName.class);

I would think this new functionality could be added directly to the 
existing Log and LogFactory classes.

Matt
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]