Op 29 okt 2010, om 14:51 heeft Magnus Manske het volgende geschreven: > On Fri, Oct 29, 2010 at 1:36 PM, Bryan Tong Minh > <bryan.tongm...@gmail.com> wrote: >> On Fri, Oct 29, 2010 at 2:25 PM, Krinkle <krinklem...@gmail.com> >> wrote: >>> For one, tags would not be hierarchical and not stored under a name, >>> rather a number (an id if you will). >> >> I would store the tag-i18n definitions in a separate Tag: namespace. >> Then you don't need to create the history tracking etc. all by >> yourself. You will need a unique identifier though, but I don't see a >> problem making the unique identifier equal to the content language. > > As to "tracking", IMHO it would suffice to just add [[Tag:XYZ]] to the > pages; that's rather inelegant from a database POV, but as Bryan > points out, it would take care of version tracking etc. All one would > need to do is to remove them from the rendering and display them > separately, like categories.
@Bryan: Ah, excuse me. You were referring to the history of the File- page. I was under the impression it was about the version tracking of the Tags. Yeah, adding to the page would be similar to categories and extracted from wikitext to a taglinks table. > Multilanguage tags, as well as synonyms, could simply be implemented > as #REDIRECTs, maybe. [[Tag:Blume]] would redirect to [[Tag:Flower]], > so a search for "Blume" would know about "Flower" easily. However, the > system would then have to search for both Blume and Flower internally. > Also, that could be a problem with "false friends" (en:Gift=present > vs. de:Gift=poison). Though that's certainly not a bad option. I was thinking not to use page-title search when searching through tags. Instead the tag-table itself which contains all the i18n versions. An option on the tag-search page could specify whether the search should cover English( and/or user-language), or all languages. Reason being that using redirects would practically mean we are supposed to keep all redirects in-sync with the tag-translations, which seems double work. -- Krinkle _______________________________________________ Commons-l mailing list Commons-l@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/commons-l
