Hi Andrew,

The JEP is clear on the concept and has many more details than are necessary
to submit it.  Supplying so much detail at the earliest stage invites more
discussion about the implementation than the concept.

Usually, the details of API and implementation are added as the JEP progresses. By the time it is implemented and complete, the JEP description will be fully
up to date and concrete.

Regards, Roger

On 7/31/18 4:01 AM, Andrew Dinn wrote:
Well, given the lack of any further input I am left wondering, JEP
neophyte that I am, whether:

   i) said happy lacuna implies that it is appropriate to submit this JEP
(as prompted by both the process blurb provided in JEP 1 and the
accordingly labelled button in the JEP JIRA interface)

or

   ii) the which unfortunate hiatus in commentary indicates simply that I
have failed to engage with the relevant worthies of this parish

Also, Iris (privately) mentioned something about "CSRs that add/modify
public APIs in the "java.*" modules". Does that mean there is more
paperwork to come? Now or later?

Advice on how to progress would be very welcome.

regards,


Andrew Dinn
-----------
Senior Principal Software Engineer
Red Hat UK Ltd
Registered in England and Wales under Company Registration No. 03798903
Directors: Michael Cunningham, Michael ("Mike") O'Neill, Eric Shander

Reply via email to