On Sun, Jan 18, 2009 at 7:59 PM, David Westbrook <dwestbr...@gmail.com>wrote:

> Whereas you wouldn't want to run a smoker on a "regular" machine (e.g.
> a $work box, or your day-to-day windows desktop, or laptop, etc),
> this is reasonably safe since it's only testing distros that you
> already installed, which implies that they (and their dependencies)
> are trusted.
> Also lets you easily submit reports for all the modules you're actual
> using, w/o a separate smoke environment.
>

I like it.  Among other things, it could be used with the File transport to
save reports to a directory for examination, which could be useful to check
things before upgrading.


>  Is this useful for others?
>    If so, as a snippet (e.g. posted on wiki)?
>    as a subclass (name??) of CPAN::Reporter::Smoker?
>    as an additional exported sub (name??) in CPAN::Reporter::Smoker?
>

At the very least, I'd put it on the CPAN Testers wiki.  I have no problem
if you want to publish a CPAN::Reporter::Smoker::* module, but I don't think
I want to include it in C::R::Smoker itself, mostly because it's a slipperly
slope of extra maintenance work for me if I start accepting different ways
of generating the list.

-- David

Reply via email to