And why, ethicaly, should the individual receive unlimited protection? Why
should an individual who acts in a unjust way receive protection simply
because they work for the government. Where in the DoI, Constitution, or
anywhere else in Democratic theory is this a requirement? Near as I can
tell, all governments (or particular agencies for that matter) that
require these sorts of exemptions are either fascist or socialist. Does
going to work for the government take away ones responsibilities and
rights as an individual? Are there valid times for the Nuremberg Defense?
I thought, at least in this country, the purpose was to represent the
people. Not to take personal advantage personaly or of the people (or
indivudal or given classes) on some procedural hell. It's supposed to be
equal protection under the law FOR ALL.

Government employees (of any type) aren't supposed to receive protection
from harms they may cause. If an incompetent causes harm why should
government employment (the n-1 people sitting around potentialy being
harmed by their actions) pay for it? Don't the people have a right to say
"Fire the dumb-ass!" Doesn't allowing this sort of stuff provide the EXACT
form of DEMOCRATIC government we want? If all men are held accountable for
their actions, won't they act with more deliberation?

On Sun, 22 Apr 2001, Phillip H. Zakas wrote:

> i clearly understand your point. where bell and i differ seems to be in the
> perception of the role of the individual working for the govt -- it appears
> to me that bell equates the individual as the govt and so can direct action
> against the individual.  this is similar to the justification-philosophy of,
> say, november 17, which targets individuals for their symbolic (or personal)
> importance (average citizens count in symbolic value to them as much as govt
> workers do.)  in fact, as i write this, it occurs to me that bell's
> justification (as i understand it) is similar to many such groups as nov 17
> around the world -- and perhaps this is why he attracted the attention he
> did -- in the view of many, he's acting/talking like the really bad bad guys
> do.

    ____________________________________________________________________

                The solution lies in the heart of humankind.

                                          Chris Lawson

       The Armadillo Group       ,::////;::-.          James Choate
       Austin, Tx               /:'///// ``::>/|/      [EMAIL PROTECTED]
       www.ssz.com            .',  ||||    `/( e\      512-451-7087
                           -====~~mm-'`-```-mm --'-
    --------------------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to