Yes, I agree that we cannot simply bundle some thing just because others are doing so. I also agree that it would be useful to know how many people want to use it. Any suggestions on how to get this information ? Within webstack-discuss, where I am currently involved , I got feedback from 2 direct customers asking for unixODBC as well as Free TSD support within PHP.
Well, one way to get user community feedback would be get the packages available in IPS format (new packaging format to be introduced within Indiana) and track the number of downloads happening. If we can do this, then we can decide as to whether this needs to be integrated within Open Solaris. Does this sound a reasonable thing to do ? For example, if a customer can download the unixODBC or Free TSD client drivers on his SXDE machine by doing some thing like (as given below), that would be great way to find out the user community interested in using these packages in Open Solaris pkg install http://database.opensolaris.org/unixodbc.pkg or pkg install http//database.opensolaris.org/freetsd.pkg - Sriram Zdenek Kotala wrote: > Sriram Natarajan wrote: > >> Hi >> Just to let you know , other OS distributors have distributed unixODBC >> drivers for some time now. >> > > It is true, but on other side important is how many users use it. If we > integrate unixODBC into opensolaris, then we will not able to remove > it in the future and somebody will must sustain it. > > By my opinion, until we don't know how many people would like to have > unixODBC inside opensolaris we cannot make decision. Integrated > something because somebody has it in another distribution is not good way. > > Zdenek > > > >> I very much hope that we consider to bundle >> it as well so that upstack components like PHP community can benefit >> from this integration. >> > > >> thanks >> sriram >> >> Josh Berkus wrote: >> >>> Sriram, >>> >>> >>> >>>> I am currently involved with WebStack project in OpenSolaris and would >>>> like to add more extensions for recently integrated PHP so that >>>> programmers can use our platform for development / production purposes. >>>> Based on the some of the feedback we received from some customers >>>> (outside Sun), it seems that we need to more database support within >>>> PHP and this requires databases client libraries like Free TSD , Oracle >>>> Instant Client and unixODBC to pre-exist on the system. >>>> >>>> >>> In principle I'm in favor of more drivers. However, I have a few questions: >>> >>> What's the licensing on the Oracle client? We can't necessarily just >>> include proprietary SW on Opensolaris. >>> >>> FreeTDS is a bit beta-quality, so it would require some QA, and probably >>> debugging for Solaris, first. Who's asking for this? Are there really >>> a lot of users who have a DB server on Windows and a web server on Solaris? >>> >>> unixODBC/iODBC keeps coming up as an issue, but we're not seeing actual >>> user requests. Do you have users with a need for it? That could affect >>> the priority. >>> >>> --Josh >>> _______________________________________________ >>> databases-discuss mailing list >>> databases-discuss at opensolaris.org >>> http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/databases-discuss >>> >>> >> _______________________________________________ >> databases-discuss mailing list >> databases-discuss at opensolaris.org >> http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/databases-discuss >> > > _______________________________________________ > databases-discuss mailing list > databases-discuss at opensolaris.org > http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/databases-discuss >
