Oct. 20
FLORIDA:
Florida Okays Execution of Schizophrenic Man in Direct Violation of Supreme
Court Ruling
The Florida Supreme Court has ruled that the state can proceed with the
execution of 64-year-old John Erroll Ferguson, despite its finding that he is a
paranoid schizophrenic. The decision will be appealed to the US Supreme Court.
The Florida Supreme Court has ruled that the state can proceed with the
execution of 64-year-old John Erroll Ferguson, despite its finding that he is a
paranoid schizophrenic. The Justices upheld the ruling of a lower court, which
found that Ferguson's "Prince of God" delusions, while "genuine", are not
"significantly different than beliefs other Christians may hold." Gov. Rick
Scott has since signed a new death warrant with the execution scheduled for
Tuesday, October 23 at 6 p.m.
Christopher Handman, one of Ferguson's attorneys, tells Truthout that Florida's
method for determining competency is "overly restrictive" and "out of step"
with the Constitution, as determined by the US Supreme Court. He says they will
appeal to the Supreme Court for a stay and ask that they hear his case.
Ferguson was sentenced to death for a 1977 mass murder in Miami Dade, which he
committed shortly after the state released him from a mental hospital against
the warnings of several state-appointed psychiatrists. During his
incarceration, state appointed experts have continued to diagnose him with
paranoid schizophrenia.
The prosecution initially argued that Ferguson was faking his symptoms. But
that was shot down last week by Bradford County Eighth Judicial Circuit Judge
David Glant who found the testimony of Ferguson's experts "credible and
compelling" and ruled that Ferguson's delusions are "genuine." Nevertheless,
Glant ruled that Ferguson is competent for execution because his beliefs are in
keeping with Christian teachings.
Ferguson expresses the belief, among other things, that he is the "Prince of
God" chosen to fight two antichrists alongside Jesus - after which he will rule
the world with multiple wives. In his mind, his incarceration is part of a
"hardening" process designed by God to prepare him to return to earth after his
execution and save America from a communist plot.
Ferguson's delusions represent a "relatively normal Christian belief, albeit a
grandiose one," concluded Glant. "There is no evidence in the record that
Ferguson's belief as to his role in the world and what may happen to him in the
afterlife is so significantly different from beliefs other Christians may hold
so as to consider it a sign of insanity."
Ferguson's attorneys immediately appealed Glant's decision to the Florida
Supreme Court, which upheld the lower court's ruling, though they ditched the
"his delusions are totally normal Christian beliefs" part.
"This is the 1st time the Florida Supreme Court has had an opportunity to
consider the state's methods for determining competency since the Supreme Court
decided Panetti," Handman told Truthout, referring to a Supreme Court ruling
that clarified competency standards.
The US Supreme Court initially banned executing the mentally ill in Ford v.
Wainwright (1986), specifically if the inmate lacks the "ability to comprehend
the nature of the penalty." The Court expanded on that view in Panetti v.
Quarterman (2007), a case brought forward by a psychotic Texas inmate whose
case closely resembles Ferguson's.
Panetti had schizoaffective disorder that led him to believe the state wanted
him dead to stop him from preaching. Though Panetti recognized the factual
rationale behind his death sentence - that he was found guilty of murdering his
ex-wife's parents - the Supreme Court held that "[a] prisoner's awareness of
the State's rationale for an execution is not the same as a rational
understanding of it." Furthermore, the Court reasoned that executing a prisoner
who "has no comprehension of why he has been singled out and stripped of his
fundamental right to life" undermines the concept of retributive justice.
Ferguson, like Panetti, thinks that the state wants him dead not because of his
crime, but as part of a conspiracy. According to testimony from George W.
Woods, an expert in neuropsychiatry who examined Ferguson three times in the
last year, Ferguson expresses a belief that "the guards [are] soldiers and
communists" who are "going to kill him because they know he is the prince of
God and that he has the power and can control the sun," and that "he has more
power than Jesus."
Ferguson also lacks any understanding of the consequences of execution. He
believes death penalty is no match for his special powers which prevent him
from ever being killed and that "just like Jesus, you'll come and look and you
won't find me there [in my grave]".
Despite all of this, the Florida Supreme Court held that only a factual
"awareness" of his crime and the reasons for his sentence are required for
Ferguson to qualify as competent. At the same time, the Court denied that
Ferguson "believes himself unable to die or that he is being executed for any
reason other than the murders he was convicted of in 1978."
"The State has taken a hardline view that Panetti didn't change anything," says
Handman. "[Panetti] amplifies the Ford requirements and clarifies the way it's
supposed to be approached because a lot of the lower courts had applied this
overly restrictive conception of what it means to be insane. Florida's statute
currently embodies that same flawed conception."
It's now up to the US Supreme Court to correct that flaw, because, contends
Handman, "No justice will be served by executing a very sick, elderly man."
(source: Truthout)
_______________________________________________
DeathPenalty mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.washlaw.edu/mailman/listinfo/deathpenalty
Search the Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A free service of WashLaw
http://washlaw.edu
(785)670.1088
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~