Oct. 21
KENTUCKY:
Ky. Human Rights Commission: End death penalty
The Kentucky Commission on Human Rights has called on the state to end the use
of the death penalty, saying it is often applied unfairly against minorities
and the poor.
The commissioners, who enforce state and federal civil rights laws, urged
Kentucky lawmakers in a resolution last week to repeal the law that allows the
use of the death penalty in some murder cases.
The resolution unanimously passed by the commissioners will be submitted to
Gov. Steve Beshear and to each state legislator.
As of April 1, Kentucky had 35 inmates on death row. Kentucky last executed an
inmate in 2008.
State Sen. Gerald Neal of Louisville says that lawmakers have considered
abolishing capital punishment, but have never passed legislation doing so.
(source: Associated Press)
CALIFORNIA:
Former executioner, warden speak at Riverside church
A former prison executioner and an ex-warden will speak at a Riverside Catholic
church Tuesday, Oct. 23, in opposition to the death penalty and in favor of
Prop. 34.
The initiative on the Nov. 6 ballot would ban capital punishment in California
and replace it with a sentence of life imprisonment without possibility of
parole. The state???s Catholic bishops have been leading supporters of the
referendum. The Diocese of San Bernardino has held several events in support of
Prop. 34.
One of the speakers Tuesday is Ron McAndrew, who as warden of Florida's largest
state prison presided over executions. The other is Jerry Givens, a former
correctional officer who was chief executioner for Virginia for 16 years.
The 2 will speak at 6 p.m. Tuesday at St. Catherine of Alexandria Catholic
Church, 3860 Arlington Ave., Riverside. For more information call the parish at
951-781-9855.
(source: Press-Enterprise)
USA:
Justice Scalia - A Toad Preserved in Amber
The city of Trenton has produced some great people in the course of its long
history - men such as John August Roebling and his son, Washington Roebling,
who designed and built the Brooklyn Bridge, Zebulon Pike the explorer, David
Dinkins, first black mayor of New York and General Norman Swarzkopf, to name
but a few. There is, however, another side to that picture.
The dark side is peopled by such characters as the present mayor, Tony Mack,
whose administration has lacked only an elephant and a trapeze artist to
qualify as a complete circus. It certainly has more than its share of clowns
with the head clown himself presently under indictment on charges of
bribe-taking. The dark side also has plenty of gangsters, wannabe drug lords
and street level losers. That's the sort of population one would expect on the
dark side of any city - crooked politicians and criminals.
In the case of Trenton however, the dark side has produced a unique
contribution to the roll-call of regressives: Justice of the Supreme Court,
Antonin Scalia. Justice Scalia has, in fact, a brilliant legal mind and it is
his intelligence that makes him so dangerous. It is an intelligence wholly
committed to returning this nation to the standards and practices of 1787, the
year the constitution was signed. Scalia is what is known as a "strict
constructionist," by which is meant that he believes 1787 saw the ultimate
flowering of human understanding, embodied in the constitution as literally
written by a party of men (the Founding Fathers) whose wisdom was near to
divine and who provided us with a specific and exact plan for society for all
times - a plan that requires no further modification or interpretation beyond
what it plainly states.
In this belief, Scalia credits the founders with far more specific wisdom than
they credited themselves with. Scholars have long agreed that our constitution,
the oldest written constitution in the world still governing a nation, has as
its greatest strengths its simplicity and its brevity. It seems clear that the
founders deliberately designed a document that did not tie the nation to a
rigid set of detailed notions but rather allowed for the certainty that times
would change and with changing times come changing values and needs. The true
wisdom of the founders was not in the specificity so prized by Scalia, but in
the prescience to realize that the accepted truths of one era may well be
discredited by succeeding eras. Therefore, rigidity would be a prescription for
failure.
Speaking recently at Washington's American Enterprise Institute, Scalia said,
"The death penalty? Give me a break. It's easy. Abortion? Absolutely easy.
Nobody ever thought the Constitution prevented restrictions on abortion.
Homosexual sodomy? Come on. For 200 years, it was criminal in every state."
(Note that this same reasoning would apply as well to slavery,
disenfranchisement of women and repeal of the Civil Rights Act.)
In other words, a re-criminalization of gays would present no constitutional
obstacles for Justice Scalia. Clearly, the application of the death penalty for
sodomy would present no obstacle either, since that was indeed the penalty on
the books of a number of states early in our history. This is not to imply that
Scalia wants to see gays criminalized and executed. It just means he would be
fine with it from a legal point of view and that's the only point of view he
cares about. He is indifferent, in his ivory tower, to human suffering. The ice
water flowing through his veins is unaffected by the misery and death caused by
prejudice and hatred of gays. The pathetic suicides of gay youth have no effect
upon this glacier of a man. The constitution does not specifically protect
sexuality, therefore, in the eyes of Justice Scalia, it can never be protected,
but like a fly in amber, must always remain in the netherworld of 1787.
Scalia is not unique in legal history. Among his predecessors are "Hanging"
Judge Jeffreys who presided over the infamous "Bloody Assizes" in the England
of 1685, the judges who sentenced children as young as 8 years old to be hung
for stealing a three penny loaf of bread in the England of Charles Dickens and
the judges of Germany's criminal courts in the Nazi Era who enforced the
Nuremburg Decree. All of these men were acting in strict accord with "the law."
Just as Trenton can claim the glory of the Brooklyn Bridge, so must it bear the
shame of unleashing this wretched man upon the nation.
(source: outinjersey.net)
*********************
Wrenching week at 9/11 trial as families face down terror suspects
The U.S. naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba - with its hidden detention camps,
barbed-wire fences and signs warning visitors not to take photos - may seem an
unlikely place to find peace of mind.
But that's what Tom and Josephine Acquaviva of Wayne say they brought home with
them on Saturday, after a week of watching preliminary hearings in the
controversial trial of 5 men accused of plotting the 9/11 attacks.
"The reality is that, they're getting a fair trial," Tom Acquaviva said on
Friday, responding to critics who have questioned the legality and openness of
the 6-year-old military commission created to try war criminals. "I believe
they will be convicted and will get the penalty. Eventually they'll get the
death penalty."
Over 5 exhausting and emotional days, the Acquavivas got a rare, up-close look
not only at their son's accused killers but at a young, evolving judicial
system that is at the center of an international debate over detainee rights,
the limits of the Constitution and the best way to deliver justice to those
accused of committing mass murder in the name of jihad.
That debate has been conspicuously absent from the U.S. presidential race, even
though closing the detention camp and moving the trials to New York City was
one of President Obama's 1st-term promises. Mitt Romney supports the military
commissions and has pledged to keep Guantanamo open.
But at Guantanamo this week it often seemed as if the commission itself was on
trial: Defense attorneys repeatedly raised questions about its fairness and
legality; civil liberties advocates argued for more transparency; and the
self-professed 9/11 mastermind, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, denounced the
proceedings from his chair at the defense table.
Tom Acquaviva and other family members said they felt frustrated by delays,
including defense attorneys who spent time in court arguing that their office
space at the base was infested with mold and rat feces and needed environmental
testing. Acquaviva also thought the military judge "went too far" in
accommodating the accused, including granting breaks during prayer times and
allowing Mohammed to deliver a 2-minute anti-U.S. lecture to the court, while
wearing a camouflage hunter???s vest over his white flowing tunic.
"I heard a lot about the rights of the accused," Acquaviva said at a preflight
news conference inside a hangar on the base Friday night, a photo of his son
Paul hanging from a chain around his neck. "I believe in our judicial system.
But what happened to 'justice delayed is justice denied?' We're going on 11
years."
Some lawyers in the case estimated it could take up to 5 more years before a
trial begins.
Despite the frustrations, the Acquavivas said they came away with an abiding
faith that government prosecutors, with whom they spoke several times, were
capable of winning a conviction through a fair trial, even if it takes years.
Other 9/11 family members, who like the Acquavivas watched the hearings from a
soundproof viewing gallery at the back of a high-security prison, said they
agreed.
"It helps in a sense because we see what's happening and see our government
lawyers are very good lawyers," Acquaviva said. "The government is so intent,
and justifiably so, on making it transparent and error-free as possible, so
that observers from around the world will say, 'Hey, it was really a fair
trial.'"
Eyes on the accused
Acquaviva isn't sure if any of the 5 alleged al-Qaida members' eyes met his.
But, starting at the moment they shuffled through the side door of the
courtroom at around 9 a.m. on Monday, he stared at them through the viewing
gallery's 3-pane soundproof window and held up a picture of his son.
"When I saw them the first time, I said 'Geez, I expected them to be bigger.'
They looked like dwarfs," he said. "And their arrogance, as if they were proud
of what they did. I felt a sense of outrage. But I couldn't do anything."
The government has not released or allowed photographs - only authorized
courtroom sketches - of Mohammed, Walid bin Attash, Ramzi bin al Shibh, Ali
Abdul Aziz Ali or Mustafa al Hawsawi since they were captured in 2002 and 2003.
When they entered 1 by 1 on Monday, their bushy black beards flowing over white
tunics, the approximately 60 members of the media, lawyers and family members
studied them, some looking for clues to the nature of their captivity, others
looking for unimaginable evil.
Throughout the hearings, on the days they attended, they appeared relaxed and
engaged, talking to translators on their legal team and leafing through large
binders with documents. Each morning, the detainees who chose to attend the
day's hearings were transferred to the courtroom from a secret camp somewhere
on the 45-square-mile base, a trip that takes 45 minutes, according to court
documents.
Access to the court's viewing gallery was limited. Security was tight.
Uniformed soldiers escorted visitors through multiple security screenings -
metal detectors, physical inspections of any belongings, credential checks -
before allowing access to the $14 million court complex, built in 2008
specifically for the trial. Journalists weren't allowed to bring their own pens
or notebooks with metal spiral bindings (pen and paper were provided), but they
had to bring their passports for entry. Photos and recordings are not permitted
nor are unauthorized sketches of the courtroom.
Inside the viewing gallery, security force officers stood along the walls, some
whispering into microphones inside their sleeves. From the gallery at the back
of the courtroom, attendees could look through soundproof glass windows at the
backs of the detainees, defense attorneys and prosecutors, seated at 12 tables.
Monitors and speakers provide an audio and video feed to the gallery, which
help attendees to make better sense of the proceedings. But the feed is on a
40-second delay. A CIA representative can cut it off, replacing the feed with
white noise and a blank screen if classified information is disclosed in open
court, inadvertently or otherwise. That includes information about the CIA's
"enhanced interrogation techniques," which have been outlawed but are still
classified.
The censor button was only used once last week - when a defense attorney
referenced beating and chaining someone to the ceiling. The passage was later
disclosed after a security official determined the lawyer's description was
only a hypothetical example, not a reference to classified information.
Most of the hearings before the commission delved into fine points of legal
theory. Still, seeing the accused plotters and reliving the loss was
emotionally taxing for Josephine Acquaviva, who teared up during the news
conference on Friday.
"The mother and child relationship, there???s no deeper relationship," Tom
Acquaviva said.
The Department of Defense provided housing for the families - the Acquavivas
stayed in a 2-bedroom town house - and a victims' advocate escorted them to
meals and informal meetings with officials involved in the case. On a few
evenings, the 9 family members of victims, chosen through a lottery system, got
the chance to meet prosecutors and ask them questions.
"They are really sharp," Acquaviva said. "I was concerned about the government
lawyers, but they are excellent."
3 of the approximately 1-dozen prosecutors have strong New Jersey roots,
Acquaviva learned. They include Assistant U.S. Attorney Edward Ryan, who grew
up in Union City and graduated from Rutgers University Law School; Lt. Cmdr.
Clayton Trivett, of Springfield, from the Navy Judge Advocate General's Corps
who graduated from Seton Hall Law School; and Army Maj. Rob McGovern of
Oradell, who formerly played in the NFL. The former presiding judge of the
military commission, retired Marine Col. Ralph Kohlmann, is from Wyckoff.
Complex case
The 9/11 case is complex and shows that, more than a decade after the worst
terror attacks in its history, the country's system for trying terror suspects
remains a work in progress.
The case deals with "offenses whose vast scope, massive response, and
continuing relevance to countering international terrorism have presented our
legal system and government with unprecedented practical and procedural
challenges," according to the lead prosecutor, Army Brig. Gen. Mark Martins.
Indeed, Guantanamo's location on land leased from Cuba for more than a century
has raised constitutional questions about whether the naval base and its
courthouse is within the full jurisdiction of the United States.
The U.S. signed its current lease with Cuba in 1934 - and agreed that breaking
the lease would require the consent of both parties - and has sent lease checks
to Cuba ever since. But the Communist leader Fidel Castro has not cashed the
checks for decades. (Castro, 86, was rumored to have suffered from a
debilitating stroke last week and to be near death.)
The naval base became home to the 1st military commission 2 months after 9/11
under orders from former President George W. Bush.
The Supreme Court ultimately ruled that Bush was not authorized to create the
commission but cleared the way for Congress to create a similar military
tribunal in 2006 and make amendments that expanded the rights of the accused
and bring them more in line with federal civilian and military courts.
But many of the arguments last week still centered on those issues: How the
commission rules would compare with those in other courts; how they would play
out in a complex case; and whether the defendants were entitled to
constitutional rights.
The defense, for example, asked the judge to decide that the constitutional
rights recognized in civilian criminal trials would also apply for wartime
offenses. Prosecutors argued it was too soon to make that determination, and
the judge deferred a ruling.
The judge did not deliver rulings on the most significant motions intended to
lay a legal framework for the early stages of the trial, but those are expected
in the coming weeks. They include rules the prosecution proposed for handling
classified evidence.
The defense said a proposed so-called protective order will prevent the 5
prisoners from publicly disclosing what happened to them while detained in
secret CIA prisons overseas, information that could be used to challenge
statements the men made to authorities or to argue they shouldn???t get the
death penalty. It could also prevent the public from learning details about the
harsh interrogations.
The U.S. government says the accused were subjected to "enhanced
interrogation"; critics say it was torture.
Martins, the prosecutor, said military commission rules would not permit any
evidence obtained through torture. And he argued that the defendants do not
have a right to present evidence about torture unless it is "relevant and
necessary" to the case.
Acquaviva said allegations of torture don???t seem relevant to the terrorism
charges.
"These people have admitted their culpability," he said, noting that the
defendants attempted to plead guilty in 2008.
On Friday, some victims' family members invoked the torture that their loved
ones likely went through at the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.
"These prisoners, what happened to them or allegedly happened to them overseas
just doesn't cut it for anyone up here," said Gordon Haberman, who lost his
daughter Andrea, 25, in the World Trade Center.
Acquaviva said what he saw in the previous week proved to him that "the accused
have gotten every right."
"They get time to pray. They get food to meet their religious requirements.
They get to wear their clothing. They're allowed to grow beards. They have
plenty of lawyers defending them," he said. "And they're accused of killing
2,976 people. I don't know what else any fair observer can possibly say is
wrong."
(source: northjersey.com)
MONTANA:
Hope for Canadian on death row as Montana execution protocol to be put on trial
A Montana judge has scheduled a trial for next summer as the state attempts to
bypass a requirement that it needs to get approval from its legislature to
change the way it carries out executions.
A ruling by Montana District Court Judge Jeffrey Sherlock in September declared
the state's method of execution unconstitutional, giving hope to Canadian
Ronald Smith, who is facing execution for the 1982 murders of 2 young Montana
men.
But the State of Montana has convinced Sherlock to hear its arguments in an
attempt bypass a requirement to get approval from the legislature to change the
way it carries out its executions.
"The state had indicated they believed they could change the protocol and
comply with the statute," said lead lawyer Ron Waterman of the American Civil
Liberties Union in an interview with The Canadian Press.
"I don't think that's possible but nevertheless that???s what they've told the
court so the judge said, all right, we can have a hearing on that."
Waterman said a 3-day hearing has been scheduled for July 22, 2013 but it is
likely the matter will be resolved through a request for a summary judgment
from Sherlock before then.
The ACLU filed a civil lawsuit in 2008 on behalf of Smith and another death row
inmate that argued the lethal injection the state uses is cruel and unusual
punishment and violates the right to human dignity.
In his Sept. 6 ruling Judge Sherlock pointed to problems such as lack of
training for individuals who administer the drugs and a discrepancy over
whether 2 or 3 drugs should be used. He also questioned the method used to
determine if an inmate is actually unconscious before receiving the lethal
injection.
"The Montana protocol has problems," Sherlock said in his 26-page judgment.
"All 3 of these concerns create a substantial risk of serious harm violative of
the plaintiff's right to be protected from cruel and unusual punishment."
Sherlock indicated the state legislature needed to rejig the statutes to bring
the execution protocol into line with Montana's constitution - something the
Attorney General's office is now hoping to avoid. The legislature route is
complex and both Waterman and legislators have indicated it might be a steep
hill to climb to get the changes through.
"It's one of those sort of things that's a little bit irritating. The fact of
the matter is that what the judge said was it's not the question of whether the
death penalty is unconstitutional - it is the question of whether the protocol
is unconstitutional," Waterman said.
"That always means that they could amend the protocol on the statute. There's
always that potential."
Smith, originally from Red Deer, Alta., has been running out of legal options
since he was convicted in Montana in 1983 for shooting Harvey Madman Jr. and
Thomas Running Rabbit, while he was high on drugs and alcohol near East
Glacier, Mont.
He had been taking 30 to 40 hits of LSD and consuming between 12 and 18 beers a
day at the time of the murders. He refused a plea deal that would have seen him
avoid death row and spend the rest of his life in prison. 3 weeks later, he
pleaded guilty. He asked for and was given a death sentence.
Smith later had a change of heart and has had a number of execution dates set
and overturned.
He is currently waiting to see if Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer will grant him
clemency.
Waterman said he is surprised that the State of Montana is attempting to bypass
the current process but said he did expect it would attempt to do something. He
said it's obvious the attorney general's assessment of the legislative
challenges coincides with his belief that it would be difficult to achieve.
"They're seeing that as something they want to avoid if they can," he said,
adding he remains optimistic.
"I'm confident that what we have is a stay that is continuing and it's
obviously going to continue for a while yet."
(source: The Canadian Press)
_______________________________________________
DeathPenalty mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.washlaw.edu/mailman/listinfo/deathpenalty
Search the Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A free service of WashLaw
http://washlaw.edu
(785)670.1088
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~