Oct. 22
PENNSYLVANIA:
Personal and ethical issue
Death penalty headlines in the Gettysburg Times remind us that the issue is
both personal and ethical. On Nov. 10 the Interfaith Center for Peace and
Justice will hold its annual potluck and meeting at the Trinity United Church
of Christ, where the program will focus two speakers on "Justice Without
Execution: Building Momentum toward Repeal of the Death Penalty." Vicki
Schieber, the mother of a murdered daughter in Philadelphia and one of the
founders of Murder Victims' Families for Human Rights, a national organization
of murder victims who oppose the death penalty, will be one of the featured
speakers. Her personal story resonates with reconciliation with the convicted
individual and family.
The second speaker will be Dr. Trudy Conway, professor of Philosophy at Mount
Saint Mary's University. Conway has spent the last ten years organizing campus
activities engaging faculty and students in reflection and activism regarding
the death penalty as well as speaking throughout Maryland on the death penalty
issue.Both Schieber and Conway serve on the Catholic Mobilizing Network to End
the Use of the Death Penalty (CMN). Schieber also serves on the Pennsylvania
Advisory Committee on Capital Punishment. She helps staff both the national CMN
office in Washington, D. C., and a regional office at Mt. St. Mary's
University. Dr. Conway's scholarly works focus on Contemporary Philosophy,
especially issues related to cross-cultural understanding and virtue ethics.
Both Conway and Schieber will have the book "Where Justice and Mercy Meet:
Catholic Opposition to the Death Penalty," co-edited with David McCarty,
published in December 2012. Dr. Conroy has commented: We invite members of the
community to join us in hearing on an updated snapshot of the issues helping to
building the momentum needed to bring about repeal, as well as the role each of
us can play in making Pennsylvania the 18th abolition state."
(source: Gettysburg Times)
VIRGINIA:
Tim Kaine's choices on life and death
Although I'm not a Democrat or even Catholic, I enjoyed the article on Virginia
Senate candidate Tim Kaine and his inner struggles sorting out the conflict
between his Catholicism and his commitment as governor to uphold the
death-penalty law in Virginia ["A man of faith and practical politics," front
page, Oct. 19]. Holding a criminal's case file in your hand, knowing that a
real person will live or die depending on which stack you set it down in, has
to eat at you regardless of how "law and order" you claim to be.
I respect anyone of either party whose bottom line is what he's going to say on
Judgment Day. Whether we argue over budgets or abortion or guns or welfare or
"binders" full of women, it all boils down to that final question: Why would
God allow me into heaven?
My vote aside, I have new respect for Mr. Kaine for being honest about what
makes him tick. The article at least made me see him not so much as a Democrat
I would generally oppose but a man with a conscience I can respect.
Jack Webb, Springfield
(source: Letter to the Editor, Washington Post)
SOUTH DAKOTA:
Lawyer: Robert wanted to die if escape failed
A man executed for killing a South Dakota prison guard wanted to commit suicide
and saw the death penalty law as an incentive, the man's attorney says.
Eric Robert was put to death last week for killing the guard, Ronald "R.J."
Johnson, when he and fellow inmate Rodney Berget tried to break out of the
prison in April 2011.
Robert pleaded guilty in September 2011 to killing Johnson, asked for a death
sentence and objected to a South Dakota Supreme Court review of his case.
Robert was serving an 80-year prison term for kidnapping at the time of his
attempted escape. His lawyer, Mark Kadi, said Robert wanted to end his own life
rather than languish in prison, and planned his escape so that he would be
eligible for a death sentence if unsuccessful.
"The availability of the death penalty encouraged rather than discouraged
Robert to commit this crime," Kadi wrote in a letter to the Sioux Falls Argus
Leader newspaper (http://argusne.ws/WVjMes). "I know this because Eric told me
so."
Robert was familiar with South Dakota's death penalty law, and knew that
killing a corrections officer while trying to escape would make it more likely
he would be sentenced to death, Kadi wrote.
South Dakota Attorney General Marty Jackley disputed Kadi's version of events,
saying that evidence in the case "points to this being a poorly planned, poorly
executed escape attempt."
Jackley pointed out that Robert had said he would kill again if he were not
executed.
"I can't say if the death penalty will deter others from committing crimes in
the future, but it deterred Eric Robert from committing any other crimes,"
Jackley said.
Kadi said his client felt "hopeless" in prison, and that he tried
unsuccessfully to kill himself with a drug overdose.
"Robert viewed a life sentence as being identical to a death sentence with the
exception that the latter had a set date," Kadi said. "Robert believed he
needed to get out, one way or the other."
Richard Dieter, director of the Death Penalty Information Center, said Robert's
statements about his wish to die and the speed at which his execution was
carried out made his case unusual.
It usually takes more than a decade for a death sentence to be carried out,
center statistics say. Of the 32 executions that have taken place in the United
States this year, Robert's is the only one that happened within a year of the
sentence. The 2nd shortest delay was 6 years.
(source: Associated Press)
OREGON:
'Dead Man Walking' author Sr. Helen Prejean discusses death-penalty, repeal
efforts
In 1982, at the suggestion of a civil rights activist, Sister Helen Prejean
wrote a letter to a man on Louisiana's death row.
Her correspondence with Patrick Sonnier, convicted of the murders of 2
teenagers, would lead Prejean into a life of challenging the death penalty and
the morality of a legal system skewed against minorities and the poor.
As Sonnier's spiritual advisor for 2 years, Prejean witnessed his execution in
Louisiana's electric chair, eventually writing a Pulitzer-Prize nominated book
"Dead Man Walking" about the experience. She has witnessed 6 executions and is
the spiritual advisor to 2 death-row inmates, 1 of whom whose sentence was
recently overturned.
Prejean, who is working on her 3rd book, is visiting Oregon this week for
several events in Portland and Eugene. She met with The Oregonian at the
University of Portland to talk about her views on the death penalty nationally
and in Oregon. The following has been edited for brevity and clarity.
Q: Since 2007, there have been 5 states that have abolished (the death penalty)
and now California's voters will decide--Do you think that this wave of states
abolishing capital punishment is going to continue - and where do you see it
happening next?
A: Yeah it is...There are a number of states. Kansas is close to doing it.
California is actually close to doing it...
You know Americans are practical. So let's take this death penalty thing that's
supposed to deter violent crime. So let's look at the states that are
practicing the death penalty the most. And we see roughly states that do have
the death penalty have double the homicide rate of states that don't have the
death penalty...
Then another factor is the money. All states are under budget crunches. ... And
so like California spends $185 million a year to keep their death penalty
machinery in place. The average waiting time for an execution is 20 years.
I bet you Oregon is close to that because you don't actually practice it. So
it's almost like you're holding this symbol in place, a political symbol.
That's basically what it boils down to because (for) politicians, it's the
easiest symbol in the world to say 'I'm tough on crime.' It's got nothing to do
with dealing with the roots of crime and violence.
Q: In many of the states that have abolished the death penalty recently, it was
through legislative efforts. And here in Oregon, we have a situation where it
most likely will have to be referred to voters. Do you think that increases the
degree of difficulty at all?
"Oh yeah, absolutely...But it means, like California and we don't know because
the jury is still out. If they can get enough money to do those ads on TV and
radio spots to just get in those facts to the people, we'll see what happens.
But it means you got to get out there and you really got to educate the people.
And I guess my hope is -- because I've seen people respond -- that if they can
hear about it, they're not tied to vengeance, they're not saying, 'Oh no, we
got to kill," and there's a whole part of us that knows we can barely trust the
government to fill the potholes...And (to) let you set up this system of
deciding life and death? Q: In Oregon, the governor last year issued a reprieve
to Gary Haugen who I know you've met with, and said there will be no more
executions???
A: And he's mad and he's suing him.
Q: He views it as his right. He believes it's his right to be executed -- that
he doesn't want to spend the rest of his life in this tiny cell 23 hours a
day... A: He's asking for suicide and asking the state to help him do it. And
the state won't. This time.
...But hey, you have me sitting in a cell for 20, 30 years and everyday you
wake up to the same walls... It takes a very strong person inwardly to deal
with the boredom, to deal with the lack of human interaction, and stimulation
not to go nuts. I don't kno what I would do under the stress. That human beings
would say 'I want it to be over, I'll take my chances on the other side' is
really understandable to me.
Q: Do you think if inmates want to voluntarily waive their legal appeals that
they should be allowed to force the state to carry out this death sentence?
A: Look how complex this is. What kind of mental state is it that a person is
asking for the state to kill them?... How do you determine insanity? What is
mental stress to the point that you've just given up?
What this shows me is we're the last ones on earth to have the wisdom to be
able to make these kind of complex decisions about human life. We don't know.
...And so whatever criteria we're going to put or whatever format we're going
to put on this to try and say here we have a deliberative, reasonable process
to decide on life or death, it never holds up. Because a deeper wisdom is
required of us and actually it's beyond us.
...We're not the authors of people's lives and so look at the arrogance where
we feel we have the wisdom to decide. From a religious point of view or from a
human rights point of view. From a religious point of view, 'God's finished
with you, Bud. You're never going to be redeemable so we???re sending you into
eternity.'
What makes us think we can do that?
From human rights, from a Universal Declaration of Human Rights... Everyone has
a right to life...No human being shall be subjected to cruel and degrading
punishment or torture.
Q: What do you say to victim's families, many of whom sit through trials that
go in grotesque detail about what happened to their loved ones and at the end
of it, their view is that this jury, our system of justice, has chosen this
sentence...And they do view this as justice being done if a death sentence is
carried out. What do you tell them?
A: The other victim's families are representing it better than I ever could...
You know when you see them come out of a courtroom. Sometimes with the 'v'
thing like we got a victory. We won, we got the death penalty. And they're
still waiting, 10, 15 years.
And their wound is open and public...Anytime there's a change in the status of
the case, another hearing or execution delayed, the media's at their door.
'Well, how do you feel now?' How do you heal in that?
I see it as a terrible manipulation and injustice to victim's families to give
them that kind of promise. 'Now, you wait, and then you're going to get your
justice, or your closure, or your healing.' And that is so illusory and it is
so patently false. Because as one victim's family said, 'Even if I could watch
the execution of the one who killed my daughter, when I come home after the
execution the chair's still going to be empty where my daughter sat.' What does
it mean? What does it mean really to heal us that way? That doesn't heal
anything.
Often it's the mothers themselves who have lost someone who say, 'And then
there's another mother that's going to bury her child?' How many deaths is it
going to take for us to know that we've got to stop this?
Q: How would you assess Oregon's chances of abolishing capital punishment,
especially considering the moratorium now on executions. Does it in a way take
away some momentum to do something more permanent?
A: Well you can just see the momentum in the country. We're in diminishment.
...It's momentum in the direction of (abolishment) and you've never been
serious about practicing it anyway...I think the governor just declared what in
fact is a fact.
Q: Do you think that there is the organization and the political will to make
that extra step when for all intents and purposes, the death penalty is not
carried out.
I think practically speaking that's the way it's been for about 25 years in
Oregon. You've never been a serious practicioner of doing it. So what's the
difference? I think the governor just declared what in fact is a fact.
...The death penalty is not in people's minds. It's not something they reflect
on. And that's why I'm out on that road...Why we have the book, why I'm glad
about the movie, the film, because that awakens consciousness.
(source: The Oregonian)
_______________________________________________
DeathPenalty mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.washlaw.edu/mailman/listinfo/deathpenalty
Search the Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A free service of WashLaw
http://washlaw.edu
(785)670.1088
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~