Your message dated Sun, 06 Nov 2022 20:40:10 +0000 with message-id <[email protected]> and subject line Bug#977832: fixed in fai 6.0~alpha23 has caused the Debian Bug report #977832, regarding fai-setup-storage: setup-storage fails if old disk setup contains a VG with plus sign in its name to be marked as done.
This means that you claim that the problem has been dealt with. If this is not the case it is now your responsibility to reopen the Bug report if necessary, and/or fix the problem forthwith. (NB: If you are a system administrator and have no idea what this message is talking about, this may indicate a serious mail system misconfiguration somewhere. Please contact [email protected] immediately.) -- 977832: https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=977832 Debian Bug Tracking System Contact [email protected] with problems
--- Begin Message ---Package: fai-setup-storage Version: 5.9.4 Severity: normal Dear Maintainer, setup-storage fails to setup a disk if the disk already contains a VG with a plus sign in its name. Minimized disk setup that causes the issue: ``` $ parted --script /dev/loop0 print free Model: Loopback device (loopback) Disk /dev/loop2: 128MB Sector size (logical/physical): 512B/512B Partition Table: gpt Disk Flags: Number Start End Size File system Name Flags 1 17.4kB 128MB 128MB primary lvm $ lsblk /dev/loop0 NAME MAJ:MIN RM SIZE RO TYPE MOUNTPOINT loop2 7:2 0 122.1M 0 loop └─loop2p1 259:7 0 122M 0 part └─old_vg-a+b 253:5 0 120M 0 lvm ``` Minimized disk config that reproduces the issue: ``` disk_config disk1 disklabel:gpt primary - 0- - - disk_config lvm ``` The setup-storage error message I get for this combination: ``` Cannot satisfy pre-depends for lvremove -f /dev/old_vg/a+b: wipefs_old_vg/a+b -- system left untouched. ``` The impact is that setup-storage can't resetup the disk. If I remove the `+` from `a+b` then the issue doesn't happen. If I remove the `disk_config lvm` line then the issue doesn't happen. We've encountered this issue with existing machines that have been previously installed with Debian Installer. Best, Michael Schaller setup-storage debug output: ``` disklist: loop0 Starting setup-storage 2.3 Using config file: <redacted> Input was: disk_config disk1 disklabel:gpt primary - 0- - - disk_config lvm (CMD) parted -s /dev/loop0 unit TiB print 1> /tmp/DawnyWaUqw 2> /tmp/1CdIC7E2lZ Executing: parted -s /dev/loop0 unit TiB print (STDOUT) Model: Loopback device (loopback) (STDOUT) Disk /dev/loop0: 0.00TiB (STDOUT) Sector size (logical/physical): 512B/512B (STDOUT) Partition Table: gpt (STDOUT) Disk Flags: (STDOUT) (STDOUT) Number Start End Size File system Name Flags (STDOUT) 1 0.00TiB 0.00TiB 0.00TiB primary lvm (STDOUT) (CMD) parted -s /dev/loop0 unit B print free 1> /tmp/6y8bZKl8j9 2> /tmp/cRw5eJZBPo Executing: parted -s /dev/loop0 unit B print free (STDOUT) Model: Loopback device (loopback) (STDOUT) Disk /dev/loop0: 128000000B (STDOUT) Sector size (logical/physical): 512B/512B (STDOUT) Partition Table: gpt (STDOUT) Disk Flags: (STDOUT) (STDOUT) Number Start End Size File system Name Flags (STDOUT) 1 17408B 127983103B 127965696B primary lvm (STDOUT) (CMD) parted -s /dev/loop0 unit chs print free 1> /tmp/JpcgqNuRbJ 2> /tmp/fAQl87C8ra Executing: parted -s /dev/loop0 unit chs print free (STDOUT) Model: Loopback device (loopback) (STDOUT) Disk /dev/loop0: 490,49,1 (STDOUT) Sector size (logical/physical): 512B/512B (STDOUT) BIOS cylinder,head,sector geometry: 490,255,2. Each cylinder is 261kB. (STDOUT) Partition Table: gpt (STDOUT) Disk Flags: (STDOUT) (STDOUT) Number Start End File system Name Flags (STDOUT) 1 0,17,0 490,33,0 primary lvm (STDOUT) Ignoring volume group: dhcp-100-105-1-216-vg Current disk layout in %current_config $VAR1 = { '/dev/loop0' => { 'sector_size' => '512', 'bios_sectors_per_track' => '2', 'size' => '128000000', 'partitions' => { '1' => { 'flags' => 'lvm', 'filesystem' => '', 'count_byte' => '127965696', 'is_extended' => 0, 'begin_byte' => '17408', 'end_byte' => '127983103' } }, 'begin_byte' => 0, 'bios_cylinders' => '490', 'bios_heads' => '255', 'disklabel' => 'gpt', 'end_byte' => 127999999 } }; Current LVM layout in %current_lvm_config $VAR1 = { 'old_vg' => { 'physical_volumes' => [ '/dev/loop0p1' ], 'size' => '120.000839233398', 'volumes' => { 'a+b' => { 'size' => '120.000839233398' } } } }; Current RAID layout in %current_raid_config $VAR1 = {}; Current device tree in %current_dev_children $VAR1 = { 'VG_old_vg' => [ '/dev/old_vg/a+b' ], '/dev/loop0p1' => [ 'VG_old_vg' ], '/dev/loop0' => [ '/dev/loop0p1' ] }; Desired disk layout in %FAI::configs $VAR1 = { 'VG_--ANY--' => { 'opts_all' => {}, 'fstabkey' => 'device' }, 'PHY_/dev/loop0' => { 'partitions' => { '1' => { 'encrypt' => 0, 'start_byte' => 1048576, 'mountpoint' => '-', 'filesystem' => '-', 'size' => { 'always_format' => 0, 'extended' => 0, 'eff_size' => 126934528, 'resize' => 0, 'range' => '126934528-126934528', 'preserve' => 0 }, 'mount_options' => '-', 'end_byte' => 127983103 } }, 'bootable' => -1, 'fstabkey' => 'device', 'preserveparts' => 0, 'disklabel' => 'gpt', 'opts_all' => {}, 'virtual' => 0 } }; Desired device tree in %FAI::dev_children $VAR1 = { '/dev/loop0' => [ '/dev/loop0p1' ] }; Erased devices: /dev/loop0p1 Trying to add CMD: true PRE: POST: exist_/dev/loop0 Trying to add CMD: wipefs -af /dev/loop0p1 PRE: exist_/dev/loop0,self_cleared_VG_old_vg POST: wipefs_/dev/loop0p1 Trying to add CMD: true PRE: exist_/dev/loop0,self_cleared_VG_old_vg,wipefs_/dev/loop0p1 POST: cleared1_/dev/loop0 Trying to add CMD: parted -s /dev/loop0 mklabel gpt PRE: cleared1_/dev/loop0 POST: cleared2_/dev/loop0 Trying to add CMD: parted -s /dev/loop0 mkpart primary "" 1048576B 127983103B PRE: cleared2_/dev/loop0 POST: prep2_/dev/loop0p1 Trying to add CMD: true PRE: prep2_/dev/loop0p1 POST: exist_/dev/loop0p1 Trying to add CMD: vgchange -a n old_vg PRE: self_cleared_/dev/old_vg/a+b POST: vgchange_a_n_VG_old_vg Trying to add CMD: vgchange -a y old_vg PRE: POST: pre_wipe_old_vg Trying to add CMD: wipefs -a /dev/old_vg/a+b PRE: pre_wipe_old_vg, POST: wipefs_old_vg/a+b Trying to add CMD: lvremove -f /dev/old_vg/a+b PRE: wipefs_old_vg/a+b POST: lv_rm_old_vg/a+b,self_cleared_/dev/old_vg/a+b Trying to add CMD: vgremove old_vg PRE: vgchange_a_n_VG_old_vg,lv_rm_old_vg/a+b POST: vg_removed_old_vg Trying to add CMD: pvremove /dev/loop0p1 PRE: vg_removed_old_vg POST: pvremove_old_vg Trying to add CMD: wipefs -af /dev/loop0p1 PRE: pvremove_old_vg POST: pv_sigs_removed_wipe_/dev/loop0p1_old_vg Trying to add CMD: true PRE: pvremove_old_vg,pv_sigs_removed_wipe_/dev/loop0p1_old_vg POST: pv_sigs_removed_old_vg Trying to add CMD: true PRE: vgchange_a_n_VG_old_vg,pv_sigs_removed_old_vg,self_cleared_/dev/old_vg/a+b POST: self_cleared_VG_old_vg Trying to add CMD: true PRE: cleared2_/dev/loop0,exist_/dev/loop0p1 POST: pt_complete_/dev/loop0 Trying to add CMD: wipefs -af /dev/loop0p1 PRE: exist_/dev/loop0,self_cleared_VG_old_vg POST: wipefs_/dev/loop0p1 Trying to add CMD: true PRE: exist_/dev/loop0,self_cleared_VG_old_vg,wipefs_/dev/loop0p1 POST: cleared1_/dev/loop0 Trying to add CMD: parted -s /dev/loop0 mklabel gpt PRE: cleared1_/dev/loop0 POST: cleared2_/dev/loop0 Trying to add CMD: parted -s /dev/loop0 mkpart primary "" 1048576B 127983103B PRE: cleared2_/dev/loop0 POST: prep2_/dev/loop0p1 Trying to add CMD: true PRE: prep2_/dev/loop0p1 POST: exist_/dev/loop0p1 Trying to add CMD: vgchange -a n old_vg PRE: self_cleared_/dev/old_vg/a+b POST: vgchange_a_n_VG_old_vg Trying to add CMD: lvremove -f /dev/old_vg/a+b PRE: wipefs_old_vg/a+b POST: lv_rm_old_vg/a+b,self_cleared_/dev/old_vg/a+b Cannot satisfy pre-depends for lvremove -f /dev/old_vg/a+b: wipefs_old_vg/a+b -- system left untouched. ```
--- End Message ---
--- Begin Message ---Source: fai Source-Version: 6.0~alpha23 Done: Thomas Lange <[email protected]> We believe that the bug you reported is fixed in the latest version of fai, which is due to be installed in the Debian FTP archive. A summary of the changes between this version and the previous one is attached. Thank you for reporting the bug, which will now be closed. If you have further comments please address them to [email protected], and the maintainer will reopen the bug report if appropriate. Debian distribution maintenance software pp. Thomas Lange <[email protected]> (supplier of updated fai package) (This message was generated automatically at their request; if you believe that there is a problem with it please contact the archive administrators by mailing [email protected]) -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 Format: 1.8 Date: Tue, 01 Nov 2022 10:35:51 +0100 Source: fai Architecture: source Version: 6.0~alpha23 Distribution: experimental Urgency: low Maintainer: Thomas Lange <[email protected]> Changed-By: Thomas Lange <[email protected]> Closes: 844377 951659 977832 985303 987779 989547 990211 990633 999739 1000572 1005745 1006847 1010593 1010906 1011642 1020976 Changes: fai (6.0~alpha23) experimental; urgency=low . [ Thomas Lange ] * fai-do-scripts: write output of all scripts to scripts.log, remove code for old cfengine versions (1 and 2) * fai-make-nfsroot: drop support for .asc files, use only .gpg * add autopkgtest * install_packages: add release=<name> feature, Closes: #844377, add pacman support * fetch-basefile: use curl instead of lftp for downloading * Commands.pm: special handling of nvme devices, Closes: #999739, quote variables, Closes: #977832, remove old code need by old version of mkfs.btrfs and lvcreate * fai-mk-network: usie iproute commands instead of brctl * fai-make-nfsroot: add dracut modul network-legacy, Closes: #1010906 do not kill dhclient, Closes: #987779, drop support for dracut < 049, patch udev rule of lvm for bullseye, include empty machine-id into base.tar * Exec.pm: better error message, Closes: #1005745 * fcopy: handle broken symlinks, Closes: #985303 * fai-chboot: add variable substitution when coping a template, add option -a * fai-class: use of .source scripts now emits an error * fai-kvm: add -M for creating NVMe devices * fai-mirror: use only first line of bpo in sources.list, Closes: #1006847, print number of packages inside the mirror * fai-diskimage: call losetup with -P, Closes: #1010593, do not remove VGs, deactivate them, Closes: #990633, add option -c, print error if umount fails, increase number of tries * fai-cd: set TMPDIR for chroot, Closes: #1000572 * fai-setup: create ECDSA keys * Fstab.pm: support tmpfs size -, this uses the system default size for tmpfs, Closes: #951659 * setup-storage: add support for fstabkey:partlabel and fstabkey:partuuid, remove crypto keyfile after use * enhance disk_config format for partition label support * ftar: add support for zstd * fai: check if unshare can be used, Closes: #989547 use only IPv4 address as hostname remove code for deprecated taskname prepareapt * watch: update to version 4, use new url * install_packages: parse apt-cache output, Closes: #990211 * subroutines: umount tmpfs if config space was downloaded via http, Closes: #1011642 * task_sysinfo: print machine readable partition information, do not call commands that modify the system if no run in FAI environment, print battery information * subroutines: add help functions: ctam (Chroot TArget Mount pseudo filesystems) ctau (Chroot TArget Umount) ctai (Chroot TArget Into) rm_target (remount /target read-write) * NFSROOT: cleanup package list, add cryptsetup * update my email address * mk-basefile: remove /var/lib/dbus/machine-id, use zstd instead of gzip * simple/examples: use fai-link and fai-sed instead of ln and sed, remove cryptsetup passphrase from logs, use class ROCKY instead of CENTOS, update Ubuntu support to 22.04, add CLOUD_EFI, use ext4 for /boot in LVM examples * get-boot-info: set NIC1 even if no network is used during installation . [ Mike Gabriel ] * fai-abort:give job control to bash, Closes: #1020976 . [ Juri Grabowski ] * install_packages: add support for alpine Linux apk and Archlinux pacman . [ Guido Günther ] * subroutines: allow one to pass a debootstrap script in FAI_DEBOOTSTRAP . [ Christian Meyer ] * fai-setup: add ECDSA-key to known_hosts . [ Aki Tuomi ] * check-cross-arch: fail on errors and unbound variables . [ Hannes Eberhardt ] * package_config/ROCKY: update EFI packages Checksums-Sha1: f359cd5b8eec6104e26673dc245f9996732d52da 2094 fai_6.0~alpha23.dsc 18640edfb1ea7750fc00344272558419044d78e8 292856 fai_6.0~alpha23.tar.xz 95c47765ef1a1f4220c3081f114168f1b4eb4def 16335 fai_6.0~alpha23_amd64.buildinfo Checksums-Sha256: 5498996c62e69533ba6342b3e8ff1a1b5c0e5b954bcb43d77fbb913363cfbac8 2094 fai_6.0~alpha23.dsc 97ebd1504051fd276b20209ed23a628aea0c6bcf3e1d5c513031628452ee3b95 292856 fai_6.0~alpha23.tar.xz 3afe51b0ae0396f3df8431c79805534d19d3338137937ddeac962f8298163612 16335 fai_6.0~alpha23_amd64.buildinfo Files: 1eca2b7b2ceb1ea58318b3203baa6139 2094 admin optional fai_6.0~alpha23.dsc eff1bdd3698a7b373401d692f768ace9 292856 admin optional fai_6.0~alpha23.tar.xz 51e74f59532293509d88d4cb0e37440c 16335 admin optional fai_6.0~alpha23_amd64.buildinfo -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- iQJFBAEBCAAvFiEEsR7jJz9rLetSjJPaK/jZ/gdLzeQFAmNoEf4RHGxhbmdlQGRl Ymlhbi5vcmcACgkQK/jZ/gdLzeTwzg//d2wwZbh98jD+hMymS35R18IThlvVgLxN iFcgosyTm4Klqw415yBXqoD+xonRqFE5oD95TEPvBKOuLk/Pu10iSAIsMbZkO5Za 2KVvikOHCMCOCJnd36BtKO9/LjldRzy1EbOLbaSqsh5pshAmhAugffHb0PQiEdhP k1Ikbd/yN73QbAW5En516PharICQNjlebj21vqG5N0Fd1BH9nS4U3kPqYV2p0gmo PuE98G4KKDHlfsOkVGCABgWu1zTuQUxcQep/rpgnkvE5Ap3TQvzdGt+8uHeXbixM miUMOHEeEWqdv46TtA1UmyonMlz1QzpkA14wsmgLsIKXJyhivvY0Yvl+rI84ADzW EG0hLWyN75+XZXWd40NtXzj0ZEJ5KPEIKAR4nQC0cd0VLkL53Kgk3WGQSlBrouFr o+N7yuZ2Hn9NrBdy7yrYhIkLXspYWyw24JS/SvHNkW0xoX9bsZVu3ixOSneI6nIk MoOgEL8VLyZD2jB3VgTm/WVg75taXSaxV20JdHagT7quKF7a1umvn7j17EWqDLnx NOLuQ8YZ+WM/45k2T3KGbLeDoLtXUnhfLLEMvChkJIxJulqIrGbH4UnVf+NAAsYf IkBQzn2kUsWY1pz9BGAp+Q4EZoNDZlhL+Mucu6PKQm1U8iTZKScNqv3mHCv+/GEA 24vhstQdXC8= =0GRP -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
--- End Message ---
