Mike Hommey wrote: "Some changes applied to the debian packages don't
fall in the community edition authorized changes, and there's no way
we want not to apply these."

If you're referring to the list of "permitted" changes in Community
Editions on 
http://www.mozilla.org/foundation/trademarks/community-edition-policy.html
I would really like to see what specifically you think would not be
allowed.  One of the permitted changes is "Porting the software to
different operating systems" which would imply a degree of
OS-integration (e.g. updates through apt-get vs. individual programs
downloading updates for themselves).  Also, it says below the list:

"It is very important that Community Editions of Firefox and
Thunderbird meet (or exceed) the quality level people have come to
associate with Mozilla Firefox and Mozilla Thunderbird. We need to
ensure this, but we don't want to get in people's way. So, we are
taking an optimistic approach."

I would like someone from Mozilla (Mike? :) and someone from Debian
(Eric? :) to sit down and determine if there is actually anything
stopping the Debian FF release from being called "Firefox Community
Edition Debian" right now...  If it can, problem solved :)  If not,
can the Mozilla CE Policy be altered slightly to accomodate Debian
and/or can Debian move some of the changes into a separate package?

Eric Dorland wrote: "If we call the package firefox, aren't we
claiming that's what it is and hence infringing the mark? I'd
certainly like to keep the package name unchanged, but also if it is
left as firefox and the browser presents itself as "Foobar" might that
not confuse users?

If the CE idea actually has merit, changing the package to
"firefox-community-edition-debian" or "firefox-ced" or some such (with
an accompanying change in the description) shouldn't be too confusing
to users; plus you could always have a metapackage "firefox" that
installs the CE version.

CK


--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to