On 04/28/09 05:48, Yves-Alexis Perez wrote:
It happens with all the usb devices you tried?
Is there something in /var/log/syslog during the various mount/umounts?
Could you try lshal -m during those operations, too?
It happens with all usb thumbdrive-type devices (actual usb thumbdrives,
my Sony Reader and my Sony Walkman) and with external USB hard drives.
There is nothing in syslog except the normal output from the kernel
(dmesg), and there is nothing unusual in that output, and nothing
different from in the past when this problem did not occur prior to
upgrading from lenny to squeeze.
Attached are two logs from lshal -m, one with thunar run as a foreground
process, the other with it running as a daemon. There is no other output
to any other logs related to this problem.
The only other thing I have noticed during testing is that every time
the device is removed and re-inserted, a new [scsi_eh_X] process appears
in the process list, where 'X' is incremented each time. Similarly, in
the kernel output (dmesg), when the device is scanned, it gets a
different scsi device ID (as in 'sd XX:0:0:0: [sdb] ...', where XX
increments each time).
Perhaps thunar is somehow caching hardware state when running as a
daemon, and the change in scsi ID is not being picked up?
--
Scott Barker sc...@mostlylinux.ca
Linux Consultant http://www.mostlylinux.ca/scott
Start monitoring devicelist:
-------------------------------------------------
07:51:04.893: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100 added
07:51:04.912: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0 added
07:51:04.942: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_usbraw added
07:51:09.882: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host added
07:51:09.885: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host_scsi_device_lun0 added
07:51:10.034: storage_serial__USB_2_0_091155002041A100_0_0 added
07:51:10.039: storage_serial__USB_2_0_091155002041A100_0_0 property info.interfaces = {'org.freedesktop.Hal.Device.Storage.Removable'} (new)
07:51:10.136: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F added
07:51:14.176: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F property volume.mount_point = '/media/DISK_IMG'
07:51:14.191: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F property volume.is_mounted = true
07:51:19.699: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F property volume.mount_point = ''
07:51:19.700: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F property volume.is_mounted = false
07:51:23.528: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host_scsi_device_lun0 removed
07:51:23.531: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host removed
07:51:23.532: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F removed
07:51:23.554: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0 removed
07:51:23.558: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_usbraw removed
07:51:23.558: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100 removed
07:51:23.558: storage_serial__USB_2_0_091155002041A100_0_0 removed
07:51:26.909: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100 added
07:51:26.918: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0 added
07:51:26.944: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_usbraw added
07:51:31.905: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host added
07:51:31.907: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host_scsi_device_lun0 added
07:51:32.030: storage_serial__USB_2_0_091155002041A100_0_0 added
07:51:32.034: storage_serial__USB_2_0_091155002041A100_0_0 property info.interfaces = {'org.freedesktop.Hal.Device.Storage.Removable'} (new)
07:51:32.163: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F added
07:51:33.518: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F property volume.mount_point = '/media/DISK_IMG'
07:51:33.519: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F property volume.is_mounted = true
07:51:35.139: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F property volume.mount_point = ''
07:51:35.156: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F property volume.is_mounted = false
07:51:37.610: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host_scsi_device_lun0 removed
07:51:37.612: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host removed
07:51:37.613: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F removed
07:51:37.631: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0 removed
07:51:37.631: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_usbraw removed
07:51:37.633: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100 removed
07:51:37.635: storage_serial__USB_2_0_091155002041A100_0_0 removed
Start monitoring devicelist:
-------------------------------------------------
07:52:51.142: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100 added
07:52:51.150: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0 added
07:52:51.173: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_usbraw added
07:52:56.139: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host added
07:52:56.141: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host_scsi_device_lun0 added
07:52:56.291: storage_serial__USB_2_0_091155002041A100_0_0 added
07:52:56.301: storage_serial__USB_2_0_091155002041A100_0_0 property info.interfaces = {'org.freedesktop.Hal.Device.Storage.Removable'} (new)
07:52:56.384: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F added
07:53:10.288: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host_scsi_device_lun0 removed
07:53:10.291: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0_scsi_host removed
07:53:10.295: volume_uuid_0021_CB1F removed
07:53:10.302: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_if0 removed
07:53:10.303: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100_usbraw removed
07:53:10.307: usb_device_1976_6025_091155002041A100 removed
07:53:10.313: storage_serial__USB_2_0_091155002041A100_0_0 removed
