Florian Weimer wrote:

How?  As MJ said, it's clearly "practical" to remove the author's
name in places where it would nevertheless be a grievous
restriction.


So you suggest that if someone approaches Debian and asks his name to
be removed, Debian would ignore this request even if it can be
honored, practically speaking?

I think this clause mainly deals with something Debian does anyway, as
a mrere courtesy.


I believe that was the intent. As stated, though, it could be abused; it doesn't restrict the erasing to just authorship credit.

The classic example here is an autobiographical work. The author could ask that all references to herself be removed from a derivative work critical of her.

In software documentation, an original author could require that changelogs or discussion of differences in design or implementation ("Original Author had it this way; the new version does it this other way") be removed.

~ESP

Reply via email to