And the answer is no!
Of course.

The debian founding documents state that debian was created for the benefit
of the user.
(The premise of the whole free software movement is the rights of the user:
the developers rights are clearly best served by the standard proprietary
copyright regime)
We are told that any vote by the user would be, in a word, disrespectful of
the founding documents!

We are then informed that because earlier a general resolution by some
attentive debian package maintainers failed there shall never be another
attempt. Of course this earlier attempt occurred before everyone decided to
update to Jessie from wheezy, but that makes no difference.

How convenient.

The fact of the matter is that the technical committee even ruling on this
matter was an illegal abuse of process. Such wide ranging changes which are
not purely technical in nature Must go to a general resolution to be voted
on by all of the debian package maintainers. The abuse of the technical
committee, which is stacked with former or current redhat and
ubuntu(canonical) employees was intentional. It came just at the time when
the correct person was in the chairmanship.

What has occurred in debian can be described as a coup.
And the trajectory has followed the standard coup path: a beurocratic organ
was used to over ride and subvert a formally democratic body, then once
such was completed the decision made by a few was declared fiat complete,
then harsh critics of the new regime were silenced, and the population
informed that they had two choices: conform or get out.

You can see the same in Egypt today. Same mechanisms. They use bullets
though, rather than bans.

Debian, in its founding documents, like the free software movement it once
belonged to in fact and in spirit, was created for the users. It is not, by
fiat, a doacracy.

When it was created the users of debian and some of the programmers who
created the "upstream" as it is now called were the debian packagers. Since
then a new class that is neither user nor programmer has arising and stuck
itself between us, all the while kicking the actually productive free
software developers out of debian for social crimes.

That is the story, that is what has happened. They have taken our Linux
distribution from us. The Frenchman above me is one of that number.

Reply via email to